State Of Haryana vs Indira - 2003 Supreme(SC) 751

Judicial Analysis Court Copy Headnote Facts Arguments Court observation

2003 Supreme(SC) 751

S. B. SINHA
State Of Haryana – Appellant
Versus
Indira – Respondent

ORDER

The respondents herein were in the service of the appellant-State as Language Teachers. They were appointed a long time back.

2. The question which arises for consideration in these appeals is as to whether the Certificate of Junior Basic Training Course (for short "J.B.T.") is equivalent to that of Orientation Training (for short "O.T.").

3. The essential qualification for holding of the post of Language Teacher is said to be "(i) Matric from Punjab University or Board of School Education Haryana or an equivalent qualification recognised by the said Board; (ii) Prabhakar (Honours in Hindi) from a recognised University; and (iii) pass in LTC (OT) examination in Hindi conducted by the Haryana Education Department or an equivalent qualification recognised by the Haryana Education Department - OR - Graduate from a recognised University with Hindi as an elective subject/M.A. in Hindi from a recognised University/B.A. (Honours) in Hindi with B.T./B.Ed. or equivalent in all the cases." The said qualification was laid down by the appellant-State by amending the Punjab Educational Service Rules, 1955 by reason of Punjab Educational Service, Class-III School Cadre (First Amendment) Rules