The has dismissed a filed by , which alleged that two private respondents had violated a standing by installing CCTV cameras and an ownership board on the church’s premises. Justice G.M. Mohiuddin ruled that the installation of security measures on property subject to an ongoing boundary dispute does not constitute a "" or a willful violation of court directives.
The litigation originated from a filed by the church in , which challenged a governmental directive to hand over portions of its land for a proposed road widening and flyover project. During the pendency of that petition, the court had granted an directing the authorities to refrain from taking any coercive steps against the church. The petitioner, , later sought to bring contempt proceedings against two individuals, claiming that these respondents had intruded upon the church property during the subsistence of the court’s protective order. The petitioner argued that the act of installing two CCTV cameras on a church beam and erecting a board asserting private ownership was a calculated attempt to intimidate the church and interfere with its possession of the land.
In its submissions to the court, the church provided photographs and a boundary map, asserting that the installations were located within the area identified as Part-I, which it claimed was part of the church’s property. The petitioner requested that the court appoint an to resolve the dispute regarding the exact placement of the cameras and the signage, arguing that the respondents' actions amounted to an and a form of indirect coercion.
The respondents, however, denied these allegations, maintaining that they held valid title to the adjacent property. They testified that their mother had purchased the land in and that they had inherited portions of this area. According to the respondents, the CCTV cameras and the signage were essential security measures installed solely to protect their property from antisocial elements and to prevent encroachments. They argued that the , which was originally directed at state authorities, did not prohibit them from protecting their own property, and that there was no intent to disregard the court’s authority. Furthermore, they offered an unconditional apology for any unintended impression of contempt, emphasizing their commitment to compliance.
The court observed that the dispute necessitated a deep dive into title documents and property demarcations, which exceeded the purpose of . Justice G.M. Mohiuddin noted that the term "coercive steps" was specifically intended to prevent the authorities from forcibly dispossessing the church or demolishing the structure pending the of the . The court held that the presence of security cameras and an ownership board did not meet this threshold, as they were not acts of dispossession or demolition.
"The term ‘coercive steps’, in the context of the
, refers to actions taken by an authority or a party to dispossess the petitioner church, demolish the structure, or otherwise interfere with its possession and rights,"
the court stated in its judgment. It reasoned that since the installation was described by the respondents as a defensive measure against encroachment, it could not be viewed as a
violation of the specific restraint on coercive actions.
Moreover, the court emphasized that
requires evidence of a deliberate and malicious intent to violate a judicial order. Examining the evidence presented, the court found that the materials were insufficient to confirm that the respondents were acting with the intention to undermine the judiciary.
"For an act to constitute
, there must be wilful and deliberate disobedience of the order of the Court,"
the judgment added, noting that even if the respondents were mistaken regarding their legal rights over the boundary lines, that alone did not equate to contempt.
The court declined the request to appoint an , noting that such an exercise would fundamentally transform the nature of the into a trial on property title and boundary demarcation. Justice Mohiuddin clarified that the court’s current was limited to determining whether the specific of , had been willfully breached. Finding that the evidence did not support a finding of willful disobedience, the court dismissed the contempt case entirely.
This ruling leaves the underlying dispute between the church and the private respondents over the ownership of the specific land patch open to be addressed through other appropriate legal channels. By dismissing the contempt case, the court has signaled that while it remains vigilant in protecting parties from coercive dispossession, it will not allow the contempt to be utilized as a substitute for civil suits concerning complex land title and boundary rights. The petitioner remains at liberty to pursue further remedies in law, such as a civil suit for or , should it choose to challenge the encroachment or the respondents' claims of ownership through the proper legal forums. The matter now rests, with the petitioner free to seek substantive civil relief if the alleged interference continues, outside the scope of the summary contempt .
property boundary dispute - interim court orders