The Bombay High Court on Wednesday set aside the sanction granted by the Board of Directors of ICICI Bank to prosecute its former Managing Director and Chief Executive Officer, Chanda Kochhar, in connection with alleged irregularities regarding loans provided to the Videocon Group. The court held that the sanction order, issued on May 15, 2023, was legally unsustainable, as the bank’s board lacked the statutory authority to approve such action. Consequently, all consequential proceedings initiated by the Special Court for the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) against Kochhar in the corruption case have been quashed.

Justice Milind N. Jadhav, presiding over the matter, emphasized that the authority to remove the head of a banking company and grant sanction for prosecution under the Prevention of Corruption (PC) Act, 1988, is exclusively vested in the Reserve Bank of India (RBI). The judgment underscored that the board of a private sector bank, constituted under the Companies Act, cannot override the specialized framework governing banking institutions.

"The sanction dated 15.05.2023 under challenge is illegal and deserves to be set aside on the ground that the authority that granted the same is not a competent authority and it completely failed to apply its mind to the material, or lack thereof, placed before it while granting sanction ," the court observed.

The legal dispute originated from an investigation initiated by the CBI in 2019 regarding various term loans sanctioned to the Videocon Group between 2009 and 2011. The investigative agency had alleged that Kochhar, while acting in her capacity as the Managing Director of the bank, approved these loans despite her husband, Deepak Kochhar, having business ties with the promoter of the Videocon Group. The CBI maintained that these transactions were part of a quid pro quo arrangement, resulting in a wrongful loss of approximately ₹1,033.39 crore to the bank.

In challenging the sanction, Kochhar’s legal team argued that the ICICI Bank board acted in violation of the statutory provisions mandated by the Banking Regulation (BR) Act, 1949. They contended that under Section 36-AA of the BR Act, the RBI serves as the sole authority competent to remove or terminate the services of a Managing Director or Chief Executive Officer of a banking company. By bypassing the RBI, the board acted without jurisdiction, rendering the sanction void ab initio.

The court validated these concerns, noting that the legislative intent behind the BR Act is to provide a comprehensive regulatory oversight that supersedes internal bank policies and the general provisions of the Companies Act. The court clarified that the power of removal carries with it the authority to sanction, and any attempt by the bank's internal board to assume this role is legally impermissible.

Beyond the issue of competence, the court expressed serious concern regarding the absence of an independent assessment of the evidence by the sanctioning authority. The judgment highlighted that the board merely relied upon the report submitted by the CBI without conducting a rigorous or independent scrutiny of the documents. This lack of application of mind further invalidated the sanction, as the process failed to demonstrate that the authority had carefully considered whether a prima facie case existed before granting permission for prosecution.

"Nullity of sanction goes to the root of prosecution's case in proceedings under the PC Act as it is a jurisdictional foundational fact and it would stand on the same pedestal as an absent sanction ," the bench stated in its order.

The ruling has immediate implications for the ongoing criminal trial. By declaring the sanction a nullity, the court effectively removed the prerequisite for the Special Court to take cognizance of the offenses against the former bank executive. The judge also noted that the bank itself had previously indicated in its records that no financial loss was suffered as a result of the loans, which further undermined the basis for the corruption allegations documented in the sanction request.

Following the pronouncement of the judgment, the representative for the CBI requested an eight-week stay on the order to facilitate an appeal before the Supreme Court of India. However, Justice Jadhav declined the request, maintaining that the procedural infirmities and the clear jurisdictional bar left no room for the impugned sanction to remain in effect.

The decision brings a significant development to the long-standing legal battle surrounding the alleged loan fraud. While the investigative agency can seek appropriate legal remedies, the court’s order forces a re-evaluation of the procedural foundation upon which the criminal prosecution against Kochhar was built. The court’s reliance on the statutory hierarchy established by the BR Act and the necessity of independent application of mind by the sanctioning authority underscores the protective safeguards embedded in the law to prevent vexatious or procedurally defective prosecutions against public servants and banking officials.

As the matter stands, the quashing of the sanction and the resulting nullification of the special court’s cognizance represent a major setback for the investigating agency’s efforts to proceed with the case in its current form. The legal proceedings in the trial court, which were pending at the stage of framing charges, have been halted by the quashing of the sanctioning order, leaving the burden on the prosecution to decide whether to pursue the requisite approvals from the appropriate authority or challenge the High Court’s ruling in a higher appellate forum.