AI Overview...
-
Loss of Income in Arbitration - Various cases highlight that claims for loss of income or profit are recognized and can be awarded as damages in arbitration proceedings. For example, in URMIL MALIK VS NATIONAL SAVINGS ORGANISATION - Delhi, wrongful termination led to a claim for loss of income amounting to lakhs of rupees annually, which was covered under arbitration clauses. Similarly, in Union of India Department of Tele Communications Now BSNL, represented by its AGM Office of Principle G. M. VS Tribhovandas Vendravan and Brothers Rep. by Kanaklal Abaichand - Madras, damages and loss of rental income due to a fire were awarded, with the court confirming the award.
-
Arbitrability of Income Loss Claims - Several sources affirm that claims for loss of income or profit are admissible under arbitration, provided they are supported by evidence and fall within the scope of the arbitration agreement (Union of India, Acting through Sr. Divisional Commercial Manager VS Sun Media Services - Bombay, Indo Pacific Software and Entertainment Ltd. vs Kone Elevators India Pvt. Ltd. - Madras). However, some cases emphasize that such claims must be explicitly covered by the arbitration clause; otherwise, they may be challenged or dismissed (Union of India VS Sun Media Services - Bombay).
-
Calculation and Validation of Losses - The determination of loss of income involves assessing damages such as rental income loss, business income, or profits lost due to breach or wrongful acts. For instance, in Union of India Department of Tele Communications Now BSNL, represented by its AGM Office of Principle G. M. VS Tribhovandas Vendravan and Brothers Rep. by Kanaklal Abaichand - Madras, the loss was quantified as Rs.8,45,000 for rental income during a specific period. Arbitrators and courts scrutinize the evidence and the calculation methods used to ensure fairness and accuracy.
-
Challenges and Limitations - Certain cases note that claims for loss of profit or income can be contested if unsupported by evidence or if the arbitration clause does not explicitly permit such claims (Union of India, Acting through Sr. Divisional Commercial Manager VS Sun Media Services - Bombay, Ram Kala VS Delhi Development Authority - Delhi). Additionally, procedural issues like the appointment of arbitrators or jurisdiction may impact the adjudication of income loss claims (First Global Stock Broking Pvt Ltd VS Tarun Gupta - Delhi, First Global Stock Broking Pvt. Ltd. vs Tarun Gupta - Delhi).
-
Timeliness and Proceedings - Courts advocate for swift arbitration processes, especially when dealing with claims of income loss, to prevent undue delays (Jameela VS National Highway Authority of India - Kerala). Proper procedural adherence ensures that claims for loss of income are addressed efficiently and justly.
Analysis and Conclusion:
Claims for loss of income or profit are integral to arbitration disputes involving wrongful termination, breach of contract, or damages. They are generally recognized and can be awarded if supported by appropriate evidence and within the scope of arbitration agreements. Courts and arbitrators focus on accurate quantification and procedural validity. Challenges often revolve around evidentiary support and the interpretation of arbitration clauses, emphasizing the need for clear contractual provisions regarding damages claims.
References:
- URMIL MALIK VS NATIONAL SAVINGS ORGANISATION - Delhi, Indo Pacific Software and Entertainment Ltd. vs Kone Elevators India Pvt. Ltd. - Madras, Union of India Department of Tele Communications Now BSNL, represented by its AGM Office of Principle G. M. VS Tribhovandas Vendravan and Brothers Rep. by Kanaklal Abaichand - Madras, Union of India, Acting through Sr. Divisional Commercial Manager VS Sun Media Services - Bombay, Jameela VS National Highway Authority of India - Kerala, K. Kalaiarasi VS Zenith Builders (P) Ltd. , Rep. by it’s Managing Director, V. Pandurangan - Madras, Union of India VS Sun Media Services - Bombay, Ram Kala VS Delhi Development Authority - Delhi, First Global Stock Broking Pvt Ltd VS Tarun Gupta - Delhi, First Global Stock Broking Pvt. Ltd. vs Tarun Gupta - Delhi
Search Results for "Loss of Income in Arbitration"
1988 0 Supreme(Del) 164 • India - Delhi
B.N.KIRPAL
alleging wrongful termination and loss of income. ... the Post Master General for arbitration. ... Arbitration - Dispute Referral - The court held that the disputes raised by the petitioner were covered by the arbitration clause ... It is alleged that the termination of the agreement was wrongful and the loss of the income is to the tune of lakhs of rupees every year. ... Kirpal ... ( 1 ) THIS is an application under section 20 of the Arbitration Act....
2025 0 Supreme(Mad) 4664 • India - IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATUREAT MADRAS
Mohammed Shaffiq, K.R. Shriram, C.J.
clauses - Sole Arbitrator partly allowed appellant's counter-claim for loss of business income and for non-supply of equipment - ... regarding supply of elevators and escalators in construction projects - Agreements executed on 19.12.2005 and 16.02.2006 included arbitration ... Validity of the Arbitrator's conclusions on agreement supersession, calculation of damages, and grounds to invoke sections of the Arbitration ... In response, appellant raised a counter-claim totalling Rs.11,98,44,385/- citing loss#HL_EN....
2011 0 Supreme(Mad) 4734 • India - Madras
R.MALA, R.BANUMATHI
The arbitrator awarded damages and loss of rental income to the claimant. ... The court confirmed the award of damages and loss of rental income to the claimant. ... of rental income. ... From 01.03.1998 to 31.03.1999, first respondent is entitled to the loss of rental income and that has been awarded in para-99 as Rs.8,45,000/-being the loss of rental income for the unexpired portion of lease. ... Due to the fire accident, the firs....
2011 0 Supreme(Bom) 719 • India - Bombay
ANOOP V.MOHTA
It applies even to the claim of loss of profit/income or expenses incurred and or such other claims. ... towards payment made to other agencies in connection with contract, claimed by respondent-Claim, not supported by any evidence-Arbitration ... ... The Arbitration clause nowhere permits the parties to claim such ... It applies even to the claim of loss of profit / income or expenses incurred and or such other claims. ... 20. I have already observed in Arbitration#HL_END....
2024 0 Supreme(Ker) 1289 • India - Kerala
The court found that the petitioners could pursue their grievances through the appropriate legal channels under the Arbitration ... The entire arbitration proceedings shall be completed at the earliest, at any rate, within eight months from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this judgment.”3. ... The Arbitrator shall consider the interlocutory application and pass orders within one week thereafter and proceed to finalise the arbitration application after hearing the petitioner and other interested persons. ... Moreover, the baseme....
2020 0 Supreme(Mad) 33 • India - Madras
P.T.ASHA
Issues: Termination of agreements, cancellation of powers of attorney, breach of contract, limitation period for invoking arbitration ... Since the petitioner was guilty of a breach of contract and as the respondent had suffered a loss of income on account of the said breach they had invoked the arbitration clause by issuing a notice dated 14.03.2017 naming an arbitrator and seeking the consent of the petitioner. ... The respondent also contended that by investing such a huge amounts into the contract and not receiving t....
2017 0 Supreme(Del) 3224 • India - Delhi
SANJEEV SACHDEVA
challenged an arbitration award that awarded various claims and counterclaims related to a parking site dispute. ... Arbitration - Parking Site Dispute - Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 - Section 34 Fact of the Case: Loss
2011 0 Supreme(Bom) 720 • India - Bombay
ANOOP V.MOHTA
As dispute arose and as the petitioner failed to appoint an Arbitrator, as an arbitration petition moved by the respondent and the ... It applies even to the claim of loss of profit/income or expenses incurred and or such other claims. ... 20. I have already observed in Arbitration Petition No. 178 of 2007, Sealand Shipping & Export Pvt. Ltd. Vs. ... The Arbitration clause nowhere permits the parties to claim such loss of profit, in such fashion, in such circumstances. ... As dispute a....
2020 0 Supreme(Del) 921 • India - Delhi
VIPIN SANGHI, SANJEEV NARULA
Arbitration & Conciliation Act - Appeal - Section 34 - Regulation 3.4.1 of the National Stock Exchange of India Limited Regulations ... emphasized the importance of establishing the authenticity of instructions for trades and compliance with relevant regulations in arbitration ... He also claimed interest on the aforesaid amount, apart from loss of income/ opportunity lost of Rs.4.5 Lakhs. He claimed compensation of Rs. 1 Lakh, and legal fees and arbitration cost of Rs.2.68 Lakhs. His total claim was Rs....
• India - Delhi High Court
VIPIN SANGHI, SANJEEV NARULA
Section 37 of the Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996 to assail the order dated 10.12.2018 passed by the learned Single Judge in O.M.P. No.686/2012 under Section 34 of the Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996. ... The stand taken by the appellant in the arbitration proceedings was that the account of the respondent was a simple trading account, wherein he alone was responsible for all the trades undertaken in his account, and that the said trades had been undertaken on his specific instructions. ... Rao submits that, on the one hand, th....
Filter by Legal Phrase
