The Gauhati High Court has struck down an order by the Pollution Control Board, Assam (PCBA), which sought to revive a Provisional Consent to Establish (PCTE) for a Calcined Petroleum Coke (CPC) manufacturing unit nine years after its expiry. The bench, comprising Justice Kalyan Rai Surana and Justice Pranjal Das, determined that the regulatory body acted beyond its statutory mandate by treating a fresh application as an extension of a defunct 2012 permit, particularly in light of strict environmental prohibitions implemented in the intervening years.

The dispute centered on the operations of M/s M M Carbon Products Pvt Ltd, which had initially been granted a PCTE in December 2012 to set up a calcination unit with an annual capacity of 12,000 metric tonnes in the Export Promotion Industrial Park at Amingaon. According to the court records, the permit was strictly valid for one year, expiring on December 9, 2013. The company failed to commence operations during that period, and the permit remained dormant until the board attempted to resuscitate it in December 2022.

In the intervening period, the regulatory landscape regarding highly polluting "red" category industries in the state had changed significantly. In February 2018, the PCBA had issued a notification prohibiting the establishment of any new CPC units and banning the expansion of existing ones due to severe pollution concerns in the surrounding areas. The petitioner, the NOC Foundation, argued that the board's decision to extend an expired consent bypassed these essential safeguards, suggesting an improper nexus between the regulator and the private entity.

Regulatory Irregularities and Administrative Falsification

During the proceedings, the court expressed profound dissatisfaction with the documentation and processes employed by the Pollution Control Board. The company had submitted a new application for a Consent to Establish in 2021, yet the board processed this request as an extension of the 2012 permit. The bench pointed out that there was no statutory provision allowing the board to perform a "suo motu" conversion of a new application into an extension of a permit that had lapsed half a decade earlier.

In a scathing observation regarding the state of the board's records, the court noted: "The respondent nos. 2 and 3 appear to be a party to the tapestry of falsification of records, which is to treat an Electrode Carbon Paste industrial unit of the respondent no. 4 as an existing Calcinated Petroleum Coke Industry."

The court further interrogated the reliability of the board’s digital portals, observing that the platform appeared capable of generating undated acknowledgements and back-dating unique identification numbers, which essentially rendered the system untrustworthy. The judges emphasized that such technical irregularities, when used to circumvent established environmental protocols, pose a significant risk to public interest and environmental stability.

The Impact of Environmental Policy Shifts

The legal friction was compounded by the shifting status of petroleum coke usage in the region. Although the 2018 notification initially imposed a broad ban, subsequent notifications in 2019 and 2020 introduced nuances regarding the use of pet coke as a raw feedstock versus fuel. However, the court maintained that these policy adjustments did not grant the Pollution Control Board the authority to unilaterally revive permits that had already lost their legal validity.

The defense presented by the industrial unit argued that its intent was to use pet coke strictly as a feedstock and not as fuel, suggesting it should be exempted from the restrictions. Nevertheless, the court found that the fundamental flaw lay in the board's attempt to extend a 2012 document that had ceased to exist under the law. The court concluded that even if the industry were considered "existing," the board had failed to produce valid records showing that the unit had ever operated under a legitimate Consent to Operate (CTO). By permitting such an entity to function without clear, verified consent, the board was seen to have neglected its duty to regulate a high-pollutant facility.

Judicial Consequences and Future Directions

The bench ultimately quashed the board's order dated December 31, 2022, which had granted the extension. The court directed that the pollution control authorities ensure all consequential actions are taken to effectuate this cancellation. Recognizing the severity of the regulatory failure, the court imposed a cost of ₹1,00,000 on the Pollution Control Board, Assam. This sum is to be deposited with the Women and Child Development Department, specifically earmarked for improving facilities for specially-abled girl children in remote care homes.

In its final directives, the court left open the possibility for the state to recover these costs from the individual officials found responsible for the oversight. The judgment specifies that the ruling will come into effect after a 30-day period, ending on December 10, 2026, providing a window for the necessary administrative steps to be completed. Through this ruling, the Gauhati High Court has reaffirmed that environmental clearances cannot be treated as permanent assets that regulators can revive at will, emphasizing that procedural adherence remains the bedrock of environmental justice.