SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2018 Supreme(Del) 1447

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
MANMOHAN, J.
Mrs. Renu Mathur & Anr. - Plaintiffs
Versus
Mrs. Uma Narula & Ors. - Defendants
CS(OS) 1133 of 2015
Decided On : 04-07-2018

Important Points

The right to demand partition and to seek separate possession are recurring rights, and the substantive right of the co-owners to seek partition of the joint property would not stand extinguished by their predecessor's failure or delay in seeking partition.

Subject

Property Law - Partition and Ownership Disputes

Act Referred

CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE : O.23 R.1, O.23 R.1(3), O.23 R.1(4), O.9 R.9
LIMITATION ACT : Art.113, Art.65, S.27

Headnote

Partition - Property Dispute - Limitation Act - Probate Case - [PROPERTY DISPUTE] - [Limitation Act, Article 113, Section 27] - The court discussed the applicability of the Limitation Act, Article 113, and Section 27 in the context of a property dispute and the dismissal of a probate case. The court emphasized that the right to demand partition and to seek separate possession are recurring rights, and the substantive right of the co-owners to seek partition of the joint property would not stand extinguished by their predecessor's failure or delay in seeking partition. The court also highlighted that the dismissal of the probate petition did not amount to admission of ownership and that questions of title are not decided in probate proceedings.

Fact of the Case:

The suit was filed for the partition of a property owned by the late grandmother of the plaintiffs. The defendants raised objections based on the Limitation Act and the dismissal of a probate petition. The plaintiffs sought a preliminary decree of partition, while the defendants argued that the suit was barred by limitation and that the property had to be divided in accordance with a Will.

Finding of the Court:

The court found that the suit was not barred by limitation as the right to demand partition and to seek separate possession are recurring rights. The court also found that the dismissal of the probate petition did not amount to admission of ownership and that questions of title are not decided in probate proceedings.

Issues: The main issues revolved around the applicability of the Limitation Act, the dismissal of the probate petition, and the division of the property in accordance with a Will.

Ratio Decidendi: The court emphasized that the right to demand partition and to seek separate possession are recurring rights, and the substantive right of the co-owners to seek partition of the joint property would not stand extinguished by their predecessor's failure or delay in seeking partition. The court also highlighted that the dismissal of the probate petition did not amount to admission of ownership and that questions of title are not decided in probate proceedings.

Final Decision: A preliminary decree was passed defining the shares of the parties in the suit property.

Advocates:
Advocate Appeared:
For the Plaintiffs : Ms. Archana Sharma, Mr. Divakar Upadhyay
For the Defendants : Ms. Roopa Paul, Mr. Praveen Swarup, Mr. Sunil Choudhary, Mr. Jugal Wadhwa, Mr. Naresh Charnal, Mr. Rishabh Wadhwa, Mr. Bharat Deepak, Mr. Tarun Kapoor

JUDGMENT :

Manmohan, J.

1. Present suit has been filed for partition of property bearing No. D-39, Hauz Khas, New Delhi-110015 admeasuring 273 sq.yards (207 sq. mtrs.) [hereinafter referred to as "suit property"] owned by late grandmother of the plaintiffs. Plaintiffs jointly seek 1/6th share in the suit property.

2. On the oral prayer of learned counsel for legal heirs of defendant No.3, they are impleaded as defendants and the plaintiffs are directed to file an amended memo of parties within a period of one week.

3. The parties are first cousins as well as maternal uncles and aunt of the plaintiffs. Defendant No.2 (a daughter of deceased owner) and legal heirs of defendant No.3 (another daughter of deceased owner) support the plaintiffs. Defendants No.5 to 8 are legal heirs of late Mr. Yoginder Kumar Mehra, son of the deceased owner. Defendants No.9 to 12 are the legal heirs of late Mr. Ashok Mehra, another son of the deceased owner.

4. Learned counsel for plaintiffs as well as defendant No.2 and legal heirs of defendant No.3 prayed for a preliminary decree of partition forthwith as, according to them, the defences of defendants No.1, 5 to 8 and 9 to 12 namely of limitation and of a Will having been executed by the deceased owner were untenable in law.

5. The counsel for plaintiffs as well as defendant No.2 and legal heirs of defendant No.3 pointed out that late Yoginder Kumar Mehra, predecessor-in-interest of defendants No.5 to 8 and elder son of deceased owner, had filed a Probate Case No.35 of 1988 with regard to the alleged Will dated 17th October, 1978 executed by the owner, which was dismissed vide order dated 12th February, 2001, by a Coordinate Bench of this Court. They stated that the order dated 12th February, 2001 was an order “in rem” and the said order had become final as the same had not been challenged. Therefore, according to them, the defendants No.1, 5 to 8 and 9 to 12 could not rely upon the Will dated 17th October, 1978.

6. However, Ms. Roopa Paul, learned counsel for defendant No.1, Mr. Jugal Wadhwa, learned counsel for defendants No.5 to 8 and Mr. Bharat Deepak, learned counsel for defendants No.9 to 12 submitted that the present suit was barred by limitation as it had been filed twenty-seven years after the death of the owner and fourteen years after the probate petition filed by the predecessor-in-interest of defendants No.5 to 8 had been dismissed. Learned counsel for defendants No.1, 5 to 8 and 9 to 12 submitted that a suit for partition is governed by Article 113 of the Limitation Act and the limitation period prescribed is three years. They further submitted that the limitation would start from the date the right to sue had accrued, i.e., when party had noticed that its right had been denied. According to them, the right to sue if any, accrued in favour of Smt. Chand Mathur, mother of the plaintiffs, as early as 1988 when the notice of the probate petition had been served upon her and at best on 12th February, 2001, when the probate petition had been dismissed. They submitted that however Smt. Chand Mathur neither claimed any right in the suit property, nor contested the probate petition nor filed any counter claim/suit for partition or possession within the statutory limitation period. The relief of partition claimed by the plaintiffs was thus, according to them, barred by limitation.

7. In support of their submissions, they relied upon the judgment of this Court in Gulab Chaudhary Vs. Govinder Singh Dahiya & Anr., 189 (2012) DLT 236 wherein it has been held as under:-

“8. In my opinion, the suit which was filed on 2.11.2006 seeking rights in the suit property for declaration and injunction was clearly barred by time inasmuch as form of the suit cannot conceal the real nature of the suit, and which was really a suit for partition and possession of the property which belonged to the father. A suit for possession of an immovable property is covered by Article 65 of the Limitation Act, 1963 and as per which,























































1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top