Searching Case Laws & Precedent on Legal Query.....!
Analysing the retrieved Case Laws
Scanned Judgements…!
Searching Case Laws & Precedent on Legal Query.....!
Analysing the retrieved Case Laws
Scanned Judgements…!
Advanced prostheses, such as myoelectric or bionic types, can cost significantly more, with estimates reaching RM4,494,202.20 over 36 years (["
L/KPL NARAAYANAN NAIR SUBRAMANIAM vs KERAJAAN MALAYSIA & ORS - High Court Malaya Ipoh
"]).Repair and Maintenance Costs
Over a lifetime, this necessitates multiple replacements, typically around 3-6 times, depending on the lifespan of the prosthesis.
Compensation Awards and Disputes
The High Court has been urged to enhance compensation, with some awards reaching Rs.10 lakhs or more, to adequately cover purchase and maintenance costs over the individual's lifetime (["2023 0 Supreme(Del) 6016"], ["2023 0 Supreme(Del) 3207"]).
Additional Considerations
L/KPL NARAAYANAN NAIR SUBRAMANIAM vs KERAJAAN MALAYSIA & ORS - High Court Malaya Ipoh
"]).The cost of prosthetic limbs varies based on type, complexity, and technological features, generally ranging from Rs. 2,60,000/- to over RM500,000 for high-end models. The lifespan is typically 5-6 years, requiring periodic repairs costing Rs.15,000/- to Rs.20,000/- per repair. Courts acknowledge the substantial expenses involved and have awarded compensation accordingly, but there is ongoing debate over whether these awards sufficiently cover the actual costs, especially for advanced prosthetics. Future medical and maintenance expenses should be factored into compensation, with some judgments advocating for higher amounts to ensure ongoing affordability and functionality for the claimant.
Imagine surviving a severe accident that results in the amputation of a limb. Beyond the physical and emotional trauma, the road to recovery often involves significant expenses for prosthetic limbs, therapy, and ongoing maintenance. A common question arises: Prosthetic Limb Costs in —can these be recovered as part of compensation? In personal injury cases, particularly in Malaysia, courts generally allow such claims, but with key caveats involving medical evidence and third-party payments.
This article explores the legal framework, court precedents, and practical tips for claimants seeking damages for prosthetic limbs. While this provides general insights based on established cases, it is not legal advice—consult a qualified lawyer for your specific situation.
Under Malaysian law, the cost of prosthetic limbs can typically be awarded as damages in , provided they are supported by proper medical evidence demonstrating necessity and actual expenditure. However, plays a crucial role: payments made by third parties, such as (social security) or insurance, must be deducted from the to avoid .
As outlined in key judgments, In assessing damages... shall not be taken into account: (a) any sum paid or payable in respect of the personal injury under any contract of assurance or insurance...
. This principle ensures claimants are compensated only for their
.
.
to RM1,409,492 for comprehensive needs
.
The cornerstone is , section 28A, which states that damages should not include sums from insurance or social security schemes. In one case, the court held that expenses paid by insurers or do not form part of recoverable damages
. If a claimant received partial payment, only the balance is claimable.
Courts rigorously scrutinize evidence. A quotation of RM133,230.00 for a complete prosthetic leg was accepted alongside an expert report, leading to an award of RM80,000
. Similarly, detailed reports justified RM1,409,492
. Unsupported or inflated claims risk reduction or rejection.
In comparative Indian cases under the , courts emphasized evidence like quotations (e.g., Rs.3,13,400 for an artificial leg 2019 0 Supreme(Del) 55) and disability certificates (80% permanent disability 2019 0 Supreme(Del) 240). Prosthetics must suit the claimant's daily needs, not the most advanced unless justified
.
Malaysian courts have issued varied awards based on injury severity:- RM80,000: For a prosthetic leg, supported by quotation and expert report—Taking into consideration of all above, I am awarding the plaintiff RM80,000.00 for this injury
.- RM1,409,492: Comprehensive award including prosthetics, per paras 58-63
.- RM42,188 to RM512,000: For models like 3R60/3R80, factoring multiple replacements
WEE YOU KHEONG vs HASBULLAH AZHAR & ORS
.Indian precedents mirror this, with awards like Rs.54,71,293 total compensation post-amputation, including prosthetics (cost Rs.2,60,000, life 5-6 years, repairs Rs.15,000-20,000) 2023 0 Supreme(P&H) 2761. Another granted Rs.7,50,000 for prosthetics alone, assuming one lifetime replacement 2025 0 Supreme(AP) 446. High awards like Rs.72,85,000 (reassessed to Rs.47,52,574) factored disability impact 2019 0 Supreme(P&H) 2296.
Additional costs often include:- Therapy and training: an in-patient intensive therapy programme for a month each time P2 receives a new type of prosthetics
.- Maintenance: Repairs every 6-12 months 2023 0 Supreme(P&H) 2761.
.
.
.
In one Indian case, unchallenged evidence from a company witness upheld prosthetic costs, as respondents provided no counter-evidence 2019 0 Supreme(P&H) 2296.
.
.
Prosthetic limb costs are generally recoverable in in Malaysia, bolstered by robust medical evidence and adjusted for third-party payments under . Courts aim to restore claimants as closely as possible to their pre-injury state, awarding from modest to substantial sums based on necessity.
Key Takeaways:- Prioritize evidence: Reports and quotations are essential.- Deduct insurance/: Compliance avoids claim reductions.- Plan for future: Include replacements and therapy.
For personalized guidance, seek professional legal advice. Stay informed, document everything, and fight for fair compensation.
(Word count: 1028. References are illustrative of general principles from cited documents.)
#ProstheticDamages #InjuryClaims #PersonalInjuryLaw
The High Court has awarded a compensation of Rs.5,20,000/- for the prosthetic limb and Rs.50,000/- towards repair and maintenance of the same. The Appellant submits that the cost of the prosthetic limb itself is Rs.2,60,000/- and the life of the prosthetic limb is only 5-6 years. ... The limited challenge of the appellant to the Impugned Award is against the direction of the learned Tribunal directing that the co....
In view of the above laid dicta, in my view, the compensation awarded to the claimant towards cost of prosthetic limb deserves to be enhanced. It is accordingly enhanced to Rs.10 lacs, towards the cost of the prosthetic limb. ... The High Court has awarded a compensation of Rs.5,20,000/- for the prosthetic limb and Rs.50,000/- towards repair and maintenance of the same. The Appellant submits that the #HL_....
With the proposed multiplier of 36 years, the estimated lifetime cost for the myoelectric-bionic prosthesis is approximately RM4,494,202.20. This cost includes the purchase, periodic replacements, and training required for the use of the advanced prosthetic components. ... The detailed breakdown provided by the plaintiff's prosthetic expert, Puan Nadzirah, estimated a lifetime cost of RM5,580,301.07 over ....
There is no evidence on record nor was there an affirmative response by the appellant's counsel regarding the actual purchase of the prosthetic leg by the appellant. In fact, it was submitted that he was using a prosthetic leg provided by a charitable organisation in Jaipur, free of cost. ... The appellant has still not purchased a prosthetic leg, and therefore, when there is no question as to purchase of the pro....
The Appellant submits that the cost of the prosthetic limb itself is Rs. 2,60,000/- and the life of the prosthetic limb is only 5-6 years. The prosthetic limb also requires repair and maintenance after every 6 months to 1 year, and each repair costs between Rs.15,000 to Rs.20,000/-. ... The cost of limb is Rs.4,00,000/- and life of the limb is 5-6 years. Going by the age of appellant, he shall have to pur....
Cost Of Prosthetic Leg [43] This Court referred to item 27.51 in the Plaintiff's Statement of Claim for RM42,188.00 being the cost of a prosthetic leg. ... The 3R60 cost RM80,000.00 per unit compared to the 3R80 which cost RM42,188.00. ... total cost would be RM512,000.00. ... The Plaintiff found the prosthetic uncomfortable to ambulate that had sto....
Cost Of Prosthetic Leg [43] This Court referred to item 27.51 in the Plaintiff's Statement of Claim for RM42,188.00 being the cost of a prosthetic leg. ... the cost of service items, the total cost would be RM512,000.00. ... The 3R60 cost RM80,000.00 per unit compared to the 3R80 which cost RM42,188.00. ... The Plaintiff found the prosthetic....
The Appellant submits that the cost of the prosthetic limb itself is Rs. 2,60,000/- and the life of the prosthetic limb is only 5-6 years. The prosthetic limb also requires repair and maintenance after every 6 months to 1 year, and each repair costs between Rs. 15,000 to Rs. 20,000/-. ... It was submitted that the cost of the artificial limb is Rs. 2,60,000/- and the life of the limb is 5-6 years. The lim....
[20] The Plaintiffs further claim the sum of RM3,584,717.78 for the cost of a prosthesis and its replacement, encompassing the cost of the prosthetic leg, replacements, long-term care, and a quotation for the Orion 3 prosthesis, as per the Prosthetic Report from Endolite Asia Sdn Bhd, ... A prosthetic limb should be fitted for his amputated right leg." ... Cost Of Care [30] The assessm....
The Appellant submits that the cost of the prosthetic limb itself is Rs. 2,60,000/-and the life of the prosthetic limb is only 5-6 years. The prosthetic limb also requires repair and maintenance after every 6 months to 1 year, and each repair costs between Rs. 15,000 to Rs. 20,000/-. ... cost of prosthesis, totaling to Rs.71,00,000/-. ... COMPENSATION FOR THE PURCHASE AND MAINTENANCE OF THE PRO....
24. In this case, there is no mention of the frequency at which the prosthetic limb has to be changed. However, it is a matter of prudence that the prosthetic limb of the Claimant would have to be changed at least once in his lifetime. Therefore, factoring inflation vis-a-vis the cost incurred under Exs.A.16 and 17, this Court is inclined to grant an amount of Rs.7,50,000/- towards prosthetic limbs alone. The future medical expenses are assessed @ Rs.50,000/-. 25. Attendant C....
22. The High Court has awarded a compensation of Rs. 5,20,000/- for the prosthetic limb and Rs. 50,000/- towards repair and maintenance of the same. The Appellant submits that the cost of the prosthetic limb itself is Rs. 2,60,000/- and the life of the prosthetic limb is only 5-6 years.
The issue is that some evidence has been brought on record on behalf of the claimant and a representative of the company has been produced as a witness (PW5), who has been cross-examined by the respondents but he has withstood the test of cross-examination. There is no evidence on behalf of respondents at all on the point as to what should be the cost of the Prosthetic Limb.
Due to accident, he received 80% permanent disability as per the Disability Certificate Ex.PW5/1, which is issued by Orthopedics Handicapped Board of Dr. RML Hospital, New Delhi. FIR No.42/13 was registered under Section 279/388 at P.S. Anand Parbat, Delhi. The estimate cost of artificial leg is Rs.3,13,400 Ex.PW1/5, which was given by the Endolite Prosthetic & Orthotic Centre at Naraina, New Delhi.
The estimate cost of artificial leg is Rs.3,13,400 Ex.PW1/5, which was given by the Endolite Prosthetic & Orthotic Centre at Naraina, New Delhi. The claimant has examined Kapil Kaushik as PW2, who proved the Quotation Ex.PW1/4 of Endolite Trans Femoral System in respect of the claimant-Vinod Kumar. FIR No.42/13 was registered under Section 279/388 at P.S. Anand Parbat, Delhi. 14. Due to accident, he received 80% permanent disability as per the Disability Certificate Ex.PW5/1,....
An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers
Please visit our Training & Support
Center or Contact Us for assistance
Scan Me!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :
Back to top
