SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2019 Supreme(MP) 827

High Court of Madhya Pradesh
Prakash Shrivastava, J.
SARVESHVAR & ORS. - APPELLANTS
Versus
SUKHDEV & ORS. - RESPONDENTS
M. P. No. 3113 of 2018
Decided On : 30-11-2019

Important Points

The merits of an amendment are not a relevant consideration at the stage of allowing the application for amendment.

Subject

Civil Law - Civil Procedure

Act Referred

CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE : O.6 R.17
CONSTITUTION OF INDIA : Art.227

Headnote

Amendment - Civil Procedure Code - Order 6, Rule 17 - Hindu Succession Act - Section 8 - [Order 6, Rule 17 of the Civil Procedure Code, Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act]

Fact of the Case:

The plaintiffs challenged the trial Court's order allowing the respondents to amend the written statement to introduce a Will after a remand order.

Finding of the Court:

The trial Court did not commit any error in allowing the amendment, considering the subsequent developments after the remand order.

Issues: Challenge to the trial Court's order allowing amendment of the written statement after a remand order.

Ratio Decidendi: The trial Court's decision to allow the amendment was supported by legal precedents emphasizing that the merits of the amendment are hardly a relevant consideration at the stage of allowing the application for amendment.

Final Decision: The miscellaneous petition challenging the trial Court's order was dismissed.

Advocates Appeared:
For Appellant : A. S. Garg, Ms. Megha Jain
For Respondent: B. I. Mehta, J. B. Mehta

ORDER/JUDGMENT – Shri A. S. Garg, learned senior counsel with Ms. Megha

Jain, learned counsel for the petitioners.

Shri B. I. Mehta, learned senior counsel with Shri J. B. Mehta, learned counsel for the respondents.

Heard finally with consent.

2. By this miscellaneous petition under Article 227 of the Constitution, the plaintiffs in the suit have challenged the order of the trial Court dated 20-6-2018, whereby the application filed by the respondents (defendants No. 3 and 4) under Order 6, Rule 17 of the Civil Procedure Code for amendment of the written statement has been allowed.

3. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioners submits that after the remand new case cannot be introduced by the respondents and that there was a limited remand by this Court and the Will which the respondents are trying to introduce, is a forged document and section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act (for short “the Act”) is attracted when male Hindu dies ‘intestate’, therefore, in terms of the remand order the question of introducing the Will does not arise.

4. As against this, learned counsel for the respondents has supported the impugned order by submitting that on account of the death of Sukhdev subsequently the question of Will has arisen and that the trial Court has not committed any error in passing the impugned order.

5. Having heard the learned counsel for the parties and on perusal of the record, it is noticed that the trial Court had earlier decreed the suit by the judgment dated 16-3-2000, which came to be challenged by the respondents by filing the First Appeal No. 238/2000. This Court by the judgment dated 31-1-2018 had reached to the conclusion that the two daughters of Sukhdev were not impleaded as party and that Sukhdevand Yashodabai w/o Sukhdev had died during the pendency of appeal. This Court had also taken note of the legal position as reflected in the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Uttam vs. Saubhag Singh, reported in AIR 2016 SC 1169 and in this background the appeal was allowed, the judgment and decree of the trial Court was set aside and the matter was remanded back to the trial Court to decide the suit afresh within a time bound period. After the remand the respondents (defendants No. 3 and 4) had filed the application for amendment of the written statement with the plea that Sukhdev had executed the Will dated 5-3-1998 in their favour, therefore, seeking amendment in the written statement and incorporating the plea relating to the Will.

6. While passing the impugned order the trial Court has duly considered the respective plea of the parties and has assigned just and proper reasons for allowing the prayer for amendment in the written statement. The trial Court has taken note of the fact that parties are claiming the properties of Sukhdev. The trial Court has also taken note of the fact that Sukhdev has died, therefore, all the relevant circumstances after the death of Sukhdev are required to be looked into. In respect of the objection on merit of the plea raised in the amendment application, the trial Court has rightly noted that the merits of the amendment cannot be looked into at this stage.

7. The view which is taken by the trial Court is duly supported by the judgment of the Supreme Court in the matter of Usha Devi vs. Rijwan Ahmad and others, reported in AIR 2008 SC 1147, wherein it has been held that the merits of amendment is hardly a relevant consideration while allowing the application for amendment. Similarly the Supreme Court in the matter of Raj Kumar Bhatia vs. Subhash Chander Bhatia, reported in AIR 2018 SC 100 has held that : –

“11. This being the position, the case which was sought to be set up in the proposed amendment was an elaboration of what was stated in the written statement. The High Court has in the exercise of its jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution entered upon the merits of the case which was sought to be set up by the appellant in the amendment. This is impermissible.

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top