The Patna High Court has issued a significant ruling modifying a previous order that had set aside the removal of a bank employee, directing instead that the disciplinary proceedings be resumed from the point where procedural errors occurred. A Division Bench comprising Chief Justice V. Kameswar Rao and Justice Partha Sarthy determined that when a removal from service is quashed on grounds of a breach of natural justice, the correct judicial course is to remand the matter to the disciplinary authority to rectify the procedural deficiency, rather than granting absolute relief to the employee.

The dispute originated from disciplinary proceedings initiated against the respondent, Pulak Chandra Das, who served as a Senior Assistant at the State Bank of India. Preliminary charges against the respondent were framed on March 13, 2007, with a formal reply submitted by the respondent on April 17, 2007. Following this initial stage, a final charge-sheet was issued on August 22, 2007, to which the respondent provided a response on September 5, 2007. Because the disciplinary authority found the respondent's explanations unsatisfactory, an inquiry officer was appointed to investigate the charges. In December 2008, the officer submitted a report concluding that the charges against the respondent were proven. Consequently, a second show-cause notice was issued on November 5, 2009, leading to the respondent's removal from service on November 14, 2009.

The respondent’s subsequent appeal to the appellate authority was dismissed, prompting him to file a writ petition before the Patna High Court. In February 2025, a learned Single Judge ruled in favor of the respondent, citing critical failures in the disciplinary process. The court observed that the charge-memo provided to the respondent lacked essential documentation, including a list of witnesses and statements of imputation. Furthermore, the court noted that the individuals responsible for the evidence used against the respondent were not examined, effectively violating the principles of natural justice. The Single Judge set aside the removal order and directed the bank to pay the respondent 50 percent of his monetary benefits for the intervening period between his removal and his eventual retirement.

The State Bank of India challenged this decision through a Letters Patent Appeal, arguing that while the procedural errors were acknowledged, the Single Judge erred by failing to remand the matter to the competent authority. The bank contended that the allegations against the respondent were grave, necessitating a full inquiry conducted in accordance with proper legal procedure. Citing several precedents, the bank argued that a breach of natural justice does not automatically entitle an employee to a total discharge from the disciplinary process; rather, the process should be set back to the stage where the error occurred to allow for a fair hearing.

The Division Bench agreed with the bank’s position, noting that the respondent—who was 42 years old at the start of the litigation and is currently nearing the age of superannuation —still had relevant service time remaining. The court emphasized that the seriousness of the charges against the respondent warranted a thorough examination. In their judgment, the court remarked: "when a Disciplinary Proceedings resulting in the punishment of removal from service is set aside, the charges against the respondent are of serious nature, the learned Single Judge should have remanded the matter back to the Disciplinary Authority to enable the Disciplinary Authority to proceed in the proceedings from the stage when the principles of natural justice have been violated so that the charges which have been framed against the respondent are enquired into."

The court subsequently modified the directions issued by the Single Judge. While the respondent is still entitled to 50 percent of his monetary benefits for the period from his initial removal until the date of his reinstatement, this benefit is now explicitly linked to the requirement that the disciplinary proceedings continue. The bank is now authorized to resume the process from the stage of the August 22, 2007, charge-sheet. The court has granted the disciplinary authority the power to regulate the intervening period for the respondent.

The order provides a strict timeline for the resolution of this matter, mandating that the resumed departmental proceedings be completed within six months from the date the order is received or produced. By choosing this path, the Patna High Court has balanced the protection of an employee’s right to procedural fairness with the legitimate interest of a financial institution in holding employees accountable for serious misconduct. The case underscores the judiciary's preference for restorative procedural justice over final, summary adjudication in matters involving public sector employment. The litigation will now proceed back to the bank’s disciplinary cell, where the respondent will have the opportunity to participate in a rectified hearing process, ensuring that the evidence is properly examined and the principles of natural justice are fully observed. The court concluded the appeal by formally disposing of the matter, leaving the bank to finalize the disciplinary inquiry within the court-imposed timeframe.