JUDGMENT

Sudesh Bansal, J. - This appeal under Section 100 CPC has been filed by the appellants-defendants-RSRTC (hereinafter `the RSRTC') against judgment and decree dated 18-11-2014 in First appeal No.10/2010 passed by additional District Judge No.5, Jaipur Metropolitan while dismissing appeal affirmed the judgment and decree dated 6-4-2010 in Civil Suit No.167/2006 passed by the additional Civil Judge (Junior Division) No.2 Jaipur Metropolitan whereby and whereunder respondent-plaintiff's civil suit for declaration has been partially decreed in his favour and against the RSRTC in the following manner:-

(a) Plaintiff has been declared to be entitled for benefits of selection scales from the date of his first regular appointment as Conductor i.e 08.07.1987.

(b) for first selection scale on completion of 9 years on 08.07.1996 notional benefits only and actual benefits w.e.f. 27.05.1999 when plaintiff was reinstated in service and

(c) for second selection scale, though the period of 18 years completed on 08.07.2005 but since plaintiff suffered penalties prior to and post to such date, hence it has been left upon the employer RSRTC to determine to date, after analysis of the service reco