IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Shampa Dutt (Paul), J.
21 Auto India Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. – Petitioner
Versus
Incred Financial Services Ltd. (Erstwhile known as Visu Leasing & Finance Private Limited) – Respondent
CRR 443 of 2020
Decided On : 19-06-2023
Indian Penal Code,1860 - Sections 420/406/120B - Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 - Section 203 - Whether existence or availment of civil remedy in respect of disputes arising from breach of contract bars remedy under criminal law - Held, Court case before us admittedly appellant was trapped in economic crisis and he had approached respondent no.2 to ameliorate situation of crisis - In order to recover aforesaid amount respondent no.2 had instituted a summary civil suit seeking recovery of loan amount which is still pending adjudication - Mere inability of appellant to return loan amount cannot give rise to a criminal prosecution for cheating unless fraudulent or dishonest intention is shown right at beginning of transaction as it is this mens rea which is crux of offence - Even if all complaint and material are take on their face value no such dishonest representation or inducement could be found or inferred - Petition Allowed.
JUDGMENT :
Shampa Dutt (Paul), J.
1. The present revision has been preferred praying for quashing and/or setting aside of proceedings arising out of complaint case No.CS-6781/19 of 2019 dated 2/2/2019 under Sections 420/406/120B of the Indian Penal Code, presently pending before the learned 19th Metropolitan Magistrate, at Kolkata and all orders passed therein including order dated 2/2/19 whereby the learned Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, Kolkata was pleased to take cognizance of the impugned complaint and transfer the proceedings to the Court of the learned 19th Metropolitan Magistrate, at Kolkata for disposal and all orders therein.
2. The petitioners case is that the petitioner no.1 is a company registered under the relevant provisions of the Companies Act having its registered office at Mohili Village opposite BMC School, Andheri, Ghatkopar, Mumbai, Maharastra-400072 being represented by its authorised representative, Mr. Abhishek Kharkar vide board resolution dated 14th December, 2019 and the petitioner nos.2 and 3 are the persons responsible for the day to day affairs of the petitioner no.1.
3. The petitioners state that they have been implicated in the proceeding being Complaint Case no.CS-6781/19 of 2019 dated 2/2/2019 under Sections 420/406/120B of the Indian Penal Code, presently pending before the learned 19th Metropolitan Magistrate at Kolkata at the behest of the opposite party.
4. The petitioner is a company having business of Honda dealership established for sales and services of Honda Two Wheelers and has goodwill and repute in the market.
5. The opposite party is a financial institution offering loan facility against interest.
6. In the year 2017 the petitioner company was in need of money to expand its business and hearing about the facility provided by the opposite party the petitioners have approached the opposite party for a loan for the purpose of expanding its business and pursuant to such approach and after due documentation and verification a loan agreement being Agreement No.LNMUM19117-180009070 of the year 15th September, 2017 has been executed by and in between the parties and pursuant to such agreement the opposite party sanctioned a loan of rupees 30 lacs to the petitioners.
7. The petitioners have paid back Rs.26,75,587/-to the opposite party through different installments.
8. That despite payment of such substantial amount, the opposite party has continued pressurizing the petitioner for payment of rest of the amount with interest, with immediate effect and also threatened the petitioner that in default the opposite party will implicate the petitioner in false criminal cases.
9. The incident which lead to the initiation of the impugned proceeding in brief is as follows:-
10. Mr. Anirban Dutta learned counsel for the petitioners has submitted that dishonest intention from the very inception is a sine qua non to attract Section 420 of the Indian Penal Code, but on a plain reading of the purported complaint, it becomes apparent that out of rupees 30 lacs, the petitioners have paid rupees 26,755,87 and only an amount of rupees 3,24,413 is due to the opposite party from the petitioners, which clearly negates the abovementioned proposition of dishonest intention from the very inception and clearly renders the said complaint legally untenable and otherwise bad in law.
11. The complaint is false, frivolo
Central Bureau of Investigation v. Duncans Agro Industries Ltd., Calcutta
Chelloor Mankkal Narayan Ittiravi Nambudiri v. State of Travancore, Cochin
Hridaya Ranjan Prasad Verma v. State of Bihar
Jaswantrai Manilal Akhaney v. State of Bombay
Madhavrao Jiwaji Rao Scindia v. Sambhajirao Chandrojirao Angre
Medchl Chemicals & Pharma (P) Ltd. v. Biological E. Ltd.
Rajesh Bajaj v. State NCT of Delhi
Rupan Deol Bajaj vs. Kanwar Pal Singh Gill
A mere breach of a promise, agreement, or contract does not, ipso facto, constitute the offence of criminal breach of trust contained in Section 405 IPC without there being a clear case of entrustmen....
The court reiterated that criminal proceedings should not be initiated when the allegations are purely civil in nature and there is no entrustment of property or dishonest intention on the part of th....
A breach of contract does not constitute cheating unless fraudulent intent is proven at the outset of the agreement, as established in relevant legal precedents.
The ingredients required to constitute the offenses of criminal breach of trust and cheating were not prima facie present against the petitioners.
The court reiterated the principles for quashing criminal proceedings at the threshold, emphasizing the distinction between civil and criminal wrongs. It held that criminal proceedings should not be ....
Fraudulent intent at the inception of a transaction is essential to establish cheating; mere breach of contract does not constitute a criminal offence.
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.