SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

1949 Supreme(All) 324

ALLAHABAD HIGH COURT
AGARWALA, SETH, WANCHOO, JJ.
Deep Chandra - Appellant
Versus
Ruknuddaula Shamsher Jang Nawab Mohammad Sajjad Ali Khan & Ors. - Respondents
First Appeal No. 410 of 1943
Decided On : 11-05-1949

Act Referred

CONTRACT ACT : S.2
EVIDENCE ACT : S.91, S.92
TRANSFER OF PROPERTY ACT : S.55(2)

Advocates appeared:
G.S. Pathak, P.L. Banerji and Govind Das, For the Appellant / P.R. Das, S.N. Katju and Wahid Ahmad Khan, For the Respondent

JUDGMENT

Seth, J. - This Full Bench reference is the outcome of disagreement between the learned Judges composing the Bench, which heard an appeal against a decree of the Civil Judge of Muzaffarnagar at Meerut, dismissing a suit for the specific performance of a contract for the sale of land alleged to have been concluded on 7-2-1942. The learned Judges were agreed on some of the points requiring determination, but not on all. The points of disagreement are the subject-matter of the questions referred to us for decision.

2. The case appears to have assumed importance, not because of its own merit, but because of the learning and ability, with which it had been presented before this Court. When so much learning and ability is bestowed upon a case, which does not possess any extraordinary feature, attention is apt to be diverted to side issues, which have hardly any material bearing on the crucial points involved but which only tend to cloud the issue. In such a case, it is necessary not to lose sight of the essential features of the case and the crucial points involved in it.

3. I have had the advantage of reading the very full and learned judgment, which my brother Agarwala proposes to deliver. My learned brother has reproduced the questions referred to us for decision, has stated the facts and pleadings in the case in full detail, and has also exhaustively dealt with the authorities cited at the Bar. It is not necessary, therefore, to reproduce the questions again. I do not wish to make the judgment of this Bench cumbersome and for this reason propose to be as brief as possible, in what I have to say.

4. Sometime in the last part of the year 1941, Ruknuddaula Shamsher Jung Nawab Mohammad Sajjad Ali Khan (hereinafter referred to as 'the Nawab') entertained the idea of selling the property in suit. His manager, Sardar Akram Khan (hereinafter referred to as 'the manager') gave this information to a broker named Chhater Sen in December 1941. Chatter Sen found a likely purchaser in the plaintiff, Lala Deep Chand (hereinafter referred to as 'the plaintiff') and started negotiations, in which he acted as an intermediary. These negotiations were carried on in the month of January and the first week of the month of February 1942. At first, the plaintiff was not willing to purchase the entire property in suit, but the Nawab was also not willing to sell a portion. Later, the plaintiff became willing to purchase the whole.

5. On 31-1-1942, the plaintiff told Chatter Sen that he was willing to purchase the property at the price at which the Nawab was willing to sell it, namely, Rs. 62,000. He, however, desired certain steps to be taken to avoid the sale being pre-empted. He proposed an exchange of land and execution of a thekanama of the property, to be sold, in favour of some nominee of his, before the sale took place. The object of the exchange was to make him a co-sharer in the property to be sold, to enable him to successfully resist a claim for pre-emption. The object of the thekanama was to dissuade likely pre-emptors from enforcing their claim by creating a situation in which a successful pre-emptor might not be able to obtain actual possession of the property.

6. Chhater Sen arranged a meeting between the plaintiff and the manager and the two met on 6-2-1942. The manager was not agreeable to either of the two proposals. The plaintiff then put forward a third proposal, viz., that instead of the real price an inflated price might be entered in the sale-deed, to ward off preemption. The manager replied that the proposal might be put to the Nawab himself. The plaintiff then desired to pay to the manager Rs. 5,000 by way of earnest. The manager did not accept it and said that it would be better if it were offered to the Nawab himself. He, however, suggested that Rs. 10,000 and not Rs. 5,000 only, be offered as earnest money.

7. The same night the plaintiff sent Chhater Sen and a lawyer, Babu Daya Shankar, from. Muzaffarnagar to the Nawab at K


1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top