The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Delhi, has set aside a revision order passed by the Principal Commissioner of Income Tax (PCIT) against Senior Advocate Maninder Singh, ruling that the properties used by the former Additional Solicitor General for his legal practice were not subject to additional rental income tax. The tribunal further upheld the assessee’s claim for depreciation on those properties, dismissing the Revenue’s argument that land and construction costs should be bifurcated for tax purposes.

The dispute stemmed from a revision order initiated under Section 263 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, by the PCIT, who argued that the original assessment order for the 2022-23 assessment year was erroneous and prejudicial to the interests of the Revenue. The PCIT had contended that no Annual Letting Value (ALV) had been declared for properties located in Jangpura Extension, Sunder Nagar, and Defence Colony, and that the Assessing Officer (AO) had failed to conduct sufficient inquiries into whether these residential properties were being used for commercial or professional purposes.

The tribunal bench, comprising Vice President Mahavir Singh and Accountant Member Krinwant Sahay, found these contentions meritless. The bench observed that the AO had conducted thorough scrutiny of the assessee’s professional income and property holdings during the original assessment proceedings. Regarding the usage of the premises, the tribunal highlighted that legal professionals are permitted to operate from residential areas under the Master Plan for Delhi 2021.

"The AO has done all the verifications and enquiries on this issue. Hence, in our view, no ALV can be computed while framing assessment, which AO has rightly done," the tribunal noted in its order. By confirming that the properties were genuinely utilized for the assessee 's legal practice, the court held that the PCIT's attempt to impose ALV was based on a different opinion rather than a failure of inquiry, exceeding the jurisdiction granted under Section 263.

Depreciation Claims on Composite Assets

A significant portion of the litigation focused on the depreciation claims of over ₹8.5 crore on two major properties acquired during the fiscal year. The PCIT had challenged this, arguing that the AO failed to notice that depreciation is only admissible for building structures, not for the underlying land. The Revenue contended that the sale deeds contained valuations for both land and construction, which should have been used to exclude the land component from the depreciation base.

Counsel for the assessee argued that the purchase consideration paid for the Sunder Nagar and Defence Colony properties was a singular, composite price. They submitted that the bifurcation of values mentioned in the sale documents was merely for the technical purpose of calculating stamp duty based on circle rates set by the Delhi government, and did not reflect an actual partition of consideration between the parties.

The ITAT agreed with the assessee , finding that the sale deeds did not allocate separate values for land and building in the actual consideration paid to the vendors. "The sale consideration recorded by the sub-registrar is a composite consideration and not separately as land and building," the tribunal observed, reinforcing that in the absence of a distinct segregation, the entire value qualifies for depreciation under Section 32 of the Income Tax Act .

Reliance on Established Precedents

To support its decision, the tribunal relied on established judicial precedents, including previous rulings in cases involving the National Housing Bank and Millennium Spire India Management. These decisions have consistently held that where a taxpayer pays a composite price for property without a specific breakdown in the agreement, the entirety of the expenditure is eligible for depreciation.

The bench also drew upon the Supreme Court’s decision in CIT vs. Max India Ltd. and the Bombay High Court’s ruling in CIT vs. Gabriel India Ltd. , which clarify that revisionary powers under Section 263 cannot be invoked merely because the Commissioner disagrees with a plausible, legally permissible view taken by an Assessing Officer after due inquiry.

The tribunal concluded that the record of the case demonstrated the AO had applied his mind to the details provided, including the registration deeds and the nature of the professional activity. Since the PCIT failed to identify any objective error or lack of investigation in the original assessment order, the tribunal ruled that the exercise of revisionary jurisdiction was improper.

By allowing the appeal, the ITAT effectively restored the original assessment order, providing relief to the Senior Advocate against the proposed additions to his taxable income. This ruling serves as a notable affirmation of the principle that professional practice from residential premises, when permitted by local urban planning regulations, does not automatically trigger deemed rental income, nor does the use of circle-rate valuations in stamp duty documents mandate the bifurcation of composite property assets for depreciation purposes.