The Supreme Court of India has issued a definitive order to resolve the long-standing dispute regarding investor claims in the PACL residential projects in Sectors 100 and 104 of Mohali, and in Bathinda. A division bench comprising Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha and Justice Atul S. Chandurkar accepted the report submitted by the Justice (Retd.) R.M. Lodha Committee, which categorizes thousands of plot allottees based on their payment history and documentation. This decision provides a structural framework for either the allocation of plots or the refund of invested amounts, marking a significant step toward concluding litigation that has persisted for over a decade.

The dispute stems from regulatory proceedings initiated by the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) against PACL for operating an unregistered Collective Investment Scheme (CIS). SEBI had initially directed the company to either register under the 1999 regulations or cease operations. Following a series of judicial interventions and a 2013 remand order by the Supreme Court, the Securities Appellate Tribunal (SAT) eventually upheld SEBI’s directive to wind up all schemes and refund investors. In 2016, the apex court established the Justice (Retd.) R.M. Lodha Committee, tasking it with the liquidation of land assets and the management of investor claims.

The Committee’s recent final report, filed in April 2025, analyzed thousands of claims relating to the Mohali and Bathinda projects, sorting them into five distinct categories. The Supreme Court observed that the judicial process had reached a point where finality was essential for the interest of the investors. As the Court noted, “More than a decade has passed since then, and yet, this Court has been struggling to resolve this issue. Committees have been constituted, and various reports have been submitted and considered sporadically, within the limited time this Court has.”

For Category I, comprising allottees who made full payments through banking channels, the Court directed the Recovery Officer under Section 28A of the SEBI Act to issue necessary sale certificates or no-objection certificates within eight weeks. Additionally, allottees who had not received their possession certificates are now entitled to receive them within the same period.

Category II allottees, who contributed more than 50% of the consideration via banking channels, were also treated as legitimate buyers. The Court ordered the Committee to provide these individuals with a statement of the balance payable, including internal development contributions. These allottees have 30 days to clear the outstanding dues to receive their property titles. If payments are not made within this timeframe, the plot will be reclassified as unsold, and the previously audited payments will be refunded.

The approach for Category III allottees—those who paid less than 50%—is more stringent. The bench declined to offer these individuals an opportunity to retain their plots at market rates. Instead, the Court directed that their plots be auctioned. The Committee is instructed to refund the amounts these allottees paid, as certified by auditors, along with 8% interest within three months of the successful auction of the specific plot. Regarding the broader necessity of these proceedings, the Court emphasized, “We cannot afford to convert these proceedings into suits for specific performance or public law proceedings for restitution and rehabilitation.”

Category IV covers allottees who either paid in cash or executed banking transactions after the February 2016 freezing date. The Supreme Court rejected these applications for property allotment or direct refunds through the Committee. However, the bench clarified that this order does not permanently bar these individuals from seeking legal recourse. The Court stated, “We are of the opinion that they will be entitled to approach the appropriate Civil Court by filing suits for recovery/declaration.” The bench indicated that it would hear from SEBI and the Amici Curiae on the specifics of legal impleadment in such suits to ensure clarity, particularly regarding the prohibitions established in earlier orders.

Category V includes allottees who transferred their interests during the pendency of the litigation. The Court ruled that these claims will follow the same classification trajectory as their original category, ensuring that secondary purchasers are not unfairly prejudiced by the timing of their acquisition.

Finally, the Court directed the Committee to conduct a verification process for several pending applications from allottees who claim eligibility for Category I, subject to review by SEBI. By adopting this clear, tiered approach, the Supreme Court has sought to balance the rights of the investors with the practical impossibility of continuing a drawn-out, case-by-case adjudication of specific performance suits. The order ensures that where valid investment proof exists, restitution is prioritized, while also setting a clear deadline for the remaining property liquidation. The Committee’s mandate remains active, and the Recovery Officer is now tasked with executing the sale certificate issuances and refund processes as per the defined timeline.