Page 1
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
…
OWP no.1759/2018
Pronounced on: 22.07.2024
Abrar Ahmad Tantray (21) S/o Fayaz Ahmad Tantray R/o Kujjar, Kulgam,
Kashmir (J&K)
…….Petitioner(s)
Through: Mr Ateeb Kanth, Advocate
Versus
1. State of J&K through Secy, Deptt of Power Dev. Deptt Civil Sectt
Sgr/Jmu
2. Dy. Commr. Kulgam
3. Chief Engineer, EM&RE Wing, Kashmir, Srinagar
4. Executive Engineer, ED Kulgam, Kashmir
5. Superintendent Engineer, Electric M&RE Circle, Bijbehara, Kashmir
……Respondent(s)
Through: Mr Alla ud din Ganai, AAG with
Ms Shaila Shameem, Assisting Counsel
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE VINOD CHATTERJI KOUL, JUDGE
JUDGMENT :
1. Petitioner prays to direct respondents to release compensation of Rs.20.00 Lacs in his favour which would include his hospitalization charges, operation, so long treatment, diet, transportation, care taking, mental pain and agony, future prospects and element of permanent disability. He also prays to direct official respondents to consider objectively and sympathetically petitioner for a suitable job in the said department as per his qualification so that he may not feel dependent and handicapped in his life because of aforesaid incident and can be rehabilitated permanently.
2. I have heard learned counsel for parties and considered the matter.
3. Brief facts summarized by petitioner in instant writ petition are that on 9 th March 2007, petitioner was eight years of age. He along with other children was playing near live wire electric transformer which was uncovered/uninsulated. The child/petitioner received electric shock due to a snapped 11 KV line at village Kujjar Kulgam as it was open uncovered/uninsulated electric wire which resulted in severe burn injuries on left side of his head, arm and other parts of body. He was immediately admitted to SKIMS, Srinagar. Police station Yaripora Kulgam entered a report no.4 of 11th March 2007. Statement of witnesses was recorded by police and FIR was registered. Due to high degree of electric shock, petitioner’s left arm was amputated and he obtained grievous injury in left side of head. Medical Board, Kulgam, declared him 75% disabled. District Superintendent of Police, Kulgam, got the matter verified and submitted are report to Deputy Commissioner, Kulgam, on 15th December 2009. Thereafter nothing was done by respondent, while petitioner was undergoing treatment even when his father had very little resources, yet still continued petitioner’s treatment. Plastic surgery, burns, reconstructive and micro-surgery, was being conducted by SKIMS Srinagar, which according to petitioner is evident from letter (Annexure B to writ petition). On representation of petitioner, Executive Engineer, ED Kulgam, in 2017 ordered AEE, Kulgam, to submit concrete report. It is being stated by petitioner that respondent-State admits that petitioner received a severe electric shock due to a snapped 11 KV line at village Kujjar. However, till date he has not been compensated by respondents.
4. The stand taken by respondents 1, 3 & 4 (Power Development Department), in their Reply is that petitioner while was playing near electric transformer installed in village Kujjar, got struck with electric transformer/electric wire, resulting in serious burn injuries on hand, arm and other body parts. Respondents admit that police station of Yaripora entered a report vide DD no.04 dated 11th March 2007, after which a police party was deputed to SKIMS Hospital, Srinagar, where petitioner was admitted for treatment and that statement of some of the witnesses was recorded and medical record was obtained. As per statement of Superintendent of Police, Kulgam, vide no.CRB/ INJ/ 09/15410 dated 15th December 2009, it has been found that there was no fault on the part of anyone, but the child got stuck with electric transformer/wire while playing with other children. Due to electric shock, the child received grievous injuries, amputation of left mid-fore arm and hand. Respondents state that writ petition has been filed after nine years, which is hit by delay and laches. In view of permanent damage suffered by petitioner and serious injuries, Assistant Executive Engineer, EM&RE, Sub Division, Kulgam, has recommended the case of petitioner for relief and rehabilitation on humanitarian grounds that has been forwarded by Chief Engineer, EM&RE, vide letter dated 11th October 2007 to Development Commissioner, Power.
5. In compliance to the order dated 30th January 2024, passed by this Court, petitioner has filed supplementary-affidavit. Petitioner has placed on record an Inpatient Estimate dated 31st January 2024, issued by Plu
The liability of power department officials for negligence resulting in injury and the determination of compensation based on the extent of disability and future earning potential.
The court established liability of the State as a welfare body to compensate for injuries to minors, asserting that minors cannot be held liable for negligence while emphasizing the negligence of the....
Courts can award compensation beyond government ex-gratia limits in electrocution cases, grounded in established legal principles that encompass loss of earnings, pain, suffering, and amenities.
The principle of restitutio in integrum and the provisions of the Electricity Act were central to the court's decision in awarding compensation for the electrical accident.
The court held that the respondents' gross negligence in failing to provide safety measures around the transformer led to the electrocution of a minor, warranting compensation for the victim's injuri....
The main legal point established in the judgment is the entitlement to compensation for permanent disability due to negligence, and the assessment of the compensation amount based on loss of earning ....
The main legal point established in the judgment is the wide amplitude of power conferred upon the High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution and the principles governing assessment of compensa....
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.