AI Overview...
-
Timing of Counterclaims - Generally, counterclaims should be filed before issues are framed and evidence is closed to avoid prejudice to the plaintiff. Courts have held that filing a counterclaim after the commencement of evidence is typically not permissible, especially once issues are framed, as it can delay proceedings and prejudice the other party. For example, in INDCAL00000001231, the High Court ruled that counterclaims cannot be entertained after issue framing. Similarly, in 00100064278, it was noted that counterclaims are generally to be raised before issues are framed and evidence is closed Paras 18, 23.
-
Exceptions and Circumstances - There are specific circumstances where late counterclaims have been entertained, such as in long-pending suits or where unique facts justify late filing. In 00800057175, the court considered whether a counterclaim filed during evidence was permissible, indicating that such allowances depend on the case's facts and whether the delay causes prejudice. The Supreme Court in 00200032655 acknowledged that counterclaims can sometimes be permitted to avoid multiplicity of proceedings, particularly in suits involving injunctive relief or where the counterclaim is integral to the matter Paras 1, 9, 10.
-
Nature and Parties Involved - Counterclaims against co-defendants are generally not maintainable, as seen in 02300084886, where the court dismissed such counterclaims because the CPC does not provide for them. Conversely, counterclaims against the plaintiff are more straightforward and can be entertained before or during trial, provided procedural rules are followed Paras 23.
-
Role of Defendant (Dominus Litis) - The defendant, as the dominus litis, has some discretion in adding parties or raising counterclaims, but this is also subject to procedural limits. In 01700057103, the court emphasized that a defendant can add parties to a counterclaim but must do so within the procedural framework, ideally before evidence is closed.
Analysis and Conclusion:
Counterclaims are generally to be filed before the framing of issues and the commencement of evidence. Filing a counterclaim after evidence has started or after issues are framed is usually not entertained unless exceptional circumstances justify it. Courts prioritize procedural discipline to prevent prejudice and ensure fair trial. However, in specific cases, late counterclaims may be allowed to prevent multiplicity or address unique facts, but such allowances are made cautiously and based on case-specific merits Ashok Kumar Kalra VS Wing Cdr. Surendra Agnihotri - Supreme Court, Sanjiv Tiwari VS Deepak Poptani - Delhi, Dr. T. D. Padalia And Anr. VS District Judge - Uttarakhand, ATANU MUKHERJEE & ANR. vs JUTHIKA MUKHERJEE & ORS. - Calcutta.
Search Results for "When Counterclaim can be Entertained after Case Fixed for Paintiff Evidence"
2020 8 Supreme 20 • India - Supreme Court
N.V.RAMANA, MOHAN M.SHANTANAGOUDAR, AJAY RASTOGI
(Para 18, 23) Facts of the case: A dispute arose between the Petitioner (defendant ... no. 2) and Respondent No. 1 (plaintiff) concerning performance of agreement to sell dated 20.11.1987 and 04.10.1989. ... Respondent No.1 (plaintiff) filed the suit for specific performance against the petitioner (defendant no. 2) on 02.05.2008. ... that a counterclaim can be raised after issues are framed and the evidence is closed. ... counterclaim may not prejudice the defendant because in spite of....
2020 0 Supreme(Del) 1141 • India - Delhi
PRATHIBA M.SINGH
Counterclaim - Filing of Counterclaim after Commencement of Evidence - Order XXXVII CPC - Section 23 Rule 2 CPC - Ashok Kumar ... evidence. ... The Defendant filed a counterclaim for a sum of Rs.56,41,129/- after the commencement of the Plaintiff's evidence. ... (Oral) - This petition raises an important question as to whether the counterclaim filed by the Defendant/Respondent (hereinafter, "Defendant") after the commencement of the evidence of the #....
2024 0 Supreme(P&H) 569 • India - Punjab and Haryana
ARCHANA PURI
the counterclaim. ... not maintainable as per the provisions of the CPC, which only allow counterclaims against the plaintiff, not co-defendants. ... counterclaims, concluding that a defendant cannot file a counterclaim against a co-defendant, which influenced the decision to dismiss ... Perusal of the same reveals that issues in the suit were framed on 02.04.2018 and the case was fixed for evidence of the plaintiff. ... for #HL_STA....
2025 0 Supreme(Pat) 1256 • India - IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
ARUN KUMAR JHA
filed after evidence closure, citing the unique circumstances surrounding the late inclusion of the counterclaim. ... ... ... Issues: The court assessed whether the trial court correctly allowed a counterclaim filed during evidence presentation, considering ... made after the closure of evidence in a long-pending title suit. ... In the present case, the respondent-plaintiff's evidence was still being recorded by the trial court, when the counterclaim#HL_EN....
2007 0 Supreme(AP) 903 • India - Andhra Pradesh
P.S.NARAYANA
Code 1908- Order 8 Rules 6 and 6A - Filing of counter-claim can be permitted to avoid multiplicity of proceedings and could be entertained ... constructing a compound wall encroaching Public Road - Counter-claim made by 1st defendant praying for mandatory injunction against plaintiff ... ... Therefore, the Supreme Court authoritatively held that in a suit for injunction a counterclaim for possession could also be entertained by operation of Order 8 Rule 6A(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure. In Jag Mohan Chawla's #HL_STA....
• India - Current Civil Cases
I.A.ANSARI
suit for injunction, counter-claim for possession can also be entertained—While defendant’s cause of action for a counter-claim ... Order 8 Rule 6A—Counter claim—Court where suit is instituted, cannot be divested of its power to try suit which it had already entertained—In ... was a tenant under defendant No.1 and not a licensee—When plaintiff was asked by defendant No.1 to vacate suit premises, plaintiff ... In course of time, both the parties adduced their evidence. ... Defendant No.1 also sought ....
2017 0 Supreme(P&H) 2169 • India - Punjab and Haryana
RAJBIR SEHRAWAT
If any counter claim by the defendant against his co-defendant is entertained ... Hence the counter claim against the co-defendant in the present case was not maintainable. ... In case defendant files a counter claim against a co-defendant then co-defendant has not been given any right to file written statement ... Default of Plaintiff to reply to counterclaim. ... Plaintiff and defendant No. 1 led their evidence. However, defendant No. 2 did not opt to contest the #H....
2019 0 Supreme(Raj) 1597 • India - Rajasthan
N. ANAND VENKATESH
The defendant is entitled to add them as defendants since he is the "dominus litis" insofar as the counterclaim is concerned. ... court reasoned that a counter-claim is in the nature of a cross-suit and that the defendant is the "dominus litis" insofar as the counterclaim ... important aspect that the defendant was entitled to add the parties as defendants since he was the "dominus litis" insofar as the counterclaim ... In all those decisions the Courts have held that the counter claim can not be entertained either after....
2007 0 Supreme(UK) 299 • India - Uttarakhand
B.S.VERMA
of evidence to avoid prejudice to the plaintiff. ... Issues: The main issue was whether the counterclaim could be entertained after the commencement of the trial. ... It highlighted the importance of setting up a counterclaim before the framing of issues and before the commencement of evidence to ... A refusal on the part of "the court to entertain a belated counterclaim may not prejudice the defendant because in spite of the counter-claim having been refused to be #....
2023 Supreme(Online)(CAL) 14104 • India - Calcutta High Court
SIDDHARTHA ROY CHOWDHURY, J
Court in revisional applications - The petitioner challenged an order passed by the Trial Court allowing a counter claim after the evidence ... ... ... Ratio Decidendi: The High Court determined that counter claims could not be entertained post-issue framing in lieu of established ... (Paras 1, 9, 10) ... ... (B) Counterclaims - Permissibility and timing - It was ... witness proves his affidavit of evidence or such witness seeks to prove a document for it to be tendered in evidence or the cross-exam....
Filter by Legal Phrase
