Searching Case Laws & Precedent on Legal Query!
Scanned Judgements…!
Searching Case Laws & Precedent on Legal Query!
Scanned Judgements…!
Parole vs. Furlough - Fundamental Difference Parole involves the suspension of the prison sentence during the period of release, effectively halting the sentence, while furlough does not suspend the sentence; the sentence continues to run during furlough. In furlough, the period is considered a remission or temporary leave without suspending the sentence. BUDHI SINGH Vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - Delhi, BUDHI SINGH vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - Delhi, DEEPAK SRIVASTAV Vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS. - Delhi, BUDHI SINGH vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - Delhi, DEVENDER SINGH vs THE STATE (GOVT OF NCT) OF DELHI - Delhi
Computation of Sentence and Conditions The term of imprisonment is not included in the calculation of parole but is included in furlough. Both are conditional releases, but parole is often granted for short-term imprisonment or exigencies like health or family emergencies, whereas furlough is typically granted for long-term prisoners as a good conduct remission. DEEPAK SRIVASTAV Vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS. - Delhi, BUDHI SINGH vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - Delhi, DEVENDER SINGH vs THE STATE (GOVT OF NCT) OF DELHI - Delhi
Purpose and Nature of Release Parole aims to meet specific exigencies such as health issues, emergencies, or compassionate grounds, with the sentence being suspended during this period. Furlough is granted mainly to maintain familial relations, provide relief, or for good behavior, with the sentence continuing to run. Furlough is also often seen as a form of remission. BUDHI SINGH Vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - Delhi, DEVENDER SINGH vs THE STATE (GOVT OF NCT) OF DELHI - Delhi, BUDHI SINGH vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - Delhi
Eligibility and Conditions Undertrial prisoners are generally not entitled to parole or furlough unless specific provisions or interim bail are granted. Eligibility depends on rules, length of imprisonment, and prior releases. Violations, such as jumping parole, are considered serious. The possibility of absconding is a concern, but factual basis for such apprehensions must be established. - Himachal Pradesh, DEVENDER SINGH vs THE STATE (GOVT OF NCT) OF DELHI - Delhi, BUDHI SINGH vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - Delhi, SANDEEP Vs STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS - Punjab and Haryana
Legal References and Case Law The Supreme Court in State of Rajasthan & Ors. (2017) SCC 55 highlighted that parole is generally for short-term releases based on exigencies, while furlough is a longer-term remission granted for good conduct. The Court emphasized the difference in purpose, with parole often suspending the sentence and furlough not doing so. BUDHI SINGH Vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - Delhi, DEEPAK SRIVASTAV Vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS. - Delhi, DEVENDER SINGH vs THE STATE (GOVT OF NCT) OF DELHI - Delhi
Analysis and ConclusionThe key distinction lies in the suspension of the sentence during parole, which is not the case with furlough. Parole is typically granted for urgent reasons, with the sentence suspended, whereas furlough is a remission granted for good conduct without suspending the sentence. Both are conditional, but their purposes, eligibility, and legal implications differ significantly. BUDHI SINGH Vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - Delhi, BUDHI SINGH vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - Delhi, BUDHI SINGH vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - Delhi
In the realm of correctional justice, terms like parole and furlough often spark confusion among the public, legal enthusiasts, and even families of inmates. A common question arises: What is the difference between parole and furlough? Both mechanisms allow prisoners temporary release from custody, but they serve distinct purposes within India's prison system. Understanding these differences is crucial for grasping how the law balances rehabilitation, public safety, and prisoner rights.
This blog post delves into the definitions, objectives, legal frameworks, key distinctions, and judicial interpretations of parole and furlough, primarily under Indian law. Drawing from statutes like the Bombay Furlough and Parole Rules, 1959, and landmark Supreme Court judgments, we'll clarify these concepts. Note: This is general information based on legal precedents and is not specific legal advice. Consult a qualified lawyer for individual cases.
Parole refers to the temporary release of a prisoner before completing their sentence, typically granted for specific reasons such as family emergencies, health issues, or other exigencies. RAHUL ALIAS PUNEET ALIAS PHILLIPS Vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - 2025 Supreme(DEL) 237Anil Shankarrao Zade VS State of Maharashtra, through Deputy Inspector General - 2001 0 Supreme(Bom) 774Atbir VS State of NCT of Delhi - 2022 5 Supreme 140. Its objectives include:- Enabling prisoners to maintain social and family ties.- Promoting psychological and physiological well-being.- Motivating good conduct and discipline in prison.- Acting as a conditional pardon with strict conditions. RAHUL ALIAS PUNEET ALIAS PHILLIPS Vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - 2025 Supreme(DEL) 237Anil Shankarrao Zade VS State of Maharashtra, through Deputy Inspector General - 2001 0 Supreme(Bom) 774
A fundamental aspect is that parole involves the suspension of the prison sentence during the period of release, effectively halting the sentence. BUDHI SINGH Vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - DelhiBUDHI SINGH vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - DelhiDEEPAK SRIVASTAV Vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS. - DelhiBUDHI SINGH vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - DelhiDEVENDER SINGH vs THE STATE (GOVT OF NCT) OF DELHI - Delhi
Furlough is a short-term, incentivized leave granted to long-term prisoners as a reward for good conduct, aimed at breaking the monotony of incarceration and aiding rehabilitation. RAHUL ALIAS PUNEET ALIAS PHILLIPS Vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - 2025 Supreme(DEL) 237Atbir VS State of NCT of Delhi - 2022 5 Supreme 140Anil Shankarrao Zade VS State of Maharashtra, through Deputy Inspector General - 2001 0 Supreme(Bom) 774. Key objectives are:- Fostering family and social integration.- Motivating good behavior.- Supporting psychological recovery.- Serving as a remission of part of the sentence, subject to conditions. RAHUL ALIAS PUNEET ALIAS PHILLIPS Vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - 2025 Supreme(DEL) 237Atbir VS State of NCT of Delhi - 2022 5 Supreme 140Anil Shankarrao Zade VS State of Maharashtra, through Deputy Inspector General - 2001 0 Supreme(Bom) 774
Unlike parole, furlough does not suspend the sentence; the sentence continues to run during furlough, and the period is considered a remission or temporary leave. BUDHI SINGH Vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - DelhiBUDHI SINGH vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - DelhiDEEPAK SRIVASTAV Vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS. - DelhiBUDHI SINGH vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - DelhiDEVENDER SINGH vs THE STATE (GOVT OF NCT) OF DELHI - Delhi
India's prison systems are regulated by state-specific rules, with the Bombay Furlough and Parole Rules, 1959 providing a model framework. The Indian Penal Code (IPC) does not directly govern these, but prison manuals and rules do. Key provisions include:
Additionally, Section 32-A of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985, prohibits counting furlough as remission for certain drug offenses. Anil Shankarrao Zade VS State of Maharashtra, through Deputy Inspector General - 2001 0 Supreme(Bom) 774
Courts have shaped these concepts significantly:- State of Maharashtra v. Suresh Pandurang Darvakar (2006): Furlough is a substantial legal right subject to rules; applications must be considered on merit. RAHUL ALIAS PUNEET ALIAS PHILLIPS Vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - 2025 Supreme(DEL) 237- Sharad Keshav Mehta v. State of Maharashtra (1989): Rule 17 cannot deprive prisoners of their substantial right to furlough if conditions are met. State of Gujarat VS Narayan @ Narayan Sai @ Mota Bhagwan Asaram @ Asumal Harpalani - 2021 7 Supreme 396- Jayant Veerappa Shetty v. State of Maharashtra: Pendency of appeal does not bar furlough. Sharad Bhiku Marchande VS State of Maharashtra & others - 1990 0 Supreme(Bom) 300- Supreme Court in State of Rajasthan & Ors. (2017) SCC 55: Parole for short-term exigencies (sentence suspended); furlough as longer-term remission for good conduct (sentence runs). BUDHI SINGH Vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - DelhiDEEPAK SRIVASTAV Vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS. - DelhiDEVENDER SINGH vs THE STATE (GOVT OF NCT) OF DELHI - Delhi
Recent High Court observations note eligibility even if not previously released on two occasions, provided reporting history is good. JAMALUDDHIN NIZAMUDDHIN KHAN vs STATE OF MAHARASHTRA, THR. SECRETARY HOME DEPARTMENT, MANTRALAYA-MUMBAI AND ANOTHER - BombayNANDU S/O SOMA KAMDI vs STATE OF MAH. THR. SUPERINTENDENT OF CENTRAL PRISON AMRAVATI DIST.AMRAVATI - BombayDINESH S/O ASHOKRAO ATHAWALE vs SUPERINTENDENT OF JAIL CENTRAL PRISON AMRAVATI DIST.AMRAVATI - Bombay
| Aspect | Parole | Furlough ||-----------------|---------------------------------------------|---------------------------------------------|| Purpose | Specific emergencies (health, family); discretionary. RAHUL ALIAS PUNEET ALIAS PHILLIPS Vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - 2025 Supreme(DEL) 237Anil Shankarrao Zade VS State of Maharashtra, through Deputy Inspector General - 2001 0 Supreme(Bom) 774 | Reward for good conduct; rehabilitation. RAHUL ALIAS PUNEET ALIAS PHILLIPS Vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - 2025 Supreme(DEL) 237Atbir VS State of NCT of Delhi - 2022 5 Supreme 140 || Duration | Shorter, up to 1 month. RAHUL ALIAS PUNEET ALIAS PHILLIPS Vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - 2025 Supreme(DEL) 237Anil Shankarrao Zade VS State of Maharashtra, through Deputy Inspector General - 2001 0 Supreme(Bom) 774Atbir VS State of NCT of Delhi - 2022 5 Supreme 140 | Longer, several weeks, multiple spells. RAHUL ALIAS PUNEET ALIAS PHILLIPS Vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - 2025 Supreme(DEL) 237Anil Shankarrao Zade VS State of Maharashtra, through Deputy Inspector General - 2001 0 Supreme(Bom) 774Atbir VS State of NCT of Delhi - 2022 5 Supreme 140 || Sentence Impact | Suspended (not counted). BUDHI SINGH Vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - DelhiBUDHI SINGH vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - Delhi | Continues (counts as remission). Anil Shankarrao Zade VS State of Maharashtra, through Deputy Inspector General - 2001 0 Supreme(Bom) 774 || Legal Status| Generally discretionary relief. | Substantial right if eligible. RAHUL ALIAS PUNEET ALIAS PHILLIPS Vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - 2025 Supreme(DEL) 237State of Gujarat VS Narayan @ Narayan Sai @ Mota Bhagwan Asaram @ Asumal Harpalani - 2021 7 Supreme 396 || Authority | Higher (e.g., Divisional Commissioners). RAHUL ALIAS PUNEET ALIAS PHILLIPS Vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - 2025 Supreme(DEL) 237Anil Shankarrao Zade VS State of Maharashtra, through Deputy Inspector General - 2001 0 Supreme(Bom) 774 | Deputy Inspectors General. RAHUL ALIAS PUNEET ALIAS PHILLIPS Vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - 2025 Supreme(DEL) 237Anil Shankarrao Zade VS State of Maharashtra, through Deputy Inspector General - 2001 0 Supreme(Bom) 774 |
Parole aims to meet specific exigencies, with sentence suspension, while furlough provides relief for familial ties and good behavior, without suspension. BUDHI SINGH Vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - DelhiDEVENDER SINGH vs THE STATE (GOVT OF NCT) OF DELHI - DelhiBUDHI SINGH vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - Delhi
Eligibility typically requires good conduct, no pending serious charges, and non-dangerous status. RAHUL ALIAS PUNEET ALIAS PHILLIPS Vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - 2025 Supreme(DEL) 237Sharad Bhiku Marchande VS State of Maharashtra & others - 1990 0 Supreme(Bom) 300Atbir VS State of NCT of Delhi - 2022 5 Supreme 140. Undertrials are generally ineligible unless via interim bail. - Himachal PradeshDEVENDER SINGH vs THE STATE (GOVT OF NCT) OF DELHI - DelhiBUDHI SINGH vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - Delhi
Refusal grounds include:- Public safety concerns.- Pending investigations.- Past misconduct or escape risks. RAHUL ALIAS PUNEET ALIAS PHILLIPS Vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - 2025 Supreme(DEL) 237Sharad Bhiku Marchande VS State of Maharashtra & others - 1990 0 Supreme(Bom) 300
Apprehensions of absconding must have a factual basis; mere possibility isn't enough. SANDEEP Vs STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS - Punjab and Haryana There is a mark difference between the two meetings. Secondly, apprehension that the petitioner would abscond, has no factual basis.
Courts stress that furlough is not absolute but a substantive right when conditions are met, and denials must be justified. State of Gujarat VS Narayan @ Narayan Sai @ Mota Bhagwan Asaram @ Asumal Harpalani - 2021 7 Supreme 396RAHUL ALIAS PUNEET ALIAS PHILLIPS Vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - 2025 Supreme(DEL) 237. Applications require merit-based consideration, balancing rights and safety. RAHUL ALIAS PUNEET ALIAS PHILLIPS Vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - 2025 Supreme(DEL) 237. Furlough is an important rehabilitative tool, distinct from parole. RAHUL ALIAS PUNEET ALIAS PHILLIPS Vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - 2025 Supreme(DEL) 237Anil Shankarrao Zade VS State of Maharashtra, through Deputy Inspector General - 2001 0 Supreme(Bom) 774
Parole and furlough, while both conditional releases, differ fundamentally: parole suspends sentences for urgencies, whereas furlough offers remission for good conduct without suspension. Governed by rules like Bombay 1959 and affirmed by judgments, furlough emerges as a substantial right, promoting rehabilitation.
Key Takeaways:- Parole: Emergency-driven, discretionary, sentence paused.- Furlough: Reward-based, right-conditioned, sentence runs.- Always apply through proper channels; courts mandate fair review.
For personalized guidance, seek legal counsel. Stay informed on evolving prison reforms.
Sources:RAHUL ALIAS PUNEET ALIAS PHILLIPS Vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - 2025 Supreme(DEL) 237Anil Shankarrao Zade VS State of Maharashtra, through Deputy Inspector General - 2001 0 Supreme(Bom) 774Atbir VS State of NCT of Delhi - 2022 5 Supreme 140State of Gujarat VS Narayan @ Narayan Sai @ Mota Bhagwan Asaram @ Asumal Harpalani - 2021 7 Supreme 396Sharad Bhiku Marchande VS State of Maharashtra & others - 1990 0 Supreme(Bom) 300BUDHI SINGH Vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - DelhiBUDHI SINGH vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - DelhiDEEPAK SRIVASTAV Vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS. - DelhiBUDHI SINGH vs STATE OF NCT OF DELHI - DelhiDEVENDER SINGH vs THE STATE (GOVT OF NCT) OF DELHI - DelhiJAMALUDDHIN NIZAMUDDHIN KHAN vs STATE OF MAHARASHTRA, THR. SECRETARY HOME DEPARTMENT, MANTRALAYA-MUMBAI AND ANOTHER - BombayNANDU S/O SOMA KAMDI vs STATE OF MAH. THR. SUPERINTENDENT OF CENTRAL PRISON AMRAVATI DIST.AMRAVATI - BombayDINESH S/O ASHOKRAO ATHAWALE vs SUPERINTENDENT OF JAIL CENTRAL PRISON AMRAVATI DIST.AMRAVATI - BombaySANDEEP Vs STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS - Punjab and Haryana
#ParoleVsFurlough, #PrisonLawIndia, #LegalRights
The difference between bail, furlough and parole was also considered by a two-judge Bench of this Court in State of Haryana v. Mohinder Singh. ... However, as discussed above, there is a fundamental difference between parole and furlough. In case of furlough the sentence is not suspended during the period for which the prisoner is released. ... Summarising the #HL_STA....
Another difference between these two terms is that term of imprisonment is not included in computation of the term of parole, whereas it is vice-versa in furlough. ... Summarising the difference between parole and furlough, the Court noted that : (Asfaq case [Asfaq v. State of Rajasthan, (2017) 15 SCC 55 : (2018) 1 SCC (Cri) 390] , SCC pp. 61-62, para 16) “16. … (i) Both parol....
or furlough). ... If the convicts are not released on 2 occasions either on furlough or parole and/or their such convicts are never released either on furlough or parole have earlier released on furlough twice and had reported back in time.
However, as discussed above, there is a fundamental difference between parole and furlough. In case of furlough the sentence is not suspended during the period for which the prisoner is released. ... State of Rajasthan & Ors.: (2017)15 SCC 55; has summarized the difference between parole and furlough which reads as under: “16. ... The concept of f....
or furlough). ... The petitioner applied for grant of emergency parole under Rule 19(1)(C)(ii) of the Maharashtra Prisons (Bombay Furlough and Parole) released on 2 occasions either on furlough or parole and/or their on 2 occasions or on 1 occasion, either on parole or furlough either on furlough or parole pr....
State of Rajasthan and Others : (2017) 15 SCC 55 while summarising the difference between parole and furlough, and the grounds to grant the same observed as under: “11. There is a subtle distinction between parole and furlough. ... Furlough, on the other hand, is a brief release from the prison. It is conditional and is given in case of long-term imprisonment. The period of sentence spen....
furlough or parole and therefore, there was no occasion for them to return back within time on 2 occasions and therefore, not released on 2 occasions either on furlough or parole and/or their released on furlough leave in the year 2020 but has not availed parole leave difference between Clause (C)(i) and (ii).
There is a mark difference between the two meetings. Secondly, apprehension that the petitioner would abscond, has no factual basis. ... That a prisoner shall not be entitled to be released on parole/furlough if it is likely to endanger the security of the state or the maintenance of public order or cause reasonable apprehension ... The prisoner can commit any crime after releasing on parole. Due to which the poss....
In such an event, for 4 years, such a person was not entitled to parole or furlough, and after conviction, he shall not be entitled to temporary release or parole or furlough because he is not entitled to temporary release or parole until the completion of one year’s imprisonment as a convict. ... Therefore, he may not be entitled to parole or furlough like a convict p....
However, as discussed above, there is a fundamental difference between parole and furlough. In case of furlough the sentence is not suspended during the period for which the prisoner is released. ... The terms bail, furlough and parole have different connotations. ... to be achieved in granting parole or furlough to prisoners/convicts. ... Single Judge....
An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers
Please visit our Training & Support
Center or Contact Us for assistance
Scan Me!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :
Back to top
