2022 Supreme(Kar) 1361
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
Krishna S.Dixit, J.
M.N. Lalitha - Appellant
Versus
Hindusthan Petroleum Corporation Limited - Respondent
Writ Petition No. 30674 of 2019, 11926/2019, 43490/2019, 30674/2019
Decided On : 03-01-2022
B.Pramod, Advocate, K.N.Nithish, Advocate, K.V.Narasimhan, Advocate, H.K.Pavan, Advocate, Venkatarami Reddy, Advocate, Adinarayan, Advocate
Efficient adjudication and management of related lawsuits, timely resolution of income management, and operation of business with specified conditions
Headnote:
Clubbing of Lawsuits - Consolidation of Lawsuits - The court ordered the consolidation of multiple lawsuits pending before different judges, directing that they be tried together by the same Senior Civil Judge within a specified time frame. The court also issued directives regarding the management of income from a specific property and the operation of a petrol bunk business, while allowing the parties to seek release of accumulated income under certain conditions.
Fact of the Case:
The court ordered the consolidation of multiple lawsuits pending before different judges and issued directives regarding the management of income from a specific property and the operation of a petrol bunk business.
Finding of the Court:
The court found that the lawsuits should be tried together by the same Senior Civil Judge within a specified time frame, and issued directives regarding the management of income from a specific property and the operation of a petrol bunk business. The court also allowed the parties to seek release of accumulated income under certain conditions.
Issues: Consolidation of lawsuits, management of income from a specific property, operation of petrol bunk business, release of accumulated income
Ratio Decidendi: The court's decision was based on the need for efficient adjudication of related lawsuits, ensuring timely resolution and management of income from a specific property, and allowing the operation of a petrol bunk business with certain conditions.
Final Decision: The court ordered the consolidation of the lawsuits, directed that they be tried together by the same Senior Civil Judge within a specified time frame, issued directives regarding the management of income from a specific property and the operation of a petrol bunk business, and allowed the parties to seek release of accumulated income under certain conditions.
JUDGMENT
1. All these writ petitions between the same parties were clubbed together by a Co-ordinate Bench of this Court for consideration, since common questions of law & facts have been involved. Both the sides having argued the matter at length are broadly in agreement with the suggestion of this Court to the following effect:
(i) The proceedings in O.S.No.588/2018 and O.S.No.54/2019, both pending on the file of learned Sr. Civil Judge at Mysore and the proceeding in O.S.No.157/2021 pending on the file of learned Sr. Civil Judge at Anekal, be clubbed and tried together by the Court of same Sr. Civil Judge at Mysore and for that purpose the suit in O.S.No.157/2021 be transferred to that court;
(ii) The pleadings in all the three suits should be completed forthwith and that the issues arising therefrom should be framed post-haste and further that the common evidence of all the parties be expeditiously recorded and further that all the suits should be heard and disposed off by the learned Sr. Civil Judge at Mysore within an outer limit of six months and further more that a compliance report be filed with the Registrar General of this Court; all contentions of the parties are kept open.
(iii) The income accruing from one of the suit properties namely the Petrol Bunk in question shall be subject to submission of a fortnightly true and correct account at the hands of respondent No.2 and that the said respondent shall deposit with the Mysore Court 35% of the gross income cumulatively accruing from the said Petrol Bunk once in fifteen days, without fail; while computing the said 35%, the expenses incurred for the said business shall not be deducted;
(iv) It is open to the petitioners to seek release of the accumulated 35% of the income as aforesaid every month at the hands of the Mysore Court by furnishing a Bank Guarantee therefor; the periodic deposit as directed above and its release shall be subject to the outcome of suit proceedings.
(v) The business of the Petrol Bunk shall be carried on by respondent No.2 subject to outcome of the suits and for that purpose, he can enter into the dealership agreements, their renewal and such other arrangements which are required to be done in due course of the business. Ordered accordingly and all the writ petitions are disposed off; the observations hereinabove made shall not influence the suit proceedings in any way. Costs made easy.