Searching Case Laws & Precedent on Legal Query..!
Scanned Judgements…!
Searching Case Laws & Precedent on Legal Query..!
Scanned Judgements…!
Many professionals wonder: is income tax not applicable to some professions? In India, tales circulate about doctors, lawyers, or chartered accountants enjoying special tax breaks. But does the Income Tax Act, 1961, truly exempt certain professions from taxation? This post dives into the nuances, backed by court rulings and legal precedents, to clarify the reality.
While no blanket income tax exemptions exist for specific professions, there's a narrow relief for medical professionals in partnerships. We'll break it down, distinguish it from state-level profession taxes, and highlight limitations. Note: This is general information, not legal advice. Consult a tax professional for your situation.
The Income Tax Act, 1961, does not provide general exemptions for professional income. However, Section 64(1) offers targeted relief from income aggregation for medical practice income earned through a partnership firm. Here, a doctor's spouse's share isn't clubbed with the assessee's income if the firm is deemed 'professional' rather than 'business'. Courts emphasize the legislative intent to exempt such professional partnerships. K. THOMAS VARGHESE VS COMMR. of INCOME TAX - 1986 0 Supreme(Ker) 89
No similar perks apply to other fields like chartered accountancy or law. State profession taxes—levied under Entry 60, List II of the Constitution—are separate and not deductible under income tax laws. Commissioner Of Income-tax, Punjab, Jammu And Kashmir And Himachal Pradesh VS Saraswati Industrial Syndicate - 1970 0 Supreme(P&H) 237
In a key ruling, a doctor and his wife partnered in a medical firm. The ITO clubbed the wife's income, but the Tribunal reclassified it as professional. The court upheld: the firm’s activities were professional in nature, and the presence of a non-professional partner did not alter this characterization. Thus, the wife's income wasn't aggregated under Section 64(1). K. THOMAS VARGHESE VS COMMR. of INCOME TAX - 1986 0 Supreme(Ker) 89
The ratio decidendi stresses: the distinction between carrying on a profession and carrying on a business, and the deliberate purpose of the provision to exempt partnerships engaged in professions such as medicine from income aggregation. K. THOMAS VARGHESE VS COMMR. of INCOME TAX - 1986 0 Supreme(Ker) 89 This relief hinges on factual classification—partnership deeds and activities must prove 'professional' status.
Chartered Accountants: Challenges to Section 44AA (books maintenance) failed. Courts found no discrimination: no discrimination between enumerated and non-enumerated professions under Section 44-AA. Obligations stand without tax breaks. H. A. K. RAO. VS UNION OF INDIA - 1990 0 Supreme(Kar) 546
Lawyers: No income tax exemptions noted. Professional activities aren't 'commercial establishments' for property tax, but this doesn't extend to income tax. South Delhi Municipal Corporation VS B. N. Magon - 2023 0 Supreme(Del) 3460
Analogous relief exists for co-operative banks under Section 80P(2)(a)(i): any income derived from funds so placed arises from the business carried on by it and the assessee has not, by reason of Section 80-P(2)(a)(i), to pay income tax thereon. Commissioner Of Income Tax, Karnataka VS Karnataka State Co-operative Apex Bank - 2001 6 Supreme 327 Yet, this is business-specific, not profession-wide.
State profession taxes aren't deductible. Courts rule: the professional tax was not an expenditure incurred exclusively for the purpose of the assessee’s business, and therefore, it was not allowable as a deduction under Section 10(2)(xv). It's a 'contribution from income', akin to income tax itself. Commissioner Of Income-tax, Punjab, Jammu And Kashmir And Himachal Pradesh VS Saraswati Industrial Syndicate - 1970 0 Supreme(P&H) 237
This blocks indirect relief. Profession taxes target 'status/person', not income/services: The nature and incidence of the tax are quite different from those of Income Tax. It is... a tax on a person, who exercises a profession... PRAKASAN VS STATE OF KERALA - 1979 0 Supreme(Ker) 66
Constitutional boundaries clarify: States levy profession taxes (Art. 276), capped at Rs. 2500 now, but not as income taxes. Historical safeguards prevented provinces from disguising income taxes as profession levies. Sub-section (1) of old S.142-A stated: a tax on professions, etc., would not be invalid on the ground that it related to a tax on income. Yet, overreach is struck down. COMMISSIONER, QUILON MUNICIPALITY VS HARRISONS AND CROSFIELD LTD. - 1963 Supreme(Ker) 196COMMISSIONER, QUILON MUNICIPALITY VS HARRISONS AND CROSFIELD LTD - 1963 Supreme(Ker) 194
For instance, cantonment boards must respect Art. 276(2) limits on brick taxes, indirectly tied to trades. Cantonment Board, Mathura VS Krishna Bricks And Lime Factory - 1996 6 Supreme 688 Pension/investment income isn't profession-taxable: tax on income from investments does not fall within its ambit. K. George VS . - 1970 Supreme(Ker) 89
Service taxes on CAs fall under Union powers: Parliament had absolute jurisdiction... to levy tax on services. All India Federation of Tax Practitioners VS Union of India - 2007 6 Supreme 452
Circumstances/property taxes aren't purely profession taxes, evading Art. 276(2) caps in some views, but irrelevant to income tax. R. R. Engineering Company: Shital Prasad VS Zila Parishad, Bareilly: Town Area Committee, Kuraoli - 1980 Supreme(SC) 123
The Apex Court notes: a tax on profession is not necessarily connected with income. Jodhpur Chartered Accountants Society VS Union of India - 2002 Supreme(Raj) 1474
Disclaimer: Tax laws evolve; this overview draws from cited cases up to available data. Seek personalized advice from a chartered accountant or lawyer. Stay compliant to avoid disputes!
Therefore, professions will not include services under Entry 60. For the above reasons, we hold that Parliament had absolute jurisdiction and legislative competence to levy tax on services. ... Therefore, we hold that tax on professions etc. has to be read as a levy on professions, trades, callings etc., as such. Therefore, Entry 60 which refers to professions cannot be extended to include services. This is what is called as an Aspect Theory. ... On retirement, he cea....
High Court are not serving under a State or under any Local Authority etc. and consequently Section 7 of the Professions Tax Act and Rule 8 framed under the said Act are not applicable to them and that recovery cannot be effected by deduction from their pay bills, as provided in the above-said rule; ... This was as follows:- ... - ... "That the employees of the High Court are not serving under a State or under any local authority etc., and consequently Section 7 of the Prof....
This is clear from the tax on professions imposed by several municipal authorities at certain rates mentioned in the relevant statutes. A tax on income can be imposed if there is income. A tax on profession can be imposed if a person carries on a profession. ... The contention of the appellants that the imposition of tax by the Panchayat Samiti amounts to double taxation and is, therefore, illegal is unsound. A tax on profession is not#HL_E....
are engaged in the Professions, Trades and Callings and not from the salary or wage earners on the income, as defined u/s 2(24) of the income Tax Act. ... dated, 30.03.2000 and not the salaries/wages or income as defined U/s 2(p) of the Act read with Section 17 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 and income, as defined U/s 2(24) of the Income Tax Act. ... in case, such person has #HL_STA....
such law shall not be invalid on the ground that it relates to a tax on income. ... that it relates to a tax on income. ... that it relates to tax on income. ... in respect of imposition of taxes on professions, trades and callings, was applicable even on the Board which had been established under the aforesaid Cantonments Act. ... , tradings, callings or employments shall be invalid on the ground that it relates to a tax#....
obligated to withhold tax from the impugned payments made to non-resident parties since the same were not chargeable to tax in India as per the provisions of the Act and/or the provisions of applicable DTAA entered into with respective countries. ... set out in Article 15 of the Indo US Tax Treaty relating to “Independent Personal Services” which is similar worded as Article 14 of India Srilanka Tax Treaty and Article 16 of India Kenya Tax Treaty held that a specific ....
If the tax is not in the nature of an Income Tax, I do not see the difference between a tax levied on the basis of income from trade and called a circumstances tax and a tax on trade. ... Banerji is firstly that the tax on circumstances and property is not a tax on professions, trades, callings or employments and is, therefore, not governed by ....
The Supreme Court dealt with the three sub-sections of S.142-A as follows: ... "Sub-section (1) provided that a tax on professions, etc., would not be invalid on the ground that it related to a tax on income. ... ... It was also apprehended that under the guise of taxes on professions, etc., the Provincial Legislature might start their own scheme of a tax on income, thus subjecting incomes from professions, etc. to an additional #H....
The Supreme Court dealt with the three sub-sections of S.142-A as follows: ... "Sub-section (1) provided that a tax on professions, etc., would not be invalid on the ground that it related to a tax on income. ... ... It was also apprehended that under the guise of taxes on professions, etc., the Provincial Legislature might start their own scheme of a tax on income, thus subjecting incomes from professions, etc. to an additional #H....
Beg largdy shared the view of Justice Pathak that the tax on circumstances and property was a composite tax and not merely a tax on professions, trades, callings or employments and therefore, the limit imposed by Article 276 (2) was not applicable to the tax. ... , trades, callings and employments shall not exceed two hundred and fifty rupees per annum was not applicable. ... For the levy of #HL_S....
That is how, the Professions Tax Act became applicable to the Union Territory of Chandigarh. So far as the State of Punjab is concerned, it has repealed this Act; and now in the territories of Punjab, no such tax is recovered. "The position, that emerges after the reorganisation, is that the laws prevailing in the State of Punjab before its reorganisation, were to remain applicable to the reorganised territories, that is, the territories transferred to Himachal Pradesh; the territories declared as Union territories, the territories forming the State of Haryana; and to what ....
In the former case, it will have to be paid by any person practising that trade, profession etc., whether he derives any income from it or not. by stating that such law shall not be invalid on the ground that it relates to a tax on income. There is a distinction between a tax on professions, trades, callings and employments and a tax on income arising out of such professions, trades etc.. This is where the above example of pensioner becomes relevant.
The Apex Court in Kamtaprasad's case reported in AIR 1974 SC Page 685 has observed that a tax on profession is not necessarily connected with income, which is evident from the fact that the tax on professions is imposed by several municipal authorities at certain rates mentioned in the relevant statutes, but a tax can be imposed if there is an income. "A tax can be imposed if a person carries on a profession.
The court pointed out that the tax on receipt of pension or income from investments is, in truth and substance, a tax on income, and that it cannot be levied by the State unless it falls under and is saved by Art.276 of the Constitution. This article relates only to taxes on professions, trades, callings or employment; and tax on income from investments does not fall within its ambit.
An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers
Please visit our Training & Support
Center or Contact Us for assistance
Scan Me!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :
Back to top
