2025 Supreme(Bom) 1450
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
SANDEEP V. MARNE, J.
Regus South Mumbai Business Centre Private Limited - Petitioner
Versus
Marie Gold Realtors Private Limited – Respondent
Commercial Arbitration Petition No. 439 of 2024
Decided On : 25-11-2025
Important Points
Subject
Arbitration - Commercial Dispute
Act Referred
EVIDENCE ACT : S.106
Headnote
Facts of the case:
The petitioner was to manage a business center according to a Business Plan, which it failed to meet, leading to a claim for damages by the respondent. The respondent incurred significant costs in establishing the premises, and the petitioner's inability to meet revenue projections led to the invocation of a bank guarantee and subsequent arbitration claims. (Paras 2, 3, 4, 28)
Findings of Court:
The court upheld the Arbitrator's findings regarding the petitioner's breach of the Management Agreement and the legitimacy of the awarded damages, asserting that the clause requiring the petitioner to endeavor to meet projections was enforceable. (Paras 36, 50)
Issues: Whether the Arbitrator correctly interpreted the obligations under the Management Agreement and whether the awarded damages were warranted. (Paras 12, 32, 35)
Ratio Decidendi: The Arbitrator established that mere failure to meet projections did not constitute a breach; however, not making adequate efforts to achieve those projections did amount to a breach of contract. The petitioner bore the onus of proving the efforts made, which it failed to demonstrate. (Paras 30, 38, 41, 42)
Result: Petition dismissed, and arbitral award upheld.
For the Petitioner:Mr. Zal Andhyarujina, Senior Advocate with Ms. Revati Desai, Mr. Manish Dembla, Mr. Muneeb Rashid Malik, Mr. Yash Pitroda, Mr. Digant Bhatt & Ms. Amrita N. i/b Mr. Mayur Shetty c/o. Kochhar & Co.
For the Respondent: Mr. Pradeep Sancheti, Senior Adv. with Mr. Pranav Sampat & Ms. Rakshika Bajpai i/b Khaitan & Co.
| Table of Content |
|---|
| 1. challenge of arbitration award based on contractual obligations. (Para 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6) |
| 2. arguments centered around breach and arbitration process. (Para 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 , 16) |
| 3. details of the management agreement and its implications. (Para 21 , 22 , 23 , 24 , 25 , 26 , 27 , 28 , 29 , 30) |
| 4. court’s evaluation of damages awarded and contractual interpretation. (Para 31 , 32 , 33 , 34 , 35) |
| 5. final dismissal of the arbitration petition and affirmation of the award. (Para 54 , 55) |
SANDEEP V. MARNE, J.
THE CHALLENGE
1) This Petition is filed by the Petitioner under the provisions of Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (Arbitration Act) challenging the Award dated 18 October 2019 passed by the learned sole Arbitrator. The learned Arbitrator has held the Petitioner to be in breach of the obligations under the terms of Management Agreement in failing to make endeavour to achieve revenue projections in the Business Plan furnished by it to the Respondent and has held that the Respondent is entitled to damages on that account. The learned Arbitrator has accordingly directed Petitioner to pay to the Respondent sum of Rs.10,10,01,000/- by way of damages alongwith interest @ of 12% p.a. from 31 July 2014 till payment and/or realisation alongwith cost of Rs.60,00,000/-. The claims raised by the Petitioner as well as other counter claims raised by the Respondent (except to the extent of award of damages of Rs.10,10,01,000/-) are rejected by the learned Arbitrator. Petitioner is aggrieved by the Award to the extent it allows the claim of Respondent for damages and rejects the claim of the Petitioner for refund of amount of Rs.2,25,00,000/- and has accordingly filed the present Petition challenging the Award.
FACTS
2) Petitioner and Respondent entered into a Management Agreement dated 20 December 2010 in respect of property owned and possessed by the Respondent as Ismail Building at Hutatma Chowk, Fort, Mumbai. Under the Management Agreement, Petitioner was to operate a business center from ground and mezzanine floors of the building by sharing 75% of the net turnover with the Respondent. Respondent was to refurbish, at its own cost and expense, the premises as per requirements of layout design and specifications provided by the Petitioner. According to the Petitioner, a tentative Business Plan was prepared with only indicative figures on the basis of then market conditions with respect to the estimated outflow of cost and inflow of turnover and profits to be generated out of performance of services in the premises. Such Business Plan was appended to the Management Agreement. The initial term of the Management Agreement was for the period of three years from practical completion, upon expiry of which Respondent was to take performance review of the business center and then take a call either to terminate the arrangement or to induct the Petitioner as a licensee in respect of the premises. Petitioner was required to furnish bank guarantee of Rs.2.25 crores, which was invocable upon happening of the specified events.
3) The Respondent handed over ground floor premises to the Petitioner on 15 April 2011 and mezzanine floor on 2 February 2012. According to the Petitioner, it discovered major multiplication errors in the Business Plan in October-2013. According to Petitioner it could not achieve the objective contained in the Business Plan appended to the Management Agreement on account of multiplication errors therein. Accordingly, the revised Business Plan was handed over to the Respondent. Petitioner had handed over bank guarantee dated 9 April 2011 to the Respondent of Rs.2.25 crores. Respondent invoked the bank guarantee on 16 January 2014 on the ground of alleged losses due to inability of the Petitioner to achieve the revenue targets as spelt out in the Business Plan. Respondent issued termination notice dated 21 January 2014 terminating the Management Agreement.
4) Petiti