Searching Case Laws & Precedent on Legal Query..!
Scanned Judgements…!
Searching Case Laws & Precedent on Legal Query..!
Scanned Judgements…!
Deadlock Resolution through Court Intervention - When a court-appointed committee faces a deadlock due to an even number of members voting equally, the courts may direct the filing of an application before the NCLT for directions on the way forward, including extension of the CIRP or appointment of an administrator. The committee can seek judicial guidance to resolve deadlocks that cannot be remedied internally ["Mr. Vijay Pitamber Lulla (RP of M/s. Syska E-Retails LLP) VS Canara Bank - National Company Law Tribunal"].
Use of Casting Vote by Presiding Officers - In cases where voting results in a tie, the presiding officer or chairperson may cast a casting vote to break the deadlock, as seen in the context of Panchayat elections or committee meetings. If votes are equally divided, the chairman's casting vote determines the outcome, and if necessary, results may be decided by drawing lots ["Balachandran P. v. V. Registrar of Co-Operative Societies and Others - Kerala"], ["Suman Kachru Garje VS State of Maharashtra - Bombay"].
Court-Ordered Appointment of Administrators - When deadlock persists and cannot be resolved internally, courts may appoint administrators or outside bodies to manage the committee or society, especially in cases of disputes or boycott of meetings. This ensures continuity and decision-making authority in the face of deadlock ["Vijay Lakhi vs Minister of Co-operation - Bombay"].
Procedural Adjustments and Quorum Requirements - Some cases suggest adjusting quorum or election procedures to prevent deadlock, such as fixing the number of committee members, allowing co-option, or increasing the number of elected members to ensure functional decision-making ["Ravindran K. and Others v. State of Kerala and Others - Kerala"], ["SIMEON FERNANDO v. GOONESEKERA"].
Legal Provisions for Deadlock Situations - Various legal provisions and court rulings emphasize that a present deadlock must be incapable of solution for a winding-up order to be justified. Often, courts prefer resolving deadlocks through internal procedures, voting rules, or court directions rather than immediate winding-up ["CEYLON TEXTILES LTD. v. CHITTAMPALAM GARDINER"], ["NUGAWELA v. RATWATTE et al."].
Analysis and Conclusion:The primary solution for deadlock in an even-member court-appointed committee involves judicial intervention, either through directions to file applications before NCLT or through appointing administrators to break deadlocks ["Mr. Vijay Pitamber Lulla (RP of M/s. Syska E-Retails LLP) VS Canara Bank - National Company Law Tribunal"]. Additionally, procedural mechanisms such as casting votes by presiding officers, drawing lots, or adjusting quorum can be employed internally to resolve voting deadlocks ["Balachandran P. v. V. Registrar of Co-Operative Societies and Others - Kerala"], ["Suman Kachru Garje VS State of Maharashtra - Bombay"]. Courts generally prefer resolving deadlocks through internal procedures or judicial directions rather than winding-up, provided the deadlock is remediable and not perpetual ["CEYLON TEXTILES LTD. v. CHITTAMPALAM GARDINER"].
Imagine a court-appointed committee, tasked with critical decisions, grinding to a halt because of an even number of members and a tied vote. Deadlocks like this can paralyze proceedings, raising the question: What is the solution if a court-appointed committee consists of even number members facing deadlock in votes?
In legal contexts, especially in India, statutes and case law provide clear mechanisms to address such impasses. This post explores these solutions, drawing primarily from Court-Martial procedures while integrating principles from panchayat committees and other judicial bodies. While this offers general insights, consult a legal professional for advice specific to your situation.
Court-appointed committees or specialized courts like Court-Martials often have provisions to prevent indefinite stalemates. The key solution revolves around the presiding officer's (President's) casting vote.
In cases of vote equality, the President's casting vote breaks the deadlock—except for findings of guilt, where a tie mandates acquittal. This is outlined in relevant statutes: In the case of an equality of votes on the finding, the Court shall acquit the accused [
#CourtCommitteeDeadlock, #CastingVote, #LegalTieResolution
among the members of the Committee of Creditors, the Committee of Creditors unanimously approves that the Resolution Professional shall file an appropriate application before the Hon’ble NCLT seeking directions on the way forward, including extension of the CIRP with issuance of a fresh Form G or initiation ... Accordingly, the Applicant constituted the Committee of Creditor which consists of Canara Bank, State Bank of India and UV Assets Reconstruction Company Limited, Financial Creditors. The first Me....
The strengh of the Executive Committee depends upon the total number of elected members of the Taluka Panchayat and accordingly when the total number of elected members of the Panchayat is 23 the Executive Committee must consist of seven members. ... When there was a tie on account of equality of votes cast on the proposal with regard to the election of the members of the Executive Committee the President who was h....
(e) When committee members boycott meetings, refuse to sign necessary documents, or create deadlock preventing collective decisions. ... Even in cases falling under clause (f) of sub-section (1), where rival groups both claim to be elected and the Co- operative Court decides which one is valid, the temporary body must hand over to that legally elected committee once the Court gives its decision. ... Hence, by the said Government Resolution dated 3 January 2024, the S....
On a challenge to the decision the learned Single Judge of the Rajasthan High Court held that in counting the whole number of members, nominated members have also to be taken into account even though they had no right to vote. ... Before the Apex Court, it was argued that the High Court erred in holding that the words whole number of members must be construed as whole number of elected members, wh....
Only if it was impossible to arrive at a solution by such means would a Court pronounce a winding up order. ... The mere fact that there may be a deadlock in the future is insufficient. There must be a present deadlock incapable of solution. In the present case the deadlock, if it did in fact exist, was remediable. ... On the same day Thampapillai was appointed managing director and one Gnanakoon was appointed secretary with effect from 7th Sep....
Even assuming it to be true that eight members are facing disqualification, the Registrar of Co - operative Societies records that ten members are still available. ... elected committee requires to be removed and an Administrative Committee appointed in its place. ... total number of members of that committee. ... The semantic definition of quorum is the minimum number of members....
The Buddhist Temporalities Ordinance, No. 8 of 1905, section 5, provided that the Atamasthana Committee shall consist of six members, and by section 17 the trustee was appointed by this committee. ... But that is not the phraseology of section 9 which says that the trustee shall be the committee, and then goes on to provide that "the said committee shall elect one of their number as chairman, its quorum shall be two and in the case of an oequal division of #HL_....
It is further stated therein the total number of votes polled was 411 and counting of votes was started at 2.30 p.m on the same day. Panel 'A' got 188 votes and Panel 'B' got 219 votes. ... That apart, it was held that a comprehensive civil suit would delay the solution, a solution to resolve the impasse, referred hereinbefore and compelling the parties to resort to such a remedy would create a deadlock for conducting 'Kettukazhcha' festival during t....
An Administrator is appointed by the State Government while members are nominated by the Standing Committee which itself consists of the Zilla Parishad members most of whom are elected. ... Dudhat, however, contended that not nominations but re-elections was a more democratic answer or solution to the stalemate that may result if insufficient number of members are elected to the panchayat. To an extent, there is some substance in this submission. .......
The village Committee of Kanuwana consists of thirty-one members. The respondent, G. Don Gilbert Goonesekera, and one Norbert Sri Vardhana are both duly elected members. On nomination day one P. ... (b) The Presiding Officer shall, thereupon, take a count and declare the candidate who obtains the larger number of votes the duly elected Chairman of the committee. ... APPLICATION for a writ of quo warranto to have the election of the Village Comm....
In the present case, the Public Works Committee comprises of five Members. Thus, it can be said that the body which has power to elect its Out of five Members, three Members have no confidence in the chairman and if this situation is allowed to continue till expiry of the term of the Committee, there will be constant deadlock and the Committee will not be able to function effectively and carry out the duties assigned to it. Office bearers by simple majority has also the inherent or implied power to remove them by passing Motion of no confidence by simple majority, unless th....
The relevant Rules, therefore, clearly contravene the constitutional mandates of Article 233(1) and (2) of the Constitution and are, therefore, illegal." (k) The Supreme Court also held that the selection of District Judges was invalid. But under the Rules, the High Court can either endorse the recommendations of the Committee or create a deadlock. Under Article 233(2) of the Constitution, the Governor can only appoint advocates recommended by the High Court to the said service.
.(f) if any mark is made by which the member may afterwards be identified; or .(e) if some mark other than the one authorized, is recorded to the name of a candidate; (c) if the mark indicating the vote thereon is placed in such manner as make it doubtful to which candidate the vote has been given. .(d) if the votes are recorded in favour of more candidates than the number of members to be elected in the case of election of member of statutory committee; or
This was pointed out to indicate that 6 even if the Panchayat consists of less number of members, its functioning is not effective. The learned counsel had sought to draw the attention to section 44 to point out that during any vacancy in the Panchayat, the continuing members may act as if no vacancy had occurred. It does not mean that such vacancy should not be filled in. The very section itself would also clearly indicate that the expression “During any vacancy in the Panchayat” would mean a vacancy existing.
Under the Act, the Committee consists of elected members whereas the board of trustees is not elected; they are only nominated and therefore, the Committee consists of even non-elected members. The making of the elected body subject to the nominated body is contrary to the Act. Similarly, Clause 19 also makes the Committee subject to the powers of the trustees; that is, the powers of the Committee is made subject to the powers of the Board of Trustees.
An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers
Please visit our Training & Support
Center or Contact Us for assistance
Scan Me!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :
Back to top
