IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
S. SRIMATHY, J.
J. Alagesan - Appellant
Versus
The Manager (P&IR)/DM, LIC Insurance Corporation of India, Madurai - Respondent
W.P.(MD). No. 17548 of 2016 & W.M.P.(MD). Nos. 12673 & 12674 of 2016
Decided On : 19-09-2022
Community Certificate - Employment - OM, dated 12.09.1990 - The judgment discusses the petitioner's claim to belong to the Konda Reddy Community, seeking conversion to open category in service records and correct fixation of pay. The court analyzes the validity of the community certificate, the delay in verification, and the applicability of the OM, dated 12.09.1990, allowing SC/ST employees to move to open category. The court holds that the petitioner is eligible for benefits under the OM and directs the respondents to treat the petitioner as open category and disburse consequential benefits.
Fact of the Case:
The petitioner seeks conversion to open category in service records and correct fixation of pay, claiming to belong to the Konda Reddy Community. The petitioner's service was not confirmed due to issues with the community certificate. The petitioner filed multiple petitions and representations seeking appropriate salary and benefits.
Finding of the Court:
The court finds that the petitioner is eligible for benefits under the OM, dated 12.09.1990, allowing SC/ST employees to move to open category. The court holds that the petitioner is entitled to be treated as open category and receive consequential monetary and service benefits.
Issues: Validity of community certificate, delay in verification, applicability of OM, dated 12.09.1990, and entitlement to open category benefits.
Ratio Decidendi: The petitioner is eligible for benefits under the OM, dated 12.09.1990, and shall be treated as open category, entitling the petitioner to receive consequential monetary and service benefits.
Final Decision: The writ petition is allowed, and the respondents are directed to treat the petitioner as open category and disburse consequential monetary and service benefits.
JUDGMENT
(Prayer: Writ Petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India for issuance of Writ of Certiorarified Mandamus, to call for the records of the respondent in his proceedings in P&IR, dated 18.08.2016 and to quash the same and consequently, to direct the respondent to convert the petitioner's community status to open category in service records and to grant him correct fixation of pay and allowance and all incentives from the date of his appointment with all arrears and benefits.)
1. The Writ Petition in filed for issuance of Writ of Certiorarified Mandamus, to quash the proceedings in P&IR, dated 18.08.2016 and consequently, to direct the respondent to convert the petitioner's community status to open category in service records and to grant him correct fixation of pay and allowance and all incentives from the date of his appointment with all arrears and benefits.
2. The petitioner claims that the petitioner belongs to the Konda Reddy Community which is a Schedule Tribe and has produced a community certificate, dated 26.02.1980, issued by the Tahsildar and another certificate by the Revenue Divisional Officer, Mettur Dam on 27.10.1988. Both these certificates were issued after due verification and enquiry and the same has not been cancelled as per law and the same is still valid and the petitioner was selected and appointed by an order, dated 31.01.1997. However, the petitioner's service was not confirmed, because of the issue in his community certificate as Scheduled Tribe. Hence, the petitioner filed W.P.No.1629 of 1999 and the said writ petition was dismissed. Aggrieved over the same, the petitioner preferred W.A.No.513 of 2003 and this Court, vide order, dated 05.06.2007, modified the order and directed the respondent Corporation to take appropriate action to verify the community certificate and the Court has also directed the District Collector to hold a proper enquiry after affording opportunity to the petitioner and this Court has also directed the respondents to pay the salary to which the petitioner is entitled to in accordance with law.
3. The contention of the petitioner is that the time limit of 4 months was fixed for the respondent Corporation to verify his community certificates, no steps whatsoever have been taken for more than 9 years. The petitioner has submitted various representations to the respondent and requested to pay appropriate salary. The petitioner is receiving Rs.9,160/- per month, whereas his colleagues appointed with him were drawing about Rs 45,000/- per month. Therefore, the petitioner approached this Court again by filing W.P.(MD)No.8038 of 2012 and this Court, vide order, dated 15.06.2012, felt that since there was already a direction by this Court in W.A.No.513 of 2003, disposed of the Writ Petition permitting the petitioner to file a contempt application, if necessary.
4. Based on the order, the respondent slightly revised the salary of the petitioner by revising as if for a new appointee on probation and the petitioner's salary was fixed as Rs.31,000/- per month whereas his colleagues and juniors appointed along with him were drawing about Rs.80,000/- per month. The petitioner was not granted any incentives and other monetary benefits when the other employees are receiving. The contention of the petitioner is that the Government of India, Ministry of Business have issued guidelines contained in OM, dated 12.09.1990 permitting SC/ST employees to move to open category (OC) by voluntarily relinquishing their SC/ST status. The petitioner submits that the SC/ST employees who were facing difficulties in having their services confirmed were facing procrastinated verification proceedings had opted to move to OC category. Hence, the petitioner, in order to avail such benefits so as to put an end to the trauma and agony he was undergoing. He submitted a representation to the respondent on 25.07.2016 requesting the respondent to put himself under OC category, so that he could be treat
The judgment establishes the principle that SC/ST employees are eligible for benefits under the OM, dated 12.09.1990, allowing them to move to open category, and are entitled to receive consequential....
The importance of constitutional norms and the goal of achieving an egalitarian society.
The State Level Scrutiny Committee has the authority to scrutinize community certificates and make decisions based on evidence. The court will not interfere with the Committee's decision unless there....
The judgment establishes that repeated verifications of Community Certificates are improper, and the State Level Scrutiny Committee did not have jurisdiction for a second verification.
The main legal point established in this judgment is that the State Level Scrutiny Committee must follow the proper procedure for verification of community certificates, including providing an opport....
The court ruled that caste certificate verification is not limited by the date of appointment, emphasizing the necessity of addressing fraudulent claims to uphold constitutional rights.
A fraudulent document is non est from the beginning and cannot be countenanced in law. A party to a litigation cannot approbate and reprobate from his stand taken before a quasi-judicial authority to....
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.