SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Can Future Commercial Use Bring a Property Dispute Under Section 2(1)(c)(vii) of the Commercial Courts Act?

When an Agreement for a Future Petrol Station on Wetland Falls Outside the Commercial Courts Act

Suppose two parties execute an agreement over a parcel of immovable property classified as wetland. At the time of execution, the land is not used for any trade or commercial activity. However, the agreement contemplates its future conversion and utilisation for establishing a petroleum filling station and allied activities. If a dispute later arises over this agreement, can it be brought within the ambit of Section 2(1)(c)(vii) of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 — particularly when the filling station was never established and no commercial activities were ever commenced or carried out on the property?

This question, which surfaced before the courts in the context of an agreement for a petroleum outlet on wetland, has a clear answer grounded in recent precedent: No. The dispute generally cannot qualify as a commercial dispute under Section 2(1)(c)(vii) merely because the agreement envisioned future commercial use 2024 0 Supreme(Kar) 436.

The Actually Used or Being Used Test

The Settled Interpretation of Used

The definitive ruling on this point came from the Gujarat High Court in Vasu Healthcare Private Limited v. Gujarat Akruti TCG Biotech Limited (AIR 2017 Gujarat 153) 2019 8 Supreme 588, and was affirmed by the Supreme Court in Ambalal Sarabhai Enterprises Ltd. v. K.S. Infraspace LLP (2020) 15 SCC 585 2024 0 Supreme(All) 875 and 2021 0 Supreme(Guj) 1141. The core proposition:

On plain reading of the relevant clause it is clear that the expression 'used' must mean 'actually used' or 'being used'... The word 'used' denotes 'actually used' and it cannot be said to be either 'ready for use' or 'likely to be used'; or 'to be used'. 2019 8 Supreme 588

The Supreme Court in Ambalal Sarabhai reiterated:

The word 'used' denotes 'actually used' and it cannot be either 'ready for use' or 'likely to be used' or 'to be used'. It should be 'actually used'. Such a wide interpretation would defeat the objects of the Act and the fast tracking procedure discussed above. 2024 0 Supreme(All) 875

Why the Future-Use Contemplation Does Not Suffice

Applying this standard, an agreement contemplating that immovable property is likely to be used for trade or commerce, or may in the future be used for that purpose, does not give rise to a commercial dispute within the meaning of Section 2(1)(c)(vii). In the petroleum filling station scenario, the land remained classified wetland, no conversion occurred, the station was never built, and no commercial operations ever began. The property was therefore not actually used or being used for trade or commerce at the relevant time, and the suit was held not maintainable before the Commercial Court 2024 0 Supreme(Kar) 436.

The Exclusivity Requirement

A further layer of the analysis is that the property must be used exclusively for trade or commerce. In Jagmohan Behl v. State Bank of Indore (2017 SCC OnLine Del 10706), the Delhi High Court held:

The immoveable property must be used exclusively for trade or business... Use of the property as for trade and business is determinative. Properties which are not exclusively used for trade or commerce would be excluded. 2022 0 Supreme(Ker) 727

In the wetland scenario, this threshold fails at the very first step — there was no commercial use at all, let alone exclusive commercial use. The Supreme Court in Ambalal Sarabhai emphasised that a dispute relating to immovable property per se is not automatically a commercial dispute; the property must actually be used exclusively in trade or commerce for the dispute to fall under clause (vii) 2024 0 Supreme(All) 875.

Contrasting Situations: When Courts Have Taken a Broader View

The jurisprudence is not entirely uniform, and litigants should be aware of contrasting decisions.

  • Gestation and construction phases: In one lease dispute involving land converted for non-agricultural commercial petrol station purposes under a 29-year lease for retailing petroleum products, a court took a purposive view that used expansively includes all stages of a commercial enterprise — including construction and gestation periods — and restored the plaint to the Commercial Court 2024 0 Supreme(Ker) 1377.
  • Explanation (a) and wide interpretation: Another decision declined to follow the narrow Gujarat High Court line, holding that Section 2(1)(c)(vii) read with Explanation (a) must be given a wide interpretation, particularly where a Memorandum of Understanding showed the property was to be developed for commercial gains. That court found that Vasu Healthcare did not assist a respondent resisting transfer, and disagreed with the narrow reading of the provision 2019 0 Supreme(Bom) 294.
  • Exclusive commercial use actually established: Where properties are admittedly godowns or licensed premises with specific pleadings that they are used for trade and commerce, disputes over such agreements have been readily characterised as commercial disputes 2021 0 Supreme(Cal) 52 and 2024 0 Supreme(Ker) 995.

These cases demonstrate that the actual-use test is applied contextually, and a counter-view exists — but where, as in the wetland matter, no commercial activity was ever commenced at all, the prevailing authority points squarely away from Commercial Court jurisdiction 2024 0 Supreme(Kar) 436.

Timing of the Assessment

A subtle but important point: the actual-use requirement is assessed at the time the dispute arises, not necessarily when the agreement was executed 2024 0 Supreme(Kar) 436. However, in the petroleum filling station scenario, neither the date of the agreement nor the date of the dispute revealed any actual commercial use — the property remained wetland throughout — so the outcome was unaffected.

The Explanation to Section 2(1)(c) clarifies that a commercial dispute does not cease to be one merely because it involves recovery of immovable property or realisation of monies out of immovable property given as security 2022 0 Supreme(Ker) 727. But this clarification operates only once the threshold condition of exclusive commercial use is already satisfied; it cannot cure an otherwise absent commercial character.

Key Takeaways

  • Section 2(1)(c)(vii) requires that the immovable property be actually used or being used exclusively in trade or commerce; likely to be used or to be used is not enough 2019 8 Supreme 588 and 2024 0 Supreme(All) 875.
  • An agreement contemplating future conversion of wetland into a petroleum filling station does not, by itself, create a commercial dispute where the station was never established and no commercial activities commenced 2024 0 Supreme(Kar) 436.
  • A strict, literal interpretation is preferred by the Supreme Court, since a wider reading would defeat the Act's object of fast-tracking genuine commercial disputes 2024 0 Supreme(All) 875.
  • Practical implication: if the property is yet to be developed or converted for commercial use, the suit should typically be filed before the ordinary Civil Court, and pleadings should clearly aver the actual commercial use of the property to establish Commercial Court jurisdiction 2019 8 Supreme 588.
  • Litigants should note that some decisions have adopted a broader, purposive reading of clause (vii) read with Explanation (a), so the jurisdictional analysis may vary by forum and facts 2019 0 Supreme(Bom) 294 and 2024 0 Supreme(Ker) 1377.

This article provides general legal information and does not constitute specific legal advice; parties should assess their particular facts with a qualified professional before choosing a forum.

#CommercialCourtsAct #CommercialDispute #ImmovableProperty #Section2c7 #CourtJurisdiction
Chat Download
Chat Print
Chat R ALL
Landmark
Strategy
Argument
Risk
Chat Voice Bottom Icon
Chat Sent Bottom Icon
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
whatsapp-icon Back to top