Jurisdiction of Section 9 Applications - The court has jurisdiction to entertain Section 9 applications before, during, or after arbitral proceedings, but before enforcement under Section 36. It is not necessary for a notice invoking arbitration to be issued prior to the application, ensuring flexibility in filing such applications at different stages of arbitration. Pearl Hospitality & Events Pvt Ltd VS Oyo Hotels And Homes Pvt Ltd - Delhi
Application for Appointment of Arbitrator (Section 11) - Filing under Section 11 for arbitrator appointment requires a clear notice to the other party; failure to do so and delays in appointment can render subsequent applications not maintainable. Challenges to orders related to arbitration are subject to judicial scrutiny, emphasizing the importance of procedural compliance. S. B. P. AND COMPANY VS PATEL ENGINEERING LTD. - Supreme Court
Intervention under Section 45 & EULAs - Courts can entertain applications under Section 45 to address jurisdiction issues or interpret End User License Agreements (EULAs), especially when such agreements were concealed or suppressed. Proper application and pointing out relevant contractual clauses are essential for intervention. GALATEA LTD. VS SHREE KRISHNA EXPORTS - Gujarat
Late Filing & Section 12 Applications - Petitions filed beyond prescribed time limits under Section 13(2) are generally not entertained. The Supreme Court directs arbitrators to decide applications under Section 16, even if filed late, but emphasizes timely submissions for effective relief. Pradyuman Kumar Sharma VS Jaysagar M. Sancheti - Bombay
Repetition in Recruitment & Rule Framing - In civil service recruitment, repetition of procedural errors can be addressed by framing or amending rules to avoid such issues, with courts emphasizing fair selection processes and proper eligibility criteria. Khaleel Ahmed K. R. VS State of Karnataka - Karnataka
Contract Interpretation & Tax Deductions - Court decisions reaffirm that contract provisions (e.g., PSCs) must explicitly specify conditions for deductions; absence of such stipulations limits the Assessing Officer's authority. Proper contractual clarity is vital for tax-related claims. JOSHI TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL INC. VS UNION OF INDIA - Supreme Court
Implementation of Mining & Lease Applications - Petitions related to mining lease applications involve deposit and procedural compliance, with courts allowing continued operations if conditions are met, and emphasizing procedural adherence in lease processes. Ashaq Hussain Paddar VS State of J&K - Jammu and Kashmir
Amendments & Constitutional Validity - Amendments to policies (e.g., MDGs) are upheld as lawful and proportional, with courts striking down only those clauses that are unconstitutional, ensuring that reforms are balanced and justified. Indian Oil Corporation Limited VS All India Petroleum Dealers Association Registered - Delhi
Pension & Service Records - Courts have reiterated that service in pensionable establishments must be clearly documented; claims are scrutinized based on plain contractual and administrative records, emphasizing transparency and accuracy in pension calculations. State of Gujarat VS Kalhans Harial Patel - Gujarat
Lease & Possession Post-Expiry - Post-lease expiration, courts have held that possession can continue if supported by statutory provisions or approvals, and disputes over vested rights are resolved based on statutory interpretation and factual evidence. Century Textiles and Industries Limited VS Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai - Bombay
The sources collectively highlight procedural nuances in arbitration applications, contractual interpretations, and administrative challenges. Notably, the importance of timely filings, clear contractual clauses, and procedural compliance is emphasized across different contexts—arbitration, civil service, taxation, and lease disputes. For an original application filed before Kt (presumably Karnataka), it is crucial to adhere to statutory procedures, ensure proper notices, and substantiate claims with relevant documentation to withstand judicial scrutiny and facilitate effective relief.
References: - Pearl Hospitality & Events Pvt Ltd VS Oyo Hotels And Homes Pvt Ltd - Delhi - S. B. P. AND COMPANY VS PATEL ENGINEERING LTD. - Supreme Court - GALATEA LTD. VS SHREE KRISHNA EXPORTS - Gujarat - Pradyuman Kumar Sharma VS Jaysagar M. Sancheti - Bombay - Khaleel Ahmed K. R. VS State of Karnataka - Karnataka - JOSHI TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL INC. VS UNION OF INDIA - Supreme Court - Ashaq Hussain Paddar VS State of J&K - Jammu and Kashmir - Indian Oil Corporation Limited VS All India Petroleum Dealers Association Registered - Delhi - State of Gujarat VS Kalhans Harial Patel - Gujarat - Century Textiles and Industries Limited VS Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai - Bombay
Reading the section as a whole it appears to us that the court has jurisdiction to entertain an application under Section 9 either before arbitral proceedings or during arbitral proceedings or after the making of the arbitral award but before it is enforced in accordance with Section 36 of the Act. ... In order to give full effect to the words "before or during arbitral proceedings" occurring in Section 9, it would not be necessary that a notice invoking the arbitration clause must be issued to the opposite party before an appli....
arbitrator for resolution of the disputes between the appellants and respondent No. 1 are not maintainable - Held, At the cost of repetition ... Appellants had challenged orders passed by the Division Bench of the Bombay High Court whereby it held that the writ petitions filed ... In that case the appellant had filed an application under Section 11 of the Act for appointment of an arbitrator by contending that despite clear 30 days notice, the first respondent failed to appoint an arbitrator in accordance with the terms ....
versions of Planning Product - Said EULAs, which were deliberately concealed and suppressed by original plaintiffs, also contain ... by appellant along with an application under Order LXI Rule 27 of C.P.C. - Said EULAs also contain clauses that would covers all ... intervention - Jurisdiction - End User License Agreement - Whether Court below committed an error in passing the impugned order rejecting application ... It is only when the Appellant pointed this out and filed an application under Section 45....
The petitioner made belated application under Section 12 by which the petitioner repeated his allegations made in petition filed ... Petitioner did not make any application within time prescribed under Section 13(2) of the Act. ... The Supreme Court did not interfere with the said order and merely directed the arbitrator to decide application under Section 16 ... On 18th September 2008, that is after completion of final arguments by the petitioner, an application under Section 12 of the Act alleging bia....
fair selection while making recruitment to posts in State Civil Services - Committee recommended framing/amending Rules to avoid repetition ... DPAR 2 SBC 94, dated 03.05.1994 - Preparation of list of eligible candidate for written examination/personality test - Erroneous application ... , thus not strangers - No relief relating to conditions of service sought - No personal interest involved - Held, Writ petition filed ... The following passage in the judgment is relevant: ... "....A reading of the aforesaid provisions w....
nbsp;(b) Legal interpretation – Contracts – PSCs dated 20-02-1995 – Appellant’s counsel attempting to contend that provisions of Model ... It started the production after entering into the contract and filed its income tax return on the income generated from the aforesaid ... mandatory for claiming these deductions – In absence of these stipulations in the PSC the Assessing Officer would be unable to give ... On this application, the Court had made observation on 12.03-2012 to the effect that it was not going to place an....
CM No. 1038/2020 This application has been filed for impleadment of eight persons as party respondents on the ground that they are ... besides depositing remaining 50% of the bid amount within a period of six months enabling respondent No. 2 to grant formal mining lease ... Rules of 2016, which was aimed at facilitating the carrying on of all the mining operations by the petitioners without there being lease ... Original record produced by Mr. F.A. Natnoo, AAG, be returned. ... Rule 27 deals with proce....
... ... Findings of Court: ... The court reinstated the amendments to MDGs as lawful and proportional measures, except for the reading ... The Single Judge struck down certain clauses of the amendments, leading to the present appeals. ... (C) No. 11246/2017 were filed and six Intervention applications were filed in W.P. ... If any information given by the dealer in his application for appointment as a dealer shall be found to untrue or in correct in any material respect. ... To this ....
unequivocally held by catena of decisions of the Apex Court as well as this Court, which this judgment only reiterates, respondents – original ... petitioner, on the ground that the petitioner had not rendered any service in a pensionable establishment – clear from the plain reading ... for pension and calculation of pensionable qualifying service by two offices of respondent Nos. 1 and 5 at the time of accepting application ... Therefore, the contention of learned Government Pleader that the original petitioner was requ....
(Paras 6.1-7.8) Fact of the case: Petition for Mandamus filed by Century Textile and Industries Limited regarding ... (Paras 1, 6.1-7.8) ... ... (B) Lease Expiration - Status post-lease - Court held continued possession ... No. 1546 claiming it as vested post-expiry of the lease under the improvement statutes. ... (emphasis in original and supplied) 6.6 In Popatrao Patil vs. ... EB/3086/GS/a dt. 17/3/2011 and any subsequent approvals thereof, immediately please.” ... “A.C.Est #HL_....
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.