SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

1996 Supreme(SC) 25

SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
K. RAMASWAMY, JJ
VALSAMMA PAUL
Vs.
COCHIN UNIVERSITY
Decided on January 4, 1996

Important Points

Reservation benefits under Articles 15(4) and 16(4) are intended for those born into backward classes who suffered historical disabilities. A person from a forward class cannot claim these benefits through marriage, adoption, or conversion, as they did not experience the social and educational backwardness the reservations aim to remedy.

Subject

Constitutional Law - RESERVATION

Act Referred

Headnote

Constitution of India,1950 - Articles 15 (4), 14, 15, 16, 21, 38, 39, 46 and 16 (4) - Hindu Marriage Act - Section 7a - Protection of Human Rights Act - Section 12 - Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 - Section 125 - Hindu Minority and Maintenance Act - Claiming protective discrimination - Importance to harmonize personal law of the citizens - Environment and social disabilities are also relevant factors - Handicaps and disadvantages - posts of Lecturers in Law Department of Cochin University were notified for recruitment, one of was reserved for Latin Catholics - Appellant Syrian Catholic having married a Latin Catholic, had applied for selection as a reserved candidate - University selected her on basis and accordingly appointed reserved post - Her appointment was questioned by filing a writ petition, praying for a direction to University to appoint her in place of the appellant to said post - Learned single Judge allowed the writ petition and held appointment should be made strictly in accordance with Rules the Kerala State Subordinate Services Rules - When appeals were filed - Bench in impugned judgment held though appellant was married according to the Canon Law, the appellant being a Syrian Catholic by birth, by marriage with a Latin Catholic is not a member of that class by marriage – Held, Latin Catholic rites and acceptance of her as member of that community they did not advert to constitutional mandate adverted to hereinbefore - Learned single Judge and the Division Bench did not correctly decide law - Equally learned single Judge of the Delhi High Court too did not lay the law correctly aforesaid reasons, had rightly concluded appellant is not entitled to the benefit of reservation under Article 16 (4) as a lecturer which post was reserved for the backward class Latin Catholic community - Orders of Division Bench and the single Judge stand set aside - Full Bench judgment stands confirmed but, in the circumstances, parties are directed to bear their own costs throughout - Appeal is allowed

Legal Category Hierarchy

  • constitutional law
    • fundamental rights
      • equality and non-discrimination
        • reservation for backward classes (Para 6, 9, 33, 34)
  • administrative law
    • public employment
      • recruitment and reservation (Para 2, 37)
  • family law
    • marriage
      • inter-caste marriage (Para 20, 30)
      • social status of spouse (Para 31)
    • adoption (Para 13, 14)
  • human rights
    • international conventions

Table of Contents

1. Appointment to a reserved post for backward classes by a person born into a forward class who married into the reserved community — Challenge to appointment. (Para 1 , 2 )

2. Whether marriage into a backward class and subsequent social acceptance entitle a forward-class person to reservation benefits versus whether reservation is strictly birth-based. (Para 4 , 5 )

3. Reservation aims to remove historical social and educational handicaps; voluntary transplantation via marriage or adoption does not replicate the lifelong disabilities of birth. (Para 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 , 22 , 23 , 24 , 25 , 26 , 27 , 28 , 29 , 30 , 31 )

4. Persons born into forward classes are ineligible for reservation under Articles 15(4) and 16(4) despite marriage or adoption into a backward class. (Para 33 , 34 )

5. Appeals dismissed — Appointment against reserved post held invalid — Full Bench judgment confirmed. (Para 37 , 38 , 39 )

6. Does marriage into a backward class entitle a person to reservation benefits?

No. Reservation under Articles 15(4) and 16(4) is intended to remove historical handicaps and disabilities suffered by those born into backward classes. A person born into a forward class does not suffer these lifelong disabilities and cannot claim reservation through marriage. (Para 33 , 34 )

7. Does adoption into a backward class grant eligibility for reserved seats?

No. Voluntary mobility via adoption does not entitle a person born into a forward class to reservation, as they have not undergone the social, educational, and cultural backwardness the reservation is designed to remedy. (Para 13 , 34 )

8. Is community recognition a sufficient condition for claiming reservation status?

No. While community recognition is relevant for social status or reconversion cases, it is not a pre-condition or sufficient ground for reservation if the candidate had an advantageous start in life as a forward-class member. (Para 32 , 36 )

9. How does the court distinguish reconversion cases from marriage or adoption cases regarding reservation?

In reconversion, a person returns to their original caste of birth. If they genuinely abjure the new faith and are accepted by the original community, their original caste status may revive, unlike voluntary transplantation via marriage or adoption. (Para 35 )

( 1 ) THESE appeals by special leave arise from the judgment dated 18/01/1995 of the Full Bench of the Kerala High Court in writ appeals Nos. 416 and 187 of 1992. The Division Bench, doubting the correctness of the judgment in Public Service Commission v. Dr. Kanjamma Alex, (1981) Ker LT 24 : (1981 Lab IC 1511), (subject matter of CA No. 1197/81) had referred the question to the Full Bench. Facts lie in a short compass and are stated as under:

( 2 ) TWO posts of Lecturers in Law Department of Cochin University were notified for recruitment, one of which was reserved for Latin Catholics (Backward Class-Fishermen ). The appellant, a Syrian Catholic (a forward class), having married a Latin Catholic, had applied for selection as a reserved candidate. The University selected her on that basis and accordingly appointed against the reserved post. Her appointment was questioned by one Rani George by filing a writ petition, viz. , O. P. No. 9450/91 praying for a direction to the University to appoint her in place of the appellant to the said post. The learned single Judge allowed the writ petition of Rani George and held that the appointment should be made strictly in accordance with Rules 14 to 17 of the Kerala State Subordinate Services Rules. When appeals were filed, the appellant cited the judgment of a single Judge in Dr. Kanjamma Alex v. Public Service Commission, (1980) Ker LT 18: (1980 Lab IC NOC 48), which later stood upheld in Public Service Commission v. Dr. Kanjamma Alex, (1981) Ker LT 24: (1981 Lab IC 1511 ). As stated earlier, doubting the correctness of the decision of the Division Bench in Dr. Kanjamma Alexs case, the reference to the Full Bench had come to be made.

( 3 ) THE Full Bench in the impugned judgment held that though the appellant was married according to the Canon Law, the appellant; being a Syrian Catholic by birth, by marriage with a Latin Catholic (Backward Class), is not a member of that class by marriage. The special provisions under Articles 15 (4) and 16 (4) of the Constitution intended for the advancement of socially and educationally backward classes of citizens cannot be defeated by including candidates by alliance or by any other mode of joining the community. It would tantamount to making a mockery of the Constitutional exercise of identification of socially and educationally backward classes of citizen. Accordingly, the Full Bench overruled the decision of the Division Bench and of the single Judge referred to herein before. The appellant challenging the Division Bench Judgment in respect of Dr. Kanjamma Alex, (Civil Appeal No. 1197/81) is placed before us along with these appeals.

( 4 ) THE question is one of Constitutional importance to harmonize the personal law of the citizens and the constitutional goal, viz. to accord equal opportunity to the disadvantaged social segments, envisaged in Articles 16 (4) and 15 (4) of the Constitution. Shri T. L. V. Iyer, learned senior counsel for the appellant, contended that though the appellant is a Syrian Catholic (a forward class)by birth and had voluntarily married J. Yesudas, a Latin Catholic (Fishermen community), admittedly a backward class she had entered into the marital home of her husband in the year 1982 and was received and recognised by the community as a member of Latin Catholic. Due to her marriage, she has subjected herself and suffered all the environment disabilities to which her husband, J. Yesudas, was subjected and to which all other members of backward class in the region are subjected to. She cannot, therefore, be discriminated by denying equality given by Article 16 (4) of the Constitution. He elaborated the contention arguing that birth by itself is not a determinative factor for claiming protective discrimination given to the backward classes. Environment and social disabilities are also relevant factors to which the appellant had volunteered by subjecting herself to them and that, therefore, she is entitled to the same treatment











































1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top