Back
M. A. ABDUL HAKHIM
C. P. Joseph Son of Late C. R. Pius – Appellant
Versus
C. P. Francis S/o. C. P. Pius – Respondent
JUDGMENT
1. Appellants are the plaintiffs in the suit.
2. The suit was for the partition of Plaint A and B schedule properties and a permanent prohibitory injunction against alienation and committing waste. Plaint A and B schedule properties belonged to Pius and his wife, Philomina Pius, respectively. Pius and Philomina Pius died on 24.11.2004 and 27.11.2008, respectively.
3. The plaintiffs 1 to 5 and defendants 1 and 2, and Mariya, the mother of defendants 3 and 4, are the children of Pius and Philomina Pius. Pius was the owner of the plaint A schedule property, which had an extent of 7.875 cents of land, and the Tharawad house therein. Philomina Pious had 7.233 cents of land, out of which Philomina executed Ext.B2 Settlement Deed in favour of the fourth plaintiff for 4 cents, and the balance of 3.233 cents is included in plaint B schedule property. Plaint A and B schedule properties formed a compact plot within a common boundary.
4. As per plaint allegations, when the first defendant refused the demand of partition from the part of plaintiffs 1 and 2, claiming that he became the absolute owner of the plaint schedule properties by a Joint Will execute
A bequest in a Will is void if attested by a beneficiary, as per Section 67 of the Indian Succession Act, impacting the validity of the Will.
(1) Second appeal – High Court is competent and endowed with discretionary jurisdiction to formulate a substantial question of law not stated when second appeal was admitted – High Court is entitled ....
The burden of proof for the execution of a Will lies with the propounder, who must establish compliance with statutory requirements, including the testimony of attesting witnesses.
The validity of a Will can be upheld despite procedural omissions if supported by sufficient evidence, and a partition suit may be dismissed if barred by limitation.
The court ruled that the validity of a Will under the Indian Succession Act requires strict compliance with execution standards, and civil courts lack jurisdiction over intestate succession matters.
The burden to prove the validity of a Will lies with the propounder, and failure to meet statutory requirements results in its invalidation.
The main legal point established in the judgment is that the admissibility and proof of a Will should adhere to the mandate prescribed under the Evidence Act, and examination of attesting witnesses i....
A registered Will, executed in accordance with legal requirements, is valid and can determine the distribution of property, overriding claims for partition based on joint possession.
An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers
Please visit our Training & Support
Center or Contact Us for assistance
Scan Me!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :
Back to top
