AI Overview...
- Perpetual Injunction Against Real Estate Persons - Main points and insights:
- A perpetual injunction cannot be issued against the true owner asserting possession, as the owner has the right to possess and seek protection (Source: Durga Kala Mandir VS S. Pulla Rao - Andhra Pradesh).
- Plaintiffs seeking perpetual or mandatory injunctions must prove that pecuniary compensation is inadequate and that their possession is lawful, real, and legal (Sources: KRUSHNA KISHORE BAL VS SANKARSAN SAMAL - Orissa, Mohd. Aslam Shawl VS Gh. Mohd. Shargru - Jammu and Kashmir).
- The grant of perpetual injunction is discretionary and requires that the party seeking it has a lawful possession; mere possession does not automatically entitle one to a perpetual injunction (Sources: THAKOR KANSING CHATURSING VS BHARWAD BHAGWAN RAIYABHAI - Gujarat, Kolte Patil Developers VS NTI Housing Co-Operative Society - Current Civil Cases).
- In cases involving trade mark infringement, the court may grant perpetual injunctions if the plaintiff proves infringement and the use is deceptive (Source: ROHTAS GOEL VS SOMAY NAYAK - Delhi).
- Injunctions related to real estate projects are also subject to specific legal provisions, such as registration requirements under relevant Acts, and courts may impose injunctions to prevent unlawful construction or sale activities (Sources: Praveen Chhabra VS Real Estate Appellate Tribunal - Delhi, Kolte Patil Developers VS NTI Housing Co-Operative Society - Current Civil Cases).
-
The relief of perpetual injunction is a final, permanent restraint, distinct from temporary injunctions, and is granted only when the court is convinced of the necessity and legality of such relief (Sources: Bhagwanrao s/o Jijaba Auti VS Ganpatrao s/o Mugaji Raut & another - Bombay, Gaddipati Sambrajayam VS Panguluri Mahalakshmamma - Andhra Pradesh).
-
Analysis and Conclusion:
- Perpetual injunctions in real estate disputes are granted with caution, primarily to protect lawful possession and prevent unlawful interference. They are not available against the true owner or in cases where possession is not lawful.
- The courts emphasize that the right to possession must be lawful, real, and legal, and mere possession does not suffice.
- The discretion of the court plays a vital role, and the plaintiff must demonstrate that no other remedy, such as damages, is adequate.
- Legal provisions specific to real estate, trade marks, and other relevant statutes guide the grant of such injunctions.
- Overall, perpetual injunctions serve as a final measure to prevent unlawful acts and protect lawful possession but are granted only when the legal criteria are fully satisfied.
Search Results for "Perpetual Injunction against Real Estate Persons"
2014 0 Supreme(AP) 1539 • India - Andhra Pradesh
B.CHANDRA KUMAR
Whether the plaintiff can maintain a suit seeking for injunction against the real owner asserting the possession and seeking protection ... and no injunction can be issued against the true owner – Petition dismissed ... Seeking for injunction - This appeal is directed against the decree and judgment passed in AS No. 39 of ... Accordingly, the plaintiff filed the suit for perpetual injunction. ... 5. The suit schedule property has been described as follows: ... "M/s. Sri Durga Kalamand....
1973 0 Supreme(Ori) 101 • India - Orissa
S.ACHARYA, G.K.MISRA, B.K.PATRA
Plaintiffs to get a perpetual and mandatory injunction must also prove that pecuniary compensation would not afford adequate relief ... Are the plaintiffs entitled to perpetual and mandatory injunctions? Ratio Decidendi: 1. ... Plaintiffs filed a suit for a mandatory injunction to dismantle illegal constructions and a permanent injunction to restrain further ... (iv) Are the plaintiffs entitled to perpetual and mandatory injunctions? 24. ... Section ....
2010 0 Supreme(Del) 716 • India - Delhi
V.K.JAIN
of buyer ---Use of word Omaxe is a clear imitation and colourable use of trade mark of plaintiff---Plaintiff is entitled to get perpetual ... Civil Procedure Code, 1908 – Order 39 Rules 1, 2- Trade Marks Act, 199 - Sections 28, 29(5) - Companies Act, 1956 - Section 22 - Injunction ... injunction against defendant ---Remedy available under Section 22 of Companies Act is altogether independent of the remedy available ... For the reasons given in the preceding paragraphs, the plaintiffs are entitled to perpetual i....
1988 0 Supreme(J&K) 74 • India - Jammu and Kashmir
M.L.BHAT
Fact of the Case: Plaintiff filed a suit seeking a perpetual injunction to prevent the defendant from forcibly evicting ... It would give benefit to those persons who have right to be in possession, that would mean whose possession is lawful, real and legal ... It would give benefit to those persons who have right to be in possession, that would mean whose possession is lawful, real and legal ... P, C. in terms of clause (C)of Rule I of order 39 does not seek to protect possession to....
2022 0 Supreme(Del) 425 • India - Delhi
YASHWANT VARMA
proceedings seeking following reliefs - Section 3(1) prescribes that no promoter shall advertise, sell or offer to sell, or invite persons ... consideration significant portent of direction issued - It has practically injuncted all construction activity in NCT of Delhi - Aforesaid injunction ... to purchase any plot, apartment or building in any real estate project which is not registered under Act. ... the case may be, in any real estate project or part of it, in any planning area, wi....
2012 0 Supreme(AP) 816 • India - Andhra Pradesh
L.NARASIMHA REDDY
State Wakf Tribunal, against petitioner and respondents 2 and 3, for the relief of perpetual injunction, in respect of Acs.6.26 guntas ... alleged that petitioner herein, who was a Sarpanch of the village, has made attempts to occupy the land, as part of his real estate ... to have violated the order of injunction, and his being detained in civil prison. ... State Wakf Tribunal, Hyderabad, against the petitioner and respondents 2 and 3, for the relief of per....
1987 0 Supreme(Bom) 231 • India - Bombay
B.G.DEO, V.P.SALVE
The relief of perpetual injunction is discretionary. ... It is only in such a case that perpetual injunction can be issued in his favour. ... The difference between the two is real and substantial one is a temporary measure, the other is a perpetual restraint by a decree ... The difference between the two is real and substantial; one is a temporary measure, the other is a perpetual restraint by a decree. A relief of perpetual #HL_ST....
1994 0 Supreme(AP) 562 • India - Andhra Pradesh
B.K.SOMASEKHARA
is not granted than the inconvenience which, the defendant or persons claiming through him would be put to if the temporary injunction ... CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, Or.39, Rules 1 and 2 - Grant of temporary injunction pending suit for permanent injunction restraining defendants ... ... HELD: The grant or refusal of a temporary injunction is covered ... Section 38 enumerates as to when perpetual injunction can be granted and section 41 enumerates as to when i....
1993 0 Supreme(Guj) 368 • India - Gujarat
J.N.BHATT
The Court cannot grant perpetual injunction under the Specific Reliefs Act in favour of a person who is not holding possession lawfully ... Mere possession does not `ipso facto entitle the party for the grant of perpetual injunction . ... Perpetual Injunction - Restraining other party disturbing possession - Mere possession does not ipso facto entitle party for grant ... The Court cannot grant perpetual injunction under the Specific....
• India - Current Civil Cases
K.L.MANJUNATH, RAVI MALIMATH
remedy available to plaintiff is only to seek comprehensive relief of positive declaration with consequential relief of permanent injunction ... state of affairs and has applied proper law to facts of case—Appeal dismis ... & ... of plaintiff is accepted, no injunctive relief can be granted in favour of plaintiff—Trial Court has adopted right approach to real ... No.5649/1997 for a perpetual injunction from restraining the plaintiff from exercising any rights under the agreements executed and further re....
Filter by Legal Phrase
