The Gauhati High Court has clarified that the dishonour of a cheque on the grounds of a bank merger does not automatically preclude criminal proceedings under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881. Ruling on a petition filed by M/S Naman Enterprise, the court emphasized that such technical banking issues, alongside the determination of a legally enforceable debt, must be adjudicated during the trial process rather than being summarily dismissed under Section 528 of the Bharatiya Nagrik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS).

The case stemmed from a commercial dispute between M/S Naman Enterprise, a proprietorship firm based in Mangaldai, and M/S Gopi Mohan Drug Distributor, a wholesale supplier of medical and surgical items. The complainant alleged that the petitioner had maintained a long-standing business relationship involving the supply of products on credit. It was claimed that a balance of ₹75,650 remained unpaid, and in discharge of this liability, the petitioner issued a cheque on December 4, 2024. When the complainant deposited the instrument into their HDFC Bank account, the bank returned it with the specific remark “Bank merged.”

The petitioner sought to quash the resulting criminal complaint—registered as NI Case No. 412 of 2025—and the subsequent issuance of a bailable warrant by the Judicial Magistrate First Class-2, Kamrup (Metro). The core of the petitioner’s argument, supported by a reference to an earlier Allahabad High Court judgment, was that the amalgamation of the erstwhile Allahabad Bank with the Indian Bank as of April 1, 2020, rendered any outstanding cheques from the former entity invalid. Consequently, the petitioner argued that the presentation of such an instrument could not constitute a valid offence under the Negotiable Instruments Act.

However, Justice Shamima Jahan, presiding over the matter, declined to accept this interpretation as a ground for quashing the proceedings. The court noted that the question of whether a cheque has become technically invalid due to structural banking changes, and whether it represents a genuine legally enforceable debt, involves disputed questions of fact that fall within the mandate of the trial court to resolve upon hearing evidence.

Judicial Interpretation of Banking Disruptions

In her analysis, Justice Jahan examined the broader principles governing the dishonour of cheques. The court referred to established legal precedents, noting that the legislative intent behind Section 138 is to provide a robust mechanism for commercial security. Relying on the Supreme Court’s reasoning in Laxmi Dyechem vs. State of Gujarat , the High Court reiterated that the expression “insufficiency of funds” serves as a genus for various forms of cheque dishonour. Reasons such as an account being closed, signatures not matching, or, in this instance, technical hurdles arising from a bank merger, are treated as species of that genus, provided the fundamental requirement of an existing debt remains.

The court further observed that placing the burden of identifying the exact status of a bank’s merger on the payee would be unreasonable. "The complainant could not be reasonably expected to know that cheques issued by Account holders of the erstwhile Allahabad Bank , had become invalid after the merger and that the Indian Bank was under no obligation to honour such cheques," Justice Jahan observed. The court emphasized that these matters fall within the internal knowledge of banking institutions and cannot serve as a blanket shield for the drawer of a cheque against criminal prosecution.

Procedural Scope of Section 528 BNSS

The High Court also addressed the limits of its inherent powers under Section 528 of the BNSS. In line with the guidelines laid down by the Supreme Court in State of Haryana and others v. Bhajan Lal , the court reiterated that its extraordinary jurisdiction is to be exercised sparingly. Quashing a criminal complaint is only appropriate when the allegations, even if accepted at face value, fail to disclose an offence or if the proceeding is clearly an abuse of the legal process.

In the present case, the court found that the petitioner’s arguments concerning the ledger accounts and the nature of the cheque—specifically the claim that it was merely a "security cheque"—amounted to factual contentions. These issues, the court maintained, must be tested during trial where both parties have the opportunity to lead evidence. The court noted that there exists a statutory presumption that a cheque is issued for valid consideration, and it is incumbent upon the petitioner to rebut this during the trial court proceedings.

Next Steps for the Parties

By dismissing the petition, the court has allowed the criminal proceedings against M/S Naman Enterprise to continue before the magistrate. The complainant now has the opportunity to present evidence regarding the supply of goods and the existence of the unpaid debt, while the petitioner retains the right to present a defense regarding the nature of the cheque and the validity of the underlying liability.

This judgment reinforces the principle that technical hurdles occurring in the banking sector, such as mergers or administrative restructurings, do not automatically invalidate the legal obligations created through cheques. The decision affirms that while banking operations undergo change, the core accountability under the Negotiable Instruments Act remains intact, ensuring that commercial transactions are not derailed by administrative technicalities at the initial stage of litigation. The magistrate is expected to proceed with the trial, providing both parties a fair hearing to resolve the underlying financial dispute.