2018 Supreme(Mad) 3769
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
T. RAVINDRAN, J.
S. Bagyalakshmi - Appellant
Versus
R.K. Subramaniam - Respondent
Second Appeal No. 202, 203, 204 of 2015
Decided On : 26-09-2018
Important Points
Subject
Property Law - Partition and Joint Family Property
Act Referred
Headnote
Joint Family Property - Partition - O.S. No.270 of 2010, O.S.No. 319 of 2012 - [Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956] - The court discussed the devolution of the property from the original owner and determined that the suit property was the separate property of the respondent, not ancestral joint family property. The court also considered the legal presumption that possession follows title and found the respondent entitled to be in possession and enjoyment of the suit property.
Fact of the Case:
The appellants sought partition and permanent injunction of the suit property, claiming it as ancestral property. The respondent contended that the property was his separate property and sought permanent injunction against the appellants.
Finding of the Court:
The court found that the suit property was the separate property of the respondent and declined the relief of partition sought by the appellants. It also granted the relief of permanent injunction in favor of the respondent and dismissed the suit laid by the respondent.
Issues: The main issue was the nature of the suit property - whether it was ancestral joint family property or the separate property of the respondent. The court also considered the entitlement to the relief of permanent injunction based on possession and title.
Ratio Decidendi: The court determined that the suit property was the separate property of the respondent, not ancestral joint family property, based on the devolution of the property from the original owner. It also upheld the legal presumption that possession follows title, finding the respondent entitled to be in possession and enjoyment of the suit property.
Final Decision: The court dismissed the second appeals, finding them devoid of merits, and upheld the judgment and decree of the first appellate court.
Chitra Sampath, Adv., A.E. Ravichandran, Adv., B. Ramamoorthy, Adv.
T. RAVINDRAN, J.
1. In these second appeals, challenge is made to the judgment and decree dated 22.09.2014 passed in A.S.Nos. 63, 67 and 68 of 2013 on the file of the Principal District court, Coimbatore, confirming/reversing/reversing the judgment and decree dated 30.04.2013 passed in O.S. No.270 of 2010 and O.S.No. 319 of 2012, on the file of Sub Court, Pollachi respectively.
2. The first appellant S.Bagyalakshmi and the appellants 2 to 5 in Second Appeal No. 202 of 2015 had laid the suit in O.S. No.270 of 2010 against the respondent R.K. Subramaniam for partition and permanent injunction. The first appellant S. Bagyalakshmi in Second Appeal No. 202 of 2015 is the wife and the appellants 2 to 5 in Second Appeal No. 202 of 2015 are the children of the respondent R.K. Subramaniam.
3. Seeking partition of 4/5 share to the plaintiffs 2 to 5 and also seeking the relief of permanent injunction, O.S. No.270 of 2010 had been laid by the abovesaid appellants against the respondent and in brief, according to their case, the suit property and other properties originally belonged to Kandasamy Gounder, the father of the respondent and the respondent and one Velusamy are his legal representatives and it is stated that after the demise of Kandasamy Gounder in 1986, the respondent had laid a suit in O.S.No.101 of 1986 for partition and in the said suit, the suit property had been alloted to the respondent's share in the final decree proceeding in I.A. No.193 of 1993 and accordingly the appellants and the respondent were enjoying the suit property in common and jointly and it is stated that the respondent thereafter, since 1997 onwards, started leading a wayward life and not looking after the family and it is only the first appellant who has been looking after the children and also maintaining the suit property and accordingly the revenue records had been mutated in the name of the first appellant in respect of the suit property and it is also stated that as Velusamy, son of Kandasamy Gounder interfered with the possession and enjoyment of the first appellant in respect of the suit property, she had also laid a police complaint against him and it is further stated that the respondent had not cared for the family and also not in the possession and enjoyment of the suit property for several years and it is only the appellants who are in the possession and enjoyment of the suit property. However, without any authority, inasmuch as the respondent attempted to dispossess and interfere with the possession and enjoyment of the appellants in respect of the suit property and as the appellants 2 to 5 are each entitled to 1/5 share in the suit property, accordingly it is stated that the appellants had been necessiated to lay the suit for the appropriate reliefs as above stated.
4. The respondent had laid the suit for the relief of permanent injunction in O.S.No.319 of 2012 against the first appellant and even therein, the same defence has been set out by the first appellant to resist the above said suit of the respondent.
5. The case of the respondent, both in O.S.Nos.270 of 2010 and 319 of 2012, is that the suit property and other properties belonged to his parents and after the demise of his father, he along with his brother Velusamy and mother Kariammal, were enjoying the properties jointly and admitted that in the partition suit laid by him in O.S. No.101/86, he had been alloted the suit property and accordingly, it is his case that the suit property is his personal property and he is in the possession and enjoyment of the same by paying kists, etc., and after the marriage with the first appellant, it is he who had been enjoying the suit property and also stated that by way of doing the scrap iron business and out of the income earned therefrom, he has purchased the other properties in his name and due to the loss incurred in the said business, he had intended to sell his properties, which stood in his name and as the same was objected to by the