2017 Supreme(SC) 1720

SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
A.K. SIKRI, ASHOK BHUSHAN, JJ.
State of Uttarakhand and Others – Appellants
Versus
Kumaon Stone Crusher – Respondent
C.A. No. 14446 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 3189 of 2012, C.A. No. 14448 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 1675 of 2012, C.A. No. 14922 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 8713 of 2008, C.A. No. 14924 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 10601 of 2008, C.A. No. 14923 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 9523 of 2008, C.A. No. 14920 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 6959 of 2008, C.A. No. 14921 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 6958 of 2008, C.A. No. 14452 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 950 of 2012, C.A. No. 14453 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 1031 of 2012, C.A. No. 14464 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 948 of 2012, C.A. No. 14465 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 1169 of 2012, C.A. No. 14468 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 1197 of 2012, C.A. No. 14469-14476 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 2213-2220 of 2012, C.A. No. 14485 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 1697 of 2012, C.A. No. 14486 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 2082 of 2012, C.A. No. 14492 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 2236 of 2012, C.A. No. 14493 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 2081 of 2012, C.A. No. 14495 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 2399 of 2012, C.A. No. 14497-14509 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 3152-3164 of 2012, C.A. No. 14510-14523 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 2938-2951 of 2012, C.A. No. 13122-13129 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 3192-3199 of 2012, C.A. No. 13300 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 1822 of 2012, C.A. No. 13301 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 4832 of 2012, C.A. No. 13313-13319 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 4002-4008 of 2012, C.A. No. 13320 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 6144 of 2012, C.A. No. 13346-13358 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 3512-3524 of 2012, C.A. No. 13360-13378 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 3320-3338 of 2012, C.A. No. 13386-13395 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 3490-3499 of 2012, C.A. No. 13405-13408 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 13019-13022 of 2012, C.A. No. 13411-13426 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 12808-12823 of 2012, C.A. No. 13448-13463 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 3624-3639 of 2012, C.A. No. 13488 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 6822 of 2012, C.A. No. 13427 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 11395 of 2013, C.A. No. 13518 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 6614 of 2012, C.A. No. 13542 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 6807 of 2012, C.A. No. 13559 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 5965 of 2012, C.A. No. 13575 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 4761 of 2012, C.A. No. 13578-13580 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 4882-4884 of 2012, C.A. No. 13602-13605 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 6047-6050 of 2012, C.A. No. 13621 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 5911 of 2012, C.A. No. 13430-13446 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 11917-11933 of 2013, C.A. No. 13465-13487 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 16261-16283 of 2013, C.A. No. 13489-13517 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 16316-16344 of 2013, C.A. No. 13627 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 6715 of 2012, C.A. No. 13428 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 21930 of 2009, C.A. No. 13385 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 12318 of 2009, C.A. No. 13397 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 12530 of 2009, C.A. No. 13520-13533 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 16285-16298 of 2013, C.A. No. 13645 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 5760 of 2012, C.A. No. 13675-13699 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 6147-6171 of 2012, C.A. No. 13714-13718 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 8991-8995 of 2012, C.A. No. 13409 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 11846 of 2009, C.A. No. 13536 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 12577 of 2013, C.A. No. 13741 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 6532 of 2012, C.A. No. 13786 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 6588 of 2012, C.A. No. 13787 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 6937 of 2012, C.A. No. 13788 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 5558 of 2012, C.A. No. 13792-13813 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 12967-12988 of 2012, C.A. No. 13816-13828 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 12989-13001 of 2012, C.A. No. 13829 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 7199 of 2012, C.A. No. 13830 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 7702 of 2012, C.A. No. 13745-13759 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 16846-16860 of 2013, C.A. No. 13935 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 8775 of 2012, C.A. No. 13936 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 10499 of 2012, C.A. No. 13537-13541 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 16299-16303 of 2013, C.A. No. 13937 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 7491 of 2012, C.A. No. 14076-14078 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 8465-8467 of 2012, C.A. No. 13760-13770 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 2776-2786 of 2014, C.A. No. 14080-14100 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 15501-15521 of 2012, C.A. No. 14101-14117 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 15611-15627 of 2012, C.A. No. 14118-14132 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 15430-15444 of 2012, C.A. No. 14134-14145 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 15405-15416 of 2012, C.A. No. 13544 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 12578 of 2013, C.A. No. 14146 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 12176 of 2012, C.A. No. 13606 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 12657 of 2014, C.A. No. 14157-14176 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 15446-15465 of 2012, C.A. No. 14178-14190 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 16989-17001 of 2012, C.A. No. 14192-14193 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 15543-15544 of 2012, C.A. No. 14194-14206 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 15417-15429 of 2012, C.A. No. 13545 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 13521 of 2013, C.A. No. 14207-14225 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 15466-15484 of 2012, C.A. No. 14227-14247 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 15522-15542 of 2012, C.A. No. 14249-14264 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 15485-15500 of 2012, C.A. No. 14266 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 16970 of 2012, C.A. No. 14268 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 12948 of 2012, C.A. No. 13622 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 12659 of 2014, C.A. No. 13626 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 13683 of 2014, C.A. No. 13637 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 12658 of 2014, C.A. No. 13646 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 12661 of 2014, C.A. No. 13700 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 13684 of 2014, C.A. No. 14270-14271 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 15401-15402 of 2012, C.A. No. 14274-14275 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 15795-15796 of 2012, C.A. No. 14277-14278 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 13776-13777 of 2012, C.A. No. 14282 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 13774 of 2012, C.A. No. 14147-14148 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 9093-9094 of 2008, C.A. No. 14284-14291 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 15547-15554 of 2012, C.A. No. 14294-14306 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 15591-15603 of 2012, C.A. No. 14307 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 14738 of 2012, C.A. No. 14309 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 15804 of 2012, C.A. No. 14311 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 13148 of 2012, C.A. No. 14315-14322 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 15555-15562 of 2012, C.A. No. 13771-13780 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 11380-11389 of 2013, C.A. No. 14328-14339 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 15571-15582 of 2012, C.A. No. 14348-14355 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 15583-15590 of 2012, C.A. No. 14357-14364 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 15563-15570 of 2012, C.A. No. 14368-14374 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 15604-15610 of 2012, C.A. No. 14376 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 15445 of 2012, C.A. No. 14378 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 16973 of 2012, C.A. No. 14381 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 16972 of 2012, C.A. No. 14382-14392 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 17016-17026, C.A. No. 14393-14404 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 17004-17015 of 2012, C.A. No. 14406-14407 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 15545-15546 of 2012, C.A. No. 14292 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 15896 of 2010, C.A. No. 13558 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 18661 of 2013, C.A. No. 14409-14410 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 16987-16988 of 2012, C.A. No. 14414-14423 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 16975-16984 of 2012, C.A. No. 14426-14444 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 16951-16969 of 2012, C.A. No. 14447 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 13640 of 2012, C.A. No. 14449-14451 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 34773-34775 of 2012, C.A. No. 13574 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 18665 of 2013, C.A. No. 14454-14463 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 23589-23598 of 2012, C.A. No. 14466-14467 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 19075-19076 of 2012, C.A. No. 13576 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 18664 of 2013, C.A. No. 14272 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 11923 of 2009, C.A. No. 13781 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 11392 of 2013, C.A. No. 14477 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 17003 of 2012, C.A. No. 13379 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 24106 of 2007, C.A. No. 14177 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 17666 of 2008, C.A. No. 14191 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 22322 of 2008, C.A. No. 14248 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 20675 of 2008, C.A. No. 14226 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 22629 of 2008, C.A. No. 13535 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 18094 of 2011, C.A. No. 13106-13116 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 26555-26565 of 2012, C.A. No. 13302-13312 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 2812-2822 of 2014, C.A. No. 13546-13557 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 27709-27720 of 2012, C.A. No. 13560-13571 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 23599-23610 of 2012, C.A. No. 14273 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 17572 of 2009, C.A. No. 13577 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 22760 of 2013, C.A. No. 13464 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 22363 of 2010, C.A. No. 13447 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 21868 of 2010, C.A. No. 13321-13344 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 2788-2811 of 2014, C.A. No. 13581-13600 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 24075-24094 of 2012, C.A. No. 13607-13620 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 23682-23695 of 2012, C.A. No. 13623-13624 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 21030-21031 of 2012, C.A. No. 13543 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 26825 of 2011, C.A. No. 13628-13636 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 24065-24073 of 2012, C.A. No. 13638-13644 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 26464-26470 of 2012, C.A. No. 13601 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 22761 of 2013, C.A. No. 13647-13674 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 26610-26637 of 2012, C.A. No. 13701-13713 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 26662-26674 of 2012, C.A. No. 13721-13740 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 26639-26658 of 2012, C.A. No. 13359 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 23547 of 2005, C.A. No. 14276 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 18760 of 2009, C.A. No. 14279 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 18843 of 2009, C.A. No. 13118 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 26273 of 2004, C.A. No. 13121 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 24889 of 2004, C.A. No. 13938 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 27324 of 2012, C.A. No. 14265 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 22635 of 2008, C.A. No. 13939-14074 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 30398-30533 of 2012, C.A. No. 14267 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 21844 of 2008, C.A. No. 14269 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 24768 of 2008, C.A. No. 14079 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 27326 of 2012, C.A. No. 14133 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 17217 of 2009, C.A. No. 14478-14484 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 33163-33169 of 2012, C.A. No. 13130 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 2294 of 2008, C.A. No. 14487-14491 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 33170-33174 of 2012, C.A. No. 14280 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 29725 of 2009, C.A. No. 14494 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 30535 of 2012, C.A. No. 14293 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 27511 of 2011, C.A. No. 14308 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 27487 of 2011, C.A. No. 14496 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 32133 of 2012, C.A. No. 14524 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 34384 of 2012, C.A. No. 14310 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 27840 of 2011, C.A. No. 14075 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 32029 of 2012, C.A. No. 14525-14531 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 36975-36981 of 2012, C.A. No. 14532 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 30185 of 2012, C.A. No. 13719-13720 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 34637-34638 of 2014, C.A. No. 14281 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 27771 of 2009, C.A. No. 13105 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 29549 of 2016, C.A. No. 14283 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 31868 of 2009, C.A. No. 14534-14536 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 37685-37687 of 2012, C.A. No. 14537 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 37683 of 2012, C.A. No. 13519 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 33180 of 2010, C.A. No. 14538 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 37576 of 2012, C.A. No. 13117 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 35807 of 2016, C.A. No. 14312-14314 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 31530-31532 of 2011, C.A. No. 14323-14326 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 32620-32623 of 2011, C.A. No. 13398 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 35680 of 2015, C.A. No. 13410 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 35673 of 2015, C.A. No. 13429 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 35682 of 2015, C.A. No. 14919 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 6956 of 2008, C.A. No. 13119 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 35813 of 2016, C.A. No. 13380-13384 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 4943-4947 of 2013, C.A. No. 14327 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 1398 of 2012, C.A. No. 14340-14347 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 34909-34916 of 2011, C.A. No. 13396 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 4461 of 2013, C.A. No. 14356 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 36272 of 2011, C.A. No. 14365-14367 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 134-136 of 2012, C.A. No. 14375 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 1684 of 2012, C.A. No. 14377 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 2433 of 2012, C.A. No. 14379 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 1874 of 2012, C.A. No. 14380 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 1198 of 2012, C.A. No. 14405 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 1074 of 2012, C.A. No. 14408 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 652 of 2012, C.A. No. 14411 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 738 of 2012, C.A. No. 14412-14413 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 146-147 of 2012, C.A. No. 14424-14425 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 877-878 of 2012, C.A. No. 14445 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 981 of 2012, C.A. No. 13399-13404 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 8204-8209 of 2013, C.A. No. 13104 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 3457 of 2016, T.P. (C) No. 76, 77 of 2012, CONMT. PET. (C) No. 199-201 of 2014 In SLP (C) No. 31530-31532 of 2011, W.P.(C) No. 203 of 2009 (X), C.A. No. 2797 of 2008 (III-A), C.A. No. 2821 of 2008, SLP (C) No. 13656 of 2012 (XI), SLP (C) No. 15721 of 2012, C.A. No. 5652, 2739-2762, 2734, 2737, 2820, 2706, 2862-2863, 2732, 2819 of 2008, C.A. No. 1007, 1008 of 2011 (X), CONMT. PET. (C) No. 585-587 of 2016, In SLP (C) No. 31530-31532 of 2011, C.A. No. 13345 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 24804 of 2017, S.L.P. (C) ... (CC) No. 22596 of 2015, CONMT. PET. (C) No. 251 of 2008, C.A. No. 2797 of 2008 (III-A), C.A. No. 13131 of 2017, SLP (C) No. 24803 of 2017, SLP (C) ...(CC) 22210 of 2016, C.A. No. 1010 of 2011 (X), T.P. (C) No. 18, 44 of 2012, C.A. No. 2047 of 2006
Decided On : 15-09-2017