IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
B. Veerappa, T. Venkatesh Naik, JJ.
Muniyellappa – Appellant
Versus
V. Rashmi Mahesh – Respondent
Civil Contempt Petition No. 2507 of 2018
Decided On : 20-04-2023
Contempt of Courts Act - Willful Disobedience - Summary: The court addressed a Civil Contempt Petition under the provisions of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, against the accused for willful disobedience of a previous order. The accused failed to comply with the order passed by the learned single Judge, confirmed by the Division Bench, leading to the filing of the Contempt Petition. However, the Director of Collegiate Education, Bengaluru, filed an affidavit stating compliance with the orders, leading to the dropping of the contempt proceedings.
Fact of the Case:
The complainants filed a Civil Contempt Petition against the accused for willful disobedience of a previous order.
Finding of the Court:
The court dropped the contempt proceedings based on the affidavit filed by the Director of Collegiate Education, Bengaluru, stating compliance with the orders.
Issues: Compliance with the court order, willful disobedience, and dropping of contempt proceedings.
Ratio Decidendi: The court dropped the contempt proceedings subject to compliance with the orders as per the affidavit filed by the Director of Collegiate Education, Bengaluru.
Final Decision: Contempt Proceedings are hereby dropped, subject to compliance of the Order passed as per Annexures-R1 to R3 to the affidavit dtd. 19/4/2023.
JUDGMENT/ORDER
B.VEERAPPA, J. - Complainants filed the present Civil Contempt Petition under the provisions of Ss. 11 and 12 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, against accused, alleging willful disobedience of the Order dtd. 18/1/2017 passed in W.P.Nos.963-965/ 2014, wherein, the learned single Judge, while allowing the writ petitions, quashed the endorsement dtd. 25/10/2013 issued by respondent No.2 and directed respondent No.2 to re- examine the claim or proposal dtd. 7/8/1990 in the light of the observations made in the order, expeditiously, and at any rate, within a period of three months from the date of receipt of certified copy of the Order. The said order, when challenged in W.A.Nos.5614/2017 and 6106-6107/2017, the co-ordinate Bench of this Court, by the Order dtd. 25/10/2017, disposed off the Writ Appeal, recording the prayer of learned Additional Government Advocate seeking four weeks' time to implement the order passed by the learned single Judge.
2. Since the accused failed to comply with the Order passed by the learned single Judge, confirmed by the Division Bench, the present Contempt Petition came to be filed on 13/12/2018. It is also relevant to note at this stage that, earlier, complainant Nos.2 and 3 had filed CCC Nos.867-945/2017 and this Court, by the Order dtd. 31/1/2019 dropped the contempt proceedings, taking on record the additional counter affidavit filed by Director of Collegiate Education, Higher Education Department stating that the Order has been complied with and unconditional apology for delay in complying the order.
3. In the present contempt petition, Dr.Appaji Gowda, Director of Collegiate Education, Bengaluru, filed the affidavit dtd. 19/4/2023, wherein, at paragraphs 5 and 6, it is stated as under:
"5. I most respectfully submit that, in compliance of the Orders passed by this Hon'ble court, the office of the Commissioner of Collegiate Education has positively considered the case of the Complainants for the purpose of admitting them to Grant-in-Aid as per the Order dtd. 30/1/2019. Copy of the said Order is herewith produced at Annexure-R1. Pursuant to the Order being passed by the Commissioner of Collegiate Education, the State of Karnataka also has passed an Order dtd. 11/2/2019, admitting the aforementioned Complainants to Grant-in-Aid and Orders were passed accordingly. Copy of the order passed by the State of Karnataka is produced herewith at Annexure-R2.
6. I most respectfully submit that pursuant to the aforementioned two (2) orders passed by our Department and State of Karnataka, the Complainants herein are also being paid salary as per Grant-in-Aid and also drawing the same accordingly. Copies of the orders for having disbursed salaries to the Complainants as per the Grant-in-Aid are produced herewith at AnnexureR3."
N
4. In view of the above, we pass the following:
ORDER
Contempt Proceedings are hereby dropped, subject to compliance of the Order passed as per Annexures-R1 to R3 to the affidavit dtd. 19/4/2023, stated supra. If for any reason, the order is not complied, it is always open for the complainants to file an application for revival of this Order in accordance with law.
The main legal point established is the requirement of compliance with court orders to avoid contempt proceedings.
The court found no grounds for contempt as the government complied with orders despite delays, emphasizing compliance assessment only.
Court emphasizes the obligation of authorities to comply with its orders and establishes a clear procedure for reporting compliance regarding the release of dues.
A contempt petition alleging wilful disobedience of a judgment in rem is non-maintainable; compliance with court orders must be ensured.
The court emphasized compliance with prior orders and established obligations for authorities to ensure timely execution of directives issued by the court.
Court emphasized mandatory compliance with earlier orders and set timelines for reporting back to the court regarding contempt petitions.
Court emphasized the obligation of compliance with prior orders, establishing a clear directive for the Commissioner, College Education to release dues to petitioners.
The court emphasized the obligation of the Commissioner, College Education, to comply with prior orders regarding the release of dues and report compliance, reinforcing the authority of the court's d....
Court emphasizes compliance with prior orders regarding the release of dues to petitioners, mandating clear reporting and obligations for authorities.
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.