IN THE HIGH COURT OF ALLAHABAD
SAURABH SHYAM SHAMSHERY, J.
Granth Verma - Petitioner
Versus
State of U.P. and Others - Respondents
Habeas Corpus Writ Petition No. 521 of 2022
Decided On : 22-09-2022
HABEAS CORPUS - INTER-PARENTAL CONFLICT - Guardians and Wards Act, 1890 - Sections 17(3), 19 - Welfare of the Child - Custody of Minor Child - Mediation and Counselling - Visitation Rights
Fact of the Case:
A seven-year-old boy, Corpus, was allegedly kidnapped by his father, Gaurav Verma, taking advantage of a meeting arranged by Corpus's mother. The mother filed a Habeas Corpus Petition to recover the Corpus.
Finding of the Court:
The Court found that the boy appeared happy with his father and expressed a desire to live with both parents and his younger brother. The Court emphasized the welfare of the child as the paramount consideration.
Issues: Inter-parental conflict, allegations of kidnapping, attempt to murder, and torture. Dispute over the execution of a compromise agreement and custody of the child.
Ratio Decidendi: The welfare of the child is the paramount consideration in custody matters. The Court interacted with the child and found him happy with his father. The Court emphasized the need for mediation, counselling, and visitation rights for both parents.
Final Decision: The Court rejected the Habeas Corpus petition and directed the child to remain with his father, with visitation rights for both parents. The Investigating Officer was directed to organize mediation and counselling sessions for the parents.
JUDGMENT :
A. GENESIS OF PRESENT WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS
1. Corpus, a seven years old boy, has approached this Court through his mother, Smt. Ashi Verma, alleging that Corpus was kidnapped by her husband, Gaurav Verma (Respondent-3) on 02.06.2022 taking advantage of good gesture shown by mother of Corpus to allow him to meet with Corpus. Respondents-4 and 5 are father and mother of Respondent-3, who are supporting her husband and they have misbehaved with her when she alongwith Police personnel went to their place to recover the Corpus. Hence, to recover the Corpus, present Habeas Corpus Petition is filed.
B. COURT'S INTERACTION WITH CORPUS
2. The Corpus is presently staying with his father who appeared before this Court on 16.09.2022 when this Court has interacted with him and brief of the same is mentioned in the order dated 16.09.2022, when after hearing counsel for parties judgment was reserved. For reference the relevant part of said order is mentioned hereinafter :
C. INTER-PARENTAL CONFLICTS; ITS' EFFECT ON CHILDREN
3. "Inter-Parental Conflict and Children's Psychological Development" are now also termed as "Child Affected by Relationship Distress". It remained an important subject for research scholars and various research papers are available on research related website which have considered "loyalty conflict", "parental alienation" etc. Few of them alongwith their conclusion/observation are referred hereinafter:
I. IRE JOURNALS (ISSN 2456-8880); December, 2021: Effects of Inter-Parental Conflict on Children's Social Well-Being and the Mediation Role of Parenting Behaviour-Author Stephanie Hess-In this paper the author after research come to the conclusion "study overall provides empirical evidence for the negative impact of inter-parental conflict on children's social well-being through a cascade of negative behavior within the family environment that spills over to the school environment. Children of parents who have frequent inter-parental conflicts perceive their mothers and fathers to be less warm and to communicate more negatively, which, in turn, leads to more peer problems and less pro-social behaviour in those children."
II. The Journal for Child Psychology and Psychiatry, Volume 59, Issue 4, Page 374-402: Annual Research Review: Inter-parental Conflict and Youth Psychopathology: An Evidence Review and Practice Focused Update; Authors Gordon T. Harold, Ruth Sellers: The Authors after study observed, "review highlights that frequent, intense, poorly resolved, and child-related inter-parental conflict adversely affects long-term emotional, behavioural, social, academic development, and future intergenerational/interpersonal relationship behaviours for youth."
III. International Journal of Scientific Engineering and Research (IJSER), Volume 7, Issue 3, March 2016: Effect of Parent's Conflict on Children: Author Khoolud Alamoudi-The conclusion of paper is that, "in conclusion, parents' conflicts damage children in many aspects, three of which are physical, psychological, and psychical effects. The impact of parents' conflicts could follow children until they grow up."
D. RIVAL SUBMISSIONS
4. Sri Sarvesh, learned counsel for petitioner and Sri Mahesh Narain Singh, Advocate for Respondents-3 to 5, have vehemently presented the case of their parties. There wer
Tejaswini Gaud and others vs. Shekhar Jagdish Prasad Tewari and others
Nil Ratan Kundu vs. Abhijit Kundu
Anjali Kapoor vs. Rajiv Baijal
Athar Hussain vs. Syed Siraj Ahmed and others
Syed Saleemuddin vs. Dr. Rukhsana
Kanu Sanyal vs. District Magistrate, Darjeeling and others
Mohd. Ikram Hussain vs. State of U.P. & Others
Goverdhan Lal v. Gajendra Kumar
M.K. Hari Govindan v. A.R. Rajaram
Rosy Jacob v. Jacob A. Chakramakkal
The welfare of the child is the paramount consideration in custody matters, and the Court emphasized the need for mediation, counselling, and visitation rights for both parents.
Natural guardians of child have right to custody of child, but that right is not absolute and courts are expected to give paramount consideration to welfare of minor child.
The welfare of the child is the paramount consideration in determining custody, and the writ of habeas corpus is maintainable in child custody matters where the detention of a minor child by a parent....
Point of law: Custody of child - In a child custody matter, a writ of habeas corpus would be entertainable where it is established that the detention of the minor child by the parent or others is ill....
Point of Law : It is only in exceptional cases, the rights of the parties to the custody of the minor will be determined in exercise of extraordinary jurisdiction on a petition for habeas corpus.
The welfare of the child is paramount in custody matters, and the extraordinary jurisdiction for habeas corpus depends on establishing unlawful detention.
Court emphasizes the welfare of the child in custody matters while maintaining jurisdictional limits.
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.