The High Court of Judicature at Madras has granted an interim injunction against a Bengaluru-based hardware business, effectively barring the proprietor of AJ and Sons from using the trademark "Nakoda" or any deceptively similar variants in the sale and distribution of metal fasteners and hardware. The court’s decision follows a legal challenge initiated by Kailash Chand Surana, the sole proprietor of Kalptaru Enterprise , who alleged that the unauthorized adoption of the mark constituted both trademark infringement and an attempt to pass off goods, thereby diluting his established reputation in the metal hardware sector.

Justice P.B. Balaji, presiding over the matter, emphasized the legal necessity of preventing unauthorized commercial exploitation of marks, particularly when the user lacks a legitimate connection to the terminology adopted. The court scrutinized the conduct of the respondent, who had begun using the "Nakoda" brand for hardware products in 2021 , despite the applicant having established a consistent presence in the market since 2017 .

Assessing the Validity of Trademark Adoption

A central point of the court’s reasoning involved the nature of the "Nakoda" mark, which is widely recognized as the name of a Jain deity. The respondent argued that "Nakoda" is a descriptive term of religious significance and therefore not subject to exclusive proprietary claims by any individual trader. However, Justice Balaji rejected this defense, highlighting that the respondent had failed to demonstrate a bona fide connection to the name. The court noted that because the respondent does not belong to the Jain community, the selection of the name for commercial use appeared to be a calculated move to capitalize on the existing goodwill associated with the applicant’s established brand, rather than an honest choice of a descriptive name.

In his order, Justice Balaji observed, "Firstly, I see the user of the mark to be dishonest and not bonafide for the simple reason that though NAKODA is a descriptive word referring to a Jain god, the respondent does not even belong to the Jain community to claim to have adopted the mark NAKODA honestly."

The court further addressed the contention regarding the alleged lack of exclusive rights over the name. By filing for its own registration of the mark, the respondent effectively invalidated its own argument that the name was too descriptive or generic to be trademarked. The court found that the respondent’s subsequent attempts to challenge the applicant's registration, only after receiving a cease-and-desist notice , demonstrated a clear intent to obscure the applicant’s prior usage and market established since 2017 .

Market Presence and Consumer Protection

The evidence submitted by the applicant painted a picture of a robust, pan-India business operation. Kalptaru Enterprise provided documentation of its 14 active trademark registrations, including marks such as NAKODA PROPLUS and PRO NAKODA. The applicant’s growth, marked by a significant annual turnover, served as evidence that the brand had gained substantial recognition among consumers of metal hardware.

Justice Balaji weighed the potential for consumer confusion as a critical factor in his decision. Given that both parties were operating in the same industrial sector, selling nearly identical products, the use of a nearly identical brand name—specifically the use of "SNE" (derived from the applicant’s original firm name, Sree Nakoda Enterprises )—posed a tangible risk of deception. The court maintained that such actions threaten to mislead the public, who would reasonably assume the goods originated from the long-standing applicant rather than a newer entrant.

Addressing the urgency of the legal intervention, the court relied on established precedents regarding the necessity of immediate relief in intellectual property disputes. The court clarified that the preservation of a plaintiff’s reputation and the prevention of economic loss due to market confusion are paramount. Regarding the timing of the intervention, the court cited, "In cases of infringement, either of Trade Mark or Copy right, normally an injunction must follow and even mere delay in bringing action is not sufficient to defeat the grant of injunction."

Strengthening Intellectual Property Standards

The ruling underscores a strict judicial approach toward entities that attempt to ride on the established reputation of prior market participants. By finding that the respondent’s actions were " malafide and clearly with an intention to ride on the reputation and goodwill acquired by the applicant," the court signaled that competitors cannot shield themselves behind generic defenses when evidence points toward deliberate imitation.

The court found that the balance of convenience heavily favored the applicant. Not only had the applicant demonstrated prior usage, but it had also consistently maintained its presence in the market, whereas the respondent failed to provide substantive documentation to support its claimed usage of the mark from 2021 . The potential for " irreparable loss " was deemed a significant factor, as the ongoing use of the infringing mark threatened to tarnish the professional image that Kalptaru Enterprise had built over the better part of two decades.

This interim order effectively restricts AJ and Sons from manufacturing, marketing, or advertising its metal hardware goods under the impugned marks or any variation that would confuse the average customer. The matter now moves forward in the High Court , with the current directive serving as a temporary protection against further infringement until the final disposal of the commercial suit . The decision serves as a notable reminder to market participants that intellectual property rights in India are protected with rigor, and that dishonest adoption of names—even those with cultural significance—will face immediate judicial scrutiny when used for competitive advantage.