Marathon Era Co-operative Housing Society Ltd vs Competent Authority & District Dy. Registrar , Cooperative Societies

Judicial Analysis Court Copy Headnote Facts Arguments Court observation

2024 Supreme(Bom) 607

G. S. PATEL
Marathon Era Co-operative Housing Society Ltd – Appellant
Versus
Competent Authority & District Dy. Registrar , Cooperative Societies – Respondent

Advocates appeared:
Mr DJ Khambata, Senior Advocate, with CS Balsara, Ali Antulay, NH Vakil & Suzan Vakil, i/b Mulla & Mulla & Craigie, Blunt & Caroe, for the Petitioner; Mr Pravin Samdani, Senior Advocate, with Karl Tamboly, Bindi Dave, Raghor Gupta & Kashish Mainkar, i/b Wadia Ghandy & Co, for Respondents nos 2 and 3, Mr Vivek Kantawala, with Amey Patil, & Shanay Bafna, i/b M/s Vivek Kantawala & Co. for Respondent no 5 and Mr BM Chatterjee, Senior Advocate, with Pooja Yadav, for MCGM, for respondent no 6, MCGM.

Table of Content
1. unilateral deemed conveyance under mofa (Para 1 , 2 , 3)
2. statutory obligations for land conveyance and fsi (Para 4 , 9 , 14)
3. facts of the marathon era development (Para 17 , 18 , 19 , 20)
4. requirements for the application of deemed conveyance. (Para 36)
5. arguments regarding entitlement to land and fsi (Para 37 , 38 , 41)
6. counterarguments on conveyance of appurtenant land (Para 50 , 55 , 56)
7. conclusion on petition and mandate for fresh application (Para 59 , 76)
8. court's dismissal of the petition with guidelines for reapplication. (Para 77 , 78)

JUDGMENT

CONTENTS

A. OVERVIEW OF THE ISSUES INVOLVED

B. THE FACTS IN THE MARATHON

WRIT PETITION

C. MARATHON ERA'S SUBMISSIONS

D. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE CONTESTING RESPONDENT

E. THE NEED FOR A CONVEYANCE EVEN BEFORE COMPLETION OF THE LAYOUT DEVELOPMENT

F. THE IMPUGNED ORDER

G. ADDITIONAL FSI

H. THE GOVERNMENT RESOLUTION OF 22ND JUNE 2018

I. ORDER

J. THE GULMOHAR PETITION

A. OVERVIEW OF THE ISSUES INVOLVED

1. In early 2018 the first of these Writ Petitions, Writ Petition No. 180 of 2018 ('the Marathon Writ Petition') came before me. The question raised was in regard to what is called a 'Unilateral Deemed Conveyance' under

Click Here to Read the rest of this document

2024 Supreme(Bom) 607

G. S. PATELMarathon Era Co-operative Housing Society Ltd – AppellantVersusCompetent Authority & District Dy. Registrar , Cooperative Societies – Respondent

Cases Referred (7)

G. S. PATEL
Marathon Era Co-operative Housing Society Ltd – Appellant
Versus
Competent Authority & District Dy. Registrar , Cooperative Societies – Respondent