Searching Case Laws & Precedent on Legal Query.....!
Analysing the retrieved Case Laws
Scanned Judgements…!
Searching Case Laws & Precedent on Legal Query.....!
Analysing the retrieved Case Laws
Scanned Judgements…!
Courts have emphasized the importance of recording reasons for such orders, and the process must be carried out peacefully without disturbing lawful activities CASTROL LIMITED Vs VIVEK PRATAP SINGH - Delhi, Thakur Dayal Seth VS Debabrata Porel - Calcutta.
Legal and Procedural Insights Main points:
The legal process allows parties to seek appointment of a Local Commissioner through applications under Order 39 Rule 7, but the court's exercise of this power depends on the facts and necessity of the case Thakur Dayal Seth VS Debabrata Porel - Calcutta, Neeta Rawal VS Kishanlal - Rajasthan.
References and Case Law
Analysis and Conclusion:Order 39 Rule 7 of the CPC mandates a discretionary yet structured approach for courts to order local inspections through appointed Commissioners. Such inspections are primarily aimed at factual elucidation and are not obligatory but are valuable tools, provided the court records reasons and ensures the process is peaceful and lawful. The power to order inspections is distinct from the power to seize infringing goods, which may be limited to inventorization. Overall, courts have upheld the importance of these inspections as aids to justice, emphasizing their discretionary nature and procedural safeguards.
In civil litigation in India, courts often rely on various tools to ascertain facts and resolve disputes efficiently. One such tool is the local inspection order under Order 39 Rule 7 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC), 1908. But a common question arises: Local Inspection Order 39 Rule 7 of CPC – is it a mandatory requirement, or does it depend on the court's discretion?
This blog post dives deep into the provisions, judicial interpretations, and practical applications of Order 39 Rule 7 CPC. We'll examine whether such orders are obligatory, drawing from legal documents and case precedents. Note: This is general information and not specific legal advice. Consult a qualified lawyer for your case.
Order 39 of the CPC deals with temporary injunctions and interlocutory orders. Rule 7 specifically empowers courts to order local inspections of the subject matter of the suit. This provision allows the court to appoint a Local Commissioner (often an advocate) to visit the site, inspect the property or premises, take photographs, videograph, and submit a report.
The primary purpose is to elucidate facts in dispute, such as the nature of the property, physical conditions, or any alterations. As noted in legal references, The petitioner in the trial Court filed an application under Order 39, Rule 7 and 8 read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure 1908 in the said suit inter-alia praying for appointment of the Learned Advocate Commissioner to hold the local inspection Krishna Sharma VS Maya Mukherjee - 2023 Supreme(Cal) 445 - 2023 0 Supreme(Cal) 445.
Key features include:- Discretionary power: Courts issue these orders when necessary to understand the factual matrix.- Procedure: The commissioner prepares a report, which becomes part of the court record CASTROL LIMITED Vs VIVEK PRATAP SINGH - Delhi.- Limitations: The role is typically limited to inspection and inventorization, not seizure of goods CASTROL LIMITED Vs VIVEK PRATAP SINGH - Delhi.
The short answer, based on available judicial documents, is no – it is not mandatory but discretionary. Certain provided legal texts do not explicitly mandate a local inspection commission order under Rule 7. Instead, they focus on unrelated issues like tax exemptions, stating, The provided legal documents do not explicitly address the requirement of a local inspection commission order under Rule 7 or its mandatory nature C. T. Kochouseph VS State of Kerala - 2025 0 Supreme(SC) 803.
Courts exercise this power judiciously. For instance:- Order 39 Rule 7 of the CPC empowers courts to order local inspections of the subject matter of a suit. Such inspections are typically ordered to elucidate facts or conditions related to the dispute Thakur Dayal Seth VS Debabrata Porel - CalcuttaNeeta Rawal VS Kishanlal - RajasthanShanti Lal S/o Ramaji Bheel vs Jagannath S/o Ramaji Bheel - Rajasthan.- The provision aims to assist in understanding the factual position and is not obligatory unless the court deems it essential Neeta Rawal VS Kishanlal - RajasthanShanti Lal S/o Ramaji Bheel vs Jagannath S/o Ramaji Bheel - Rajasthan.
In tax-related judgments, no direct reference to Rule 7 appears, reinforcing that procedural inspections like this are not prerequisites for substantive rulings on exemptions C. T. Kochouseph VS State of Kerala - 2025 0 Supreme(SC) 803. Exemptions under sales tax notifications do not extend to purchase tax and do not hinge on inspection orders C. T. Kochouseph VS State of Kerala - 2025 0 Supreme(SC) 803.
Parties can file an application under Order 39 Rule 7 (often read with Rule 8 or Section 151 CPC) for inspection. Examples from cases:- The opposite party no.1 also filed an application for local inspection under Order 39 Rule 7, Civil Procedure Code for holding local inspection of the said property. Commission work was conducted on March 3, 2008 and the report of the commissioner was filed in Court Shyamali Halder VS Shibnath Banerjee - 2012 Supreme(Cal) 258 - 2012 0 Supreme(Cal) 258.- Points for inspection might include noting the nature of premises, locks on doors, etc. Satyanarayan Das VS Prabhunath Keshri - 2008 Supreme(Cal) 464 - 2008 0 Supreme(Cal) 464.
Courts must record reasons for ordering inspections to ensure transparency Kewal Ashokbhai Vasoya Gujarat v. Suarabhakti Goods Pvt. Ltd. Mumbai - Bombay. The process should be peaceful, without disturbing lawful activities CASTROL LIMITED Vs VIVEK PRATAP SINGH - DelhiThakur Dayal Seth VS Debabrata Porel - Calcutta.
Often confused, Order 26 Rule 9 allows commissions for local investigations to elucidate disputes, ascertain damages, or market value. It is clear from the provisions under Order XXVI, Rule 9 of the Code that, the court can appoint a commission for local inspection only when it finds that a local inspection by the commission is required for the purpose of elucidating any matter in dispute Kakkottakath Puthiyapurayil Muhammad Ali S/o C. P. Moideen Haji VS Kakkottakath Puthiyarambath Mahamood S/o Mammath Haji - 2022 Supreme(Ker) 299 - 2022 0 Supreme(Ker) 299.
Key differences:| Provision | Focus | Nature ||-----------|--------|--------|| Order 39 Rule 7 | Temporary injunction suits, fact elucidation via inspection Neeta Rawal VS Kishanlal - Rajasthan | Discretionary for interlocutory relief || Order 26 Rule 9 | Broader local investigation, e.g., damages Thankamani W/o Thankavelu VS Vasanthi W/o Vasu - 2020 Supreme(Ker) 623 - 2020 0 Supreme(Ker) 623 | Also discretionary, court deems necessary |
The opening line of Order 26 Rule 9 CPC would make it clear that the Commission can be appointed for local inspection when the court thinks it necessary Thankamani W/o Thankavelu VS Vasanthi W/o Vasu - 2020 Supreme(Ker) 623 - 2020 0 Supreme(Ker) 623.
Courts have clarified the scope:- In one matter, liberty was granted under Order 39 Rule 2-A CPC, but not directly Rule 7, showing related remedies SMT. MALTI VERMA vs SAHIBIN MANIKPURI - 2024 Supreme(Online)(Chh) 18112 - 2024 Supreme(Online)(Chh) 18112.- Appointment must align with proper rules; misuse under wrong provisions is invalid, e.g., not under Order 7 Rule 39 but Order 26 Rule 9 for site inspections Dhanna Ram VS Jairoop Ram - 2013 Supreme(Raj) 1742 - 2013 0 Supreme(Raj) 1742.- During appeals or consumer cases, local inspections aid fact-finding: However, invoking the provisions under Order 26, Rule 9 of the Code and seeking appointment of an advocate commissioner to make local inspection Midnapore Developers LLP VS Rupali Mana Roy - Consumer.
Tax cases like Kailash Nath and Parle Exports discuss exemptions but not inspections, underscoring that Rule 7 is procedural, not substantive C. T. Kochouseph VS State of Kerala - 2025 0 Supreme(SC) 803.
Typically ordered when:- Physical verification is needed (e.g., property disputes, injunctions).- Oral evidence is insufficient Shanti Lal S/o Ramaji Bheel vs Jagannath S/o Ramaji Bheel - Rajasthan.- To prevent tampering or clarify site conditions Thakur Dayal Seth VS Debabrata Porel - Calcutta.
Exceptions/Limitations:- Not mandatory if facts are clear from pleadings/evidence.- Analysis limited to provided documents; consult full CPC text or rules for specifics C. T. Kochouseph VS State of Kerala - 2025 0 Supreme(SC) 803.- No power to seize unless separately ordered CASTROL LIMITED Vs VIVEK PRATAP SINGH - Delhi.
Order 39 Rule 7 CPC provides a valuable, discretionary tool for local inspections, not a mandatory prerequisite. Courts use it to aid justice by clarifying facts, but only when necessary, with recorded reasons and procedural safeguards. While tax exemption cases don't reference it C. T. Kochouseph VS State of Kerala - 2025 0 Supreme(SC) 803, civil suits frequently invoke it for practical fact-finding Krishna Sharma VS Maya Mukherjee - 2023 Supreme(Cal) 445 - 2023 0 Supreme(Cal) 445Shyamali Halder VS Shibnath Banerjee - 2012 Supreme(Cal) 258 - 2012 0 Supreme(Cal) 258.
Key Takeaways:- Discretionary, not mandatory – depends on case necessity Neeta Rawal VS Kishanlal - Rajasthan.- Appoint Local Commissioner for reports, photos, etc. CASTROL LIMITED Vs VIVEK PRATAP SINGH - Delhi.- Distinguish from Order 26 Rule 9 for broader probes Kakkottakath Puthiyapurayil Muhammad Ali S/o C. P. Moideen Haji VS Kakkottakath Puthiyarambath Mahamood S/o Mammath Haji - 2022 Supreme(Ker) 299 - 2022 0 Supreme(Ker) 299.- Always record reasons for transparency Kewal Ashokbhai Vasoya Gujarat v. Suarabhakti Goods Pvt. Ltd. Mumbai - Bombay.
For tailored advice, consult a legal expert. Stay informed on CPC updates to strengthen your civil litigation strategy.
#Order39Rule7, #CPCLocalInspection, #IndianCivilLaw
The proceedings of the Local Commission shall be photographed and videographed at the expense of the appellant. The Local Commissioner shall place the said evidence on record with his report. ... Service of notice on the respondent, in the present appeal, would be effected only after the commission is executed and the report of the Local Commissioner is placed on record. ... The Local Co....
However, liberty is granted to the petitioner to exhaust remedy available to him under Order39 Rule 2-A of CPC. Sd/- (Narendra Kuamr Vyas) JUDGE Raju ... Considering the fact that since the petitioner has remedy of initiating proceeding under Order 39 Rule 2-A of Code of Civil Procedure as interim order in the First Appeal has been passed which is alleged to have been violated, the contempt petition is disposed of. ... On the other hand, l....
The requirement of recording reasons is no mere formality. It is mandatory. ... (c) The legal principle "ex debito justiciae" underlies the practice to be followed by courts in granting injunctions, whether interim or ad - interim. ... 11. ... That rule with its two provisos reads thus : ... "4. ... This duty of disclosure includes matters of which the applicant would have been aware had he made reasonable enquiries. .......
The subject matter of challenge in this case is against the rejection of a prayer for local inspection under Order 39 Rule 7 of the Code of Civil Procedure. 2. According to Mr. ... Since real state of affairs, existing with respect to the ‘C’ schedule land intervening ‘A’ and ‘B’ schedule property, there arose the necessity to propose for local inspection under Order 39 Rule#HL....
39 Rule 7 of the Code of Civil Procedure. ... The petitioner in the trial Court filed an application under Order 39, Rule 7 and 8 read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure 1908 in the said suit inter-alia praying for appointment of the Learned Advocate Commissioner to hold the local inspection as per the schedule maintaining proposal ... Rule 7#HL_E....
, remuneration or other valuable consideration, and includes –(i) A local authority, company, Hindu undivided family, firm or other association of persons which carries on such business; (ii) a causal trader, (iii) a factor, a broker, a commission ... In para 71 of his opinion, the learned Judge states: “It is well settled that reasonable construction should be followed and literal construction may be avoided if that defeats the manifest ob....
However, invoking the provisions under Order 26, Rule 9 of the Code and seeking appointment of an advocate commissioner to make local inspection along with an civil engineer and submit a report etc., as ordered by the Consumer District Forum and as approved by the State Commission under the impugned ... During pendency of the case the complainants filed an application for holding a local inspect....
According to the provisions of the Specific Relief Act also, there is no requirement for any inspection of the suit property. Hence, there was no requirement for the appointment of a Commissioner when the sale deed itself was fraudulently registered by the respondents. ... Prior to passing of the aforesaid injunction order, respondents had filed an application dated August 17, 2022 (Annexure. 6) under Order 39 Rule #HL_STA....
Rule (7) i.e. ... The provisions of Order 26 Rule (9) of CPC, as well, confers discretionary power on a Court to issue commission for local investigation as is evident from the expression “the Court may issue a commission” leaving no room of doubt that the provision too is enabling in nature to ... Order 26 Rule (9) of CPC allows a Court to issue a commission....
Perusal of above rule clearly reflects that for the purpose of elucidating any matter in dispute, the Court may issue a Commission to make an investigation and give a report. ... The petitioners (plaintiffs) seek quashing of the impugned order dated 05.03.2025 (Annexure 5), vide which their application under Order 26 Rule 9 CPC, seeking appointment of a Local Commissioner, was rejected. ... 7. ... , the ....
It is clear from the provisions under Order XXVI, Rule 9 of the Code that, the court can appoint a commission for local inspection only when it finds that a local inspection by the commission is required for the purpose of elucidating any matter in dispute or for any other purpose mentioned in the said Rule. Therefore, in a case in which the tenant has not discharged the initial burden of proof under the first proviso to Section 11(3) of the Act, by disclosing the identity of....
8. The opening line of Order 26 Rule 9 CPC would make it clear that the Commission can be appointed for local inspection when the court thinks it necessary. Therefore, the Commission Report and plan have great significance in resolving the factual dispute in a civil case and hence, Order 26 Rule 9 CPC enables the Court to direct the Commissioner to make such investigation as may be necessary and to report the matter to the court. The very wording is local investigation and th....
The appointment of Commissioner in the instant matter is not as per Order 26 Code of Civil Procedure. Rule 67 of the Rules of 1986 pertains to issuing a commission for making local investigation under Order 26, Rule 9 Code-3- of Civil Procedure and not for appointment of a person for making site inspection under Order 7, Rule 39 Code of Civil Procedure. The trial court well within its jurisdiction sought inspection of the site to have a better conclusion on the application un....
3. THE opposite party no.1 also filed an application for local inspection under Order 39 Rule 7, Civil Procedure Code for holding local inspection of the said property. Commission work was conducted on March 3, 2008 and the report of the commissioner was filed in Court. THE application was allowed and an Advocate Commissioner appointed.
8. In the plaintiffs' application for local inspection under Order 39 Rule 7 read with section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, the following points were set out for the purpose of holding inspection:- a) To note the nature and character of the suit premises as mentioned in the plaint. b) To note how many locks are there on the door/shutter of the suit premises.
An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers
Please visit our Training & Support
Center or Contact Us for assistance
Scan Me!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :
Back to top
