SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Judicial Analysis Court Copy Headnote Facts Arguments Court observation
Listen Audio Icon Pause Audio Icon
judgment-img

2023 Supreme(Guj) 627

IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
N.V. ANJARIA, NIRAL R. MEHTA, JJ.
DIVYANGBHAI JAYENDRABHAI SHAH – Petitioner
Versus
THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX – Respondent
Special Civil Application Nos. 4243, 4244, 4257, 4337, 4353, 4354, 4397, 4416, 4417, 4423, 4424, 4425, 4426, 4427, 4429, 4430, 4431, 4433, 4434, 4435, 4436, 4437, 4438, 4439, 4440, 4441, 4442, 4443, 4444, 4445, 4446, 4447, 4460, 4468, 4469, 4470 of 2023
Decided On : 13-03-2023

Advocates:
Advocate Appeared:
For the Petitioners: TUSHAR HEMANI, PARIMALSINH PARMAR.
For the Respondents: NIKUNT RAVAL, KALPANA RAVAL, VARUN PATEL, DEV PATEL.

Headnote:

Constitution of India,1950 - Article 226 - Income Tax Act, 1961 - Section 148A(d) - Special Civil Application - Issued for re-opening of assessment - Challenge the notices – Held, all such notices when they would relate to Assessment Year or Assessment Year would be time barred as per provisions of the Act as applicable in the old regime prior - These notices cannot be issued as per amended provision of Act - Learned advocate for Revenue was entirely at his receiving end, unable to dispute the position of law holding field as above - All impugned notices in respective petitions under section 148 of Act relatable to Assessment year , as case may be, are beyond permissible time limit, liable to be treated illegal and without jurisdiction - Petitions stand allowed

JUDGMENT :

N.V. ANJARIA, J.

1. Leave to amend is granted in Special Civil Application No. 4442 of 2023. To be carried out forthwith.

All these Special Civil Applications seeking to challenge the notices issued for re-opening of the assessment for the assessment years concerned under Section 148 and the orders passed under Section 148A(d) of the Income Tax Act, 1961.

1.1 The petitions involve similar facts and identical issues, therefore, they were heard together to be treated for disposal by this common judgment and order.

1.2 In the facts and circumstances of the case, having regard to the issues involved and with consent and request of learned advocates for the parties, all these Special Civil Applications were taken up for final consideration today.

2. Rule returnable in each of the Special Civil Applications forthwith. Learned advocates Mrs. Kalpana K. Raval and Mr. Varun Patel for the respondent Revenue waive service of Rule in the respective petitions.

2.1 Heard learned senior advocate Mr. Tushar Hemani assisted by learned advocate Mr. Parimalsinh Parmar for the petitioners and learned advocate for the respondent.

3. In the present petitions filed under Article 226 of the Constitution, the respective petitioners have called in question the notice issued by respondent-assessing officer under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 seeking to reopen the assessment in respect of assessment year 2013-14 or assessment year 2014-15 as the case may be. Also challenged are the orders passed under Section 148A(d) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred to as “the Act”).

3.1 The details of date of notice, date of order under Section 148A(d) of the Act, assessment year, etc., in respect of all the petitioners are given in the table below:

S. No.

Special Civil Application No.

Date of Notice under Section 148

Date of Order under Section 148A(d)

Assessment Year

1.

4353 of 2023

29.07.2022

29.07.2022

2013-14

2.

4243 of 2023

28.07.2022

27.07.2022

2014-15

3.

4244 of 2023

22.07.2022

22.07.2022

2013-14

4.

4337 of 2023

29.07.2022

29.07.2022

2013-14

5.

4257 of 2023

26.07.2022

26.07.2022

2013-14

6.

4354 of 2023

29.07.2022

29.07.2022

2013-14

7.

4416 of 2023

26.07.2022

26.07.2022

2014-15

8.

4417 of 2023

28.07.2022

28.07.2022

2013-14

9.

4434 of 2023

29.07.2022

29.07.2022

2014-15

10.

4436 of 2023

28.07.2022

28.07.2022

2013-14

11.

4439 of 2023

29.07.2022

29.07.2022

2013-14

12.

4440 of 2023

28.07.2022

28.07.2022

2014-15

13.

4423 of 2023

26.07.2022

26.07.2022

2013-14

14.

4424 of 2023

27.07.2022

27.07.2022

2014-15

15.

4443 of 2023

29.07.2022

29.07.2022

2013-14

16.

4445 of 2023

28.07.2022

28.07.2022

2013-14

17.

4468 of 2023

28.07.2022

28.07.2022

2014-15

18.

4425 of 2023

28.07.2022

28.07.2022

2014-15

19.

4469 of 2023

29.07.2022

29.07.2022

2013-14

20.

4426 of 2023

29.07.2022

29.07.2022

2013-14

21.

4427 of 2023

29.07.2022

29.07.2022

2014-15

22.

4470 of 2023

29.07.2022

29.07.2022

2013-14

23.

4429 of 2023

22.07.2022

21.07.2022

2014-15

24.

4430 of 2023

29.07.2022

29.07.2022

2014-15

25.

4447 of 2023

30.07.2022

30.07.2022

2013-14

26.

4435 of 2023

30.07.2022

29.07.2022

2014-15

27.

4397 of 2023

30.07.2022

30.07.2022

2014-15

28.

4437 of 2023

27.07.2022

27.07.2022

2013-14

29.

4438 of 2023

28.07.2022

28.07.2022

2013-14

30.

4460 of 2023

29.07.2022

29.07.2022

2013-14

31.

4441 of 2023

30.07.2022

30.07.2022

2013-14

32.

4442 of 2023

31.07.2022

31.07

            Click Here to Read the rest of this document
            1
            2
            3
            4
            5
            6
            7
            8
            9
            10
            11
            SupremeToday Portrait Ad
            supreme today icon
            logo-black

            An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers

            Please visit our Training & Support
            Center or Contact Us for assistance

            qr

            Scan Me!

            India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!

            For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :

            whatsapp-icon Back to top