The of Judicature for Rajasthan at Jodhpur has ordered the registration of a to investigate a significant discrepancy between rates and the actual market value of real estate in Jalore. The decision followed the court's observation that property registration values in the region were appearing at rates as low as 1/70th of their actual market worth. Justice Baljinder Singh Sandhu, while presiding over a series of connected , highlighted that this massive disparity not only causes substantial losses to the state exchequer but also creates a landscape where unaccounted money can circulate through property transactions.
The issue surfaced during the hearing of several bail petitions, including those of individuals involved in property transactions where the declared value in was significantly lower than the actual consideration paid. In one particular case documented by the court, an agreement revealed the actual value of a land parcel to be ₹5,51,00,000, yet the was registered for a mere ₹8,00,000. This massive deviation led the court to conclude that the current DLC rates, which are intended to serve as a benchmark for collection, are failing to curb the usage of unaccounted cash, commonly referred to as black money, in the real estate sector.
The DLC is fundamentally constituted to establish minimum market values for immovable properties after conducting thorough surveys of prevailing market trends. The primary legislative intent behind these rates is to ensure that is collected on a fair basis, preventing the evasion of revenue and curbing the use of undisclosed funds. While the court acknowledged that minor fluctuations between and market values are often unavoidable due to rapid economic changes, it described the 70-fold disparity in Jalore as an exorbitant gap that demands urgent administrative attention. By maintaining rates that do not align with market realities, the state inadvertently creates a system where buyers and sellers are encouraged to undervalue properties, thus facilitating the use of cash transactions representing the difference between the declared price and the market price.
Systemic Revenue Failures and Judicial Intervention
The court’s scrutiny of this issue dates back to , when it first observed the striking difference between the reported values and the actual market prices during a bail hearing. At that time, the court had directed the Principal Secretary of the to investigate the matter and take remedial measures to prevent further loss to the state. Despite this directive, follow-up observations indicated that no significant action had been taken by the government to rectify the anomalous DLC rates.
During the latest proceedings, Justice Sandhu expressed his concern that while his jurisdiction was primarily focused on the pending bail applications of the petitioners, the issue regarding the accuracy of property valuation transcended the specific facts of any criminal case. The court noted that the systemic undervaluation affects the entirety of the state’s property market in Jalore and poses a threat to broader . Because the matter involves complex questions of revenue and administrative policy that exceed the narrow scope of criminal bail proceedings, the court determined that it would be inappropriate to pursue the matter further within those specific cases.
Instead, the court opted to convert the issue into a . By taking this step, the ensures that the challenge to the current valuation mechanism will be handled by an appropriate bench tasked with addressing the systemic failures of the . This institutional shift allows for a more comprehensive review of how DLC rates are determined, audited, and updated to reflect economic changes, ensuring that the state exchequer is adequately protected from recurring losses.
Impact on State Revenue and Transparency
The ongoing failure to align DLC rates with market reality has broad consequences for the transparency of the real estate sector. When is levied on rates that are 70 times lower than the market value, the collected becomes a nominal figure, depriving the state of essential funds required for regional development. Furthermore, the reliance on such outdated benchmarks validates the use of "on-money" or unaccounted cash, as the disparity provides a convenient legal loophole for parties to register deeds at lower values.
The court's decision to place the matter before the Chief Justice for further assignment reflects the urgency of the situation. The expectation is that this new petition will trigger a state-wide or district-specific review of the DLC valuation process, potentially leading to more frequent revisions and more robust market surveys conducted by the . The court has maintained that the integrity of the registration process depends upon the government’s ability to set realistic benchmarks that discourage the under-declaration of property prices.
As the matter now moves forward under the purview of a fresh , the is expected to face rigorous scrutiny regarding its failure to comply with the initial directives issued in . The outcome of these upcoming proceedings will likely serve as a precedent for how the state government must handle the periodic adjustment of property rates, moving away from stagnant lists toward a responsive and accurate system that captures the real economic activity within the district. The disposal of the current bail applications allows the petitioners to seek fresh relief, but the larger administrative questions now sit squarely with the newly formed bench, which will determine the corrective path for the state’s property valuation infrastructure.
land registration - black money