AI Overview...
-
Profit Claim in Suit for Injunction - Generally, a suit for injunction simpliciter (i.e., a simple injunction without seeking possession or title) does not involve or require proof of title or claim for profits. Such suits focus solely on possession or interference with possession, and the issue of profits or mesne profits is typically not directly in issue unless specifically claimed. Mokul International Ltd. VS Veena Paintal - Delhi, Surendra Nath Pasricha VS Kamla Pasricha - Delhi, DHANI RAM @ KALE VS MOHD FAISAL - Delhi, Satish Kumar vs Krishna - Delhi
-
Injunction Suit and Title - While the primary purpose of a suit for injunction simpliciter is to protect possession, the issue of title can sometimes be addressed incidentally. However, the main focus remains on possession rather than profits or damages. The courts have clarified that a claim for profits or mesne profits cannot be claimed in simpliciter injunction suits unless specifically included. Mokul International Ltd. VS Veena Paintal - Delhi, Grace Samuel VS Rani @ Porkilai - Madras
-
Main Points and Insights:
- A suit for injunction simpliciter primarily deals with possession, not title or profits. The issue of title is normally not directly and substantially in issue in such suits. Mokul International Ltd. VS Veena Paintal - Delhi, Surendra Nath Pasricha VS Kamla Pasricha - Delhi, DHANI RAM @ KALE VS MOHD FAISAL - Delhi
- Claims for mesne profits or damages are separate and cannot be claimed in simpliciter suits unless explicitly included in the prayer. Surendra Nath Pasricha VS Kamla Pasricha - Delhi, DHANI RAM @ KALE VS MOHD FAISAL - Delhi
- Courts have held that profits or damages are not claimable in simpliciter injunction suits because these relate to monetary relief, which is distinct from the relief of injunction. Narsingh Ispat Udyog Private Ltd. VS Jwala Coke Private Ltd. - Calcutta
-
The incidental consideration of title in injunction suits does not extend to claims for profits unless specifically pleaded and proved. Aditya Real Estates, Rep. by Manish Agrawal VS P. Baskar, Partner, M/s. Vasavi Builders Medavakkam, Now known as Sri Aishwaryam Homes - Madras
-
Analysis and Conclusion:
- A suit for injunction simpliciter is limited to protecting possession and does not automatically include claims for profits or mesne profits.
- To claim profits, a separate suit or a prayer explicitly including mesne profits is necessary.
- The courts emphasize that monetary claims like profits are distinct from the equitable relief of injunction and cannot be claimed in simpliciter suits unless specifically pleaded and adjudicated upon.
References: - Mokul International Ltd. VS Veena Paintal - Delhi - Surendra Nath Pasricha VS Kamla Pasricha - Delhi - DHANI RAM @ KALE VS MOHD FAISAL - Delhi - Satish Kumar vs Krishna - Delhi - Grace Samuel VS Rani @ Porkilai - Madras - Narsingh Ispat Udyog Private Ltd. VS Jwala Coke Private Ltd. - Calcutta - Aditya Real Estates, Rep. by Manish Agrawal VS P. Baskar, Partner, M/s. Vasavi Builders Medavakkam, Now known as Sri Aishwaryam Homes - Madras
Search Results for "Means Profit can Not Claim in Simpliciter Suit for Injunction"
2018 0 Supreme(Del) 2757 • India - Delhi
VALMIKI J.MEHTA
The judgment and decree in the suit for possession and mesne profits were confirmed, and the amount of mesne profits deposited by ... of adverse possession was not substantiated. ... The respondents claimed to be the owners of the property and filed a suit for recovery of possession and mesne profits against the ... Where the title of the plaintiff is not disputed, but he is not in possession, his remedy is to file a suit for posses....
• India - Delhi High Court
C.HARI SHANKAR
... ... Ratio Decidendi: The court reaffirmed that an injunction suit did not necessitate a possession claim if rights were clear ... (A) Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 - Sections 21(2), Order XIV Rule 5, Order XIX Rule 3 - Suit for Mandatory Injunction - Suit filed ... was not mischaracterized but maintainable based on established rights and obligations. ... The petitioner further contested the maintainability of the suit, before t....
2014 0 Supreme(Del) 678 • India - Delhi
VALMIKI J.MEHTA
by documents, and the issue of title could be decided in a suit for injunction. ... The plaintiff sought a mandatory injunction and mesne profits, which was decreed by the trial court and the first appellate court ... mandatory injunction was maintainable. ... ... (b) As a suit for injunction simpliciter is concerned only with possession, normally the issue of title will not be directly and substantially in issue. The prayer for #H....
2018 0 Supreme(Del) 698 • India - Delhi
VALMIKI J.MEHTA
The issues related to mesne profits and interest on mesne profits were also framed in the suit. ... Issues: The issues framed in the suit were related to the entitlement of mesne profits and interest on mesne profits. ... present suit. ... ... (b) As a suit for injunction simpliciter is concerned only with possession, normally the issue of title will not be directly and substantially in issue. ....
2020 0 Supreme(Guj) 663 • India - Gujarat
BHARGAV D.KARIA
simpliciter, therefore, such findings cannot be interfered with being concurrent in nature. ... simpliciter, therefore, such findings cannot be interfered with being concurrent in nature Facts of the case ... adjacent to their land and as there is merely an interference with plaintiff's lawful possession, it is sufficient to sue for an injunction ... (b) As a suit for injunction simpliciter is concerned only with possession, normally the issue of title will not be di....
2018 0 Supreme(Del) 3247 • India - Delhi
VALMIKI J.MEHTA
property need not be proved – Trial Court erred in dismissing the suit – Trial Court judgment is set aside – Appeal allowed. ... Civil Procedure Code, 1908 - Order 7 Rule 3 – Property is also capable of identification by municipal numbers, site plan of the suit ... (b) As a suit for injunction simpliciter is concerned only with possession, normally the issue of title will not be directly and substantially in issue. The prayer for injunction will be ....
2018 0 Supreme(Mad) 1168 • India - Madras
M.VENUGOPAL, S.VAIDYANATHAN
is not simpliciter a suit for enforcement of specific performance/contract/agreement and if ultimately the relief of specific performance ... which will have a direct bearing on the title or the possession of the land in view of the alternative relief of seeking permanent injunction ... Revocation of Leave to Sue, which was granted under Clause 12 of the Letters Patent of the Madras High Court on the premise that the claim ... Even the ancillary relief of permanent injunction is also f....
2021 0 Supreme(Cal) 333 • India - Calcutta
SHEKHAR B. SARAF
Finding of the Court : Passing of an ad interim injunction order in respect of non-suit property is not permissible ... an injunction on goods that were to be delivered to the plaintiff as the plaintiff does not seek a decree for specific performance ... matter in dispute is allowed under O.39 R.1 (b) and the same could be exercised even when a money claim is being sought in the suit ... When in the plaint the plaintiff is seeking a simplicitor mone....
2012 0 Supreme(Mad) 869 • India - Madras
M.VENUGOPAL
It held that the issue of title could be addressed incidentally in a Suit for injunction. ... It emphasized that the issue of title could be addressed incidentally in a Suit for injunction. ... The parties were left to bear their own costs, and the dismissal did not preclude them from seeking other remedies before the appropriate ... In law, there is no need for both the trial Court as well as the Appellate Court to go into the question of prima facie title either substantially or materially in a #HL_ST....
2017 0 Supreme(MP) 546 • India - Madhya Pradesh
S.K.GANGELE, ANURAG SHRIVASTAVA
simpliciter for declaration -- maintainability of -- joint family property -- plaintiff found in constructive possession -- suit ... simpliciter for declaration of title -- whether decree of partition and possession can be granted -- without proper pleading and ... simpliciter for declaration of her share is maintainable. (1993) Supp. 3 SCC 129, (2007)14 SCC 253, and ... On additional issues, learned trial Court vide order dated 8.2.2016 recorded the findings that the suit of plaintiff is not#....
Filter by Legal Phrase
