Searching Case Laws & Precedent on Legal Query!
Scanned Judgements…!
Searching Case Laws & Precedent on Legal Query!
Scanned Judgements…!
Compensation Awards for Ulnar Styloid Fractures Several cases have awarded damages for closed ulnar styloid fractures, often in conjunction with distal radius fractures. Notably, Soong Chee Kian & Satu Lagi ["2016"] 2 PIR 59 awarded RM20,000 for fracture of the right ulnar styloid, and Teh Poh Choon ["2012"] 1 PIR 74 granted RM25,000 for closed fracture at the distal end of the left radius and ulnar styloid, indicating a recognized standard for such injuries. Similarly, the case involving the appellant with bilateral fractures awarded RM33,000, including damages for left ulna styloid injury [](https://supremetoday.ai/doc/judgement/MY_PILRU_2018_PILRU_67).
Legal Recognition of Ulnar Styloid Fractures The courts acknowledge ulnar styloid fractures as significant injuries, often linked with other wrist fractures, and have awarded damages accordingly. For example, in Chong Kiat Mian v. ["unspecified"], the injury was considered more serious than similar cases, and damages of RM17,000 were awarded for a styloid fracture ["MOHAMED ZAIN IBRAHIM DAN YANG LAIN-LAIN LAGI LWN. ASIAN RENT A CAR SDN BHD DAN LAGI SATU - Sessions Court"]. In another case, an award of RM40,000 was granted for fracture of the distal end of left radius with associated ulnar styloid injury, emphasizing the injury's impact ["Samsuri Lajis v. Mohd Asrul Mahmod [2010"]].
Injury Severity and Disability Assessments Cases such as the one involving the appellant with bilateral radius and ulnar styloid fractures illustrate that these injuries can lead to permanent disability, muscle wasting, and movement limitations. Awards ranged from RM18,000 to RM33,000, depending on severity and associated disabilities ["ANTO THOMAS vs SATHISH BABU - Kerala"], ["ANTO THOMAS vs SATHISH BABU - Kerala"], [](https://supremetoday.ai/doc/judgement/MY_PILRU_2018_PILRU_67).
Relevance of Medical Evidence Medical reports consistently confirm the nature of the fractures and their consequences, supporting the awards and legal recognition of the injury's seriousness. The injuries often include wrist dislocation, radial and ulnar styloid fractures, and associated disabilities such as limited movement and muscle wasting.
References:["VASANTHI BALAKRISNAN LWN. SUNWAY MEDICAL CENTRE SDN BHD & SATU LAGI - High Court"] ["R VEERASINGAM RAMASAMY LWN. ZAMZURI JAIS & SATU LAGI - 2022 MarsdenLR 1714"] ["Samsuri Lajis v. Mohd Asrul Mahmod [2010"]] [](https://supremetoday.ai/doc/judgement/MY_PILRU_2018_PILRU_67) ["ANTO THOMAS vs SATHISH BABU - Kerala"] ["ANTO THOMAS vs SATHISH BABU - Kerala"]
If you've sustained a closed fracture of the right ulnar styloid in an accident, you might be wondering: Please provide me case laws for closed fracture of right ulnar styloid. This common wrist injury often arises in personal injury claims, particularly negligence cases from road accidents or falls. Malaysian courts typically assess damages based on precedents, medical evidence, and injury severity. While no single case directly mirrors every scenario, judicial opinions offer clear guidance on compensation ranges—generally from RM20,000 to RM36,000 for similar fractures. This post analyzes key cases, legal principles, and comparable awards to help you understand potential outcomes. Note: This is general information, not legal advice. Consult a qualified lawyer for your specific situation.
Ulnar styloid fractures involve the bony projection at the end of the ulna bone near the wrist, often linked to distal radius fractures from trauma like falls or collisions. In personal injury litigation, plaintiffs seek damages for pain, suffering, medical costs, and loss of earning capacity. Courts emphasize:- Precedent-based assessment: Awards align with prior similar cases.- Anatomical factors: Proximity to the radius influences whether damages are combined or separate.- Medical evidence: Lack of proof for heightened severity keeps awards within standard ranges. R VEERASINGAM RAMASAMY LWN. ZAMZURI JAIS & SATU LAGI - 2022 MarsdenLR 1714
Malaysian courts frequently reference the Compendium of Personal Injury Awards for wrist and forearm injuries, ensuring consistency. R VEERASINGAM RAMASAMY LWN. ZAMZURI JAIS & SATU LAGI - 2022 MarsdenLR 1714
In this landmark case, the court awarded RM36,000 for fractures at the lower ends of the radius and ulnar styloid. This sets a high-end benchmark for closed fractures with associated wrist trauma. AINI ABDULLAH vs NATHAN ATHIMOOLAM - 2023 MarsdenLR 1633
Here, RM20,000 was granted for an open fracture of the distal third of the radius/ulna. Though slightly more severe due to being open, it provides a baseline for closed variants. Courts noted the current claim's proposed RM18,000 global sum was reasonable absent evidence of greater severity. AINI ABDULLAH vs NATHAN ATHIMOOLAM - 2023 MarsdenLR 1633
The court recommended damages between RM21,500 and RM36,000 for anatomically close injuries like ulnar styloid and distal radius fractures, citing the Compendium. The proximity of the ulnar styloid and distal radius is significant in damages assessment. R VEERASINGAM RAMASAMY LWN. ZAMZURI JAIS & SATU LAGI - 2022 MarsdenLR 1714
In cases of adjacent bone injuries, consolidated lump-sum awards are preferred to reflect overall impact, as seen in Kim Lin Chan v. Lee Hua Sing, where individual sums were considered but combined in practice. R VEERASINGAM RAMASAMY LWN. ZAMZURI JAIS & SATU LAGI - 2022 MarsdenLR 1714
Broader precedents reinforce these ranges, particularly where ulnar styloid fractures accompany other wrist injuries:
International insights from Indian courts (analogous in common law principles) show similar approaches:- ANTO THOMAS vs SATHISH BABU - Kerala_HC_KLHC010260192005: For trans-scaphoid perilunar dislocation with radial and ulnar styloid fractures, the court assessed 6% earning capacity reduction, emphasizing compensation for pain and loss. ANTO THOMAS vs SATHISH BABU - 2011 Supreme(Online)(KER) 43813- ANTO THOMAS vs SATHISH BABU - Kerala_HC_KLHC010242952004: Fracture right ulnar styloid alongside leg fractures led to enhanced awards for disabilities, stressing fair reflection of actual earnings. SHIJU P.V. Vs PAUL N.X. - 2008 Supreme(Online)(KER) 42394- HAREESH T. A. VS SANTHOSHKUMAR - 2015 Supreme(Ker) 911: Fracture of radial and ulnar styloid with plaster treatment warranted higher loss-of-earnings compensation beyond Rs.3,000, underscoring inadequate initial awards. HAREESH T. A. VS SANTHOSHKUMAR - 2015 Supreme(Ker) 911- ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO. LTD. VS R. SHIVAKUMAR - 2015 Supreme(Kar) 188: Severe case with fracture Radial Styloid and Ulnar Styloid resulted in 41.5% whole-body disability; compensation enhanced to Rs.21,68,600, including Rs.1,50,000 for pain. ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO. LTD. VS R. SHIVAKUMAR - 2015 Supreme(Kar) 188- Miss Kumud Pagi VS Gurudas Shet Gaonkar - 2012 Supreme(Bom) 962: Compound ulnar styloid fracture yielded Rs.40,000 for pain, with 23% disability. Miss Kumud Pagi VS Gurudas Shet Gaonkar - 2012 Supreme(Bom) 962- Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. VS Teekaam Chand Jain - 2011 Supreme(Raj) 418 and Yadava Kumar VS The Divisional Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd. - 2010 Supreme(SC) 808: Bilateral radius/ulnar styloid fractures caused 20-33% upper limb disability, preventing work like painting; awards included future earnings loss using multipliers. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. VS Teekaam Chand Jain - 2011 Supreme(Raj) 418Yadava Kumar VS The Divisional Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd. - Samsuri Lajis v. Mohd Asrul Mahmod [2010 Supreme(SC) 808
These cases illustrate courts' tendency to award higher for functional impairment, often 20-40% of affected limbs translating to whole-body percentages.
Bullet-point takeaways:- Use Compendium for ranges.- Factor liability shares (e.g., 50-50 in collisions). MOHAMAD AZHAR YUSSOH vs MOHAMAD HAIRUL ALHAFIZ ZAN IMI & ANOR- Include pain, medicals, future loss where disability proven.
Typically, plaintiffs propose globals like RM18,000, adjusted by courts. Always document everything.
Malaysian courts consistently award RM20,000-RM36,000 for ulnar styloid fractures, guided by precedents like Chong Kiat MianAINI ABDULLAH vs NATHAN ATHIMOOLAM - 2023 MarsdenLR 1633 and anatomical principles R VEERASINGAM RAMASAMY LWN. ZAMZURI JAIS & SATU LAGI - 2022 MarsdenLR 1714. Additional cases affirm focus on disability and fairness MOHAMAD AZHAR YUSSOH vs MOHAMAD HAIRUL ALHAFIZ ZAN IMI & ANOR. If pursuing a claim, gather strong medical proof to argue for the upper range.
Key Takeaways:- Benchmark: RM18,000-RM36,000 globals common.- Precedents drive decisions; cite them.- Proximity and evidence matter most.
For tailored advice, contact a personal injury specialist. Stay safe on the roads!
Sources: AINI ABDULLAH vs NATHAN ATHIMOOLAM - 2023 MarsdenLR 1633R VEERASINGAM RAMASAMY LWN. ZAMZURI JAIS & SATU LAGI - 2022 MarsdenLR 1714MOHAMAD AZHAR YUSSOH vs MOHAMAD HAIRUL ALHAFIZ ZAN IMI & ANORANTO THOMAS vs SATHISH BABU - 2011 Supreme(Online)(KER) 43813SHIJU P.V. Vs PAUL N.X. - 2008 Supreme(Online)(KER) 42394HAREESH T. A. VS SANTHOSHKUMAR - 2015 Supreme(Ker) 911ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO. LTD. VS R. SHIVAKUMAR - 2015 Supreme(Kar) 188Miss Kumud Pagi VS Gurudas Shet Gaonkar - 2012 Supreme(Bom) 962Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. VS Teekaam Chand Jain - 2011 Supreme(Raj) 418Yadava Kumar VS The Divisional Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd. - Samsuri Lajis v. Mohd Asrul Mahmod [2010 Supreme(SC) 808
#UlnarStyloidFracture, #PersonalInjuryLaw, #MalaysiaDamages
It is also likely that Dr Hisham has missed the fracture of the ulnar styloid from the very first instance, resulting in him not discussing options of treatment for the ulnar styloid fracture with his patient. ... These are partly the features of the ulnar styloid fracture in Ms Vasanthi's wrist. However, there are many schools of thoughts to surgical fixation of ulnar styloid injuries.... ... Lo....
end left radius, and for fracture of left ulnar styloid. ... Soong Chee Kian & Satu Lagi; [2016] 2 PIR 59 di mana dalam kedua-dua kes tersebut, RM20,000.00 dibenarkan bagi kecederaan "fracture of the right ulnar styloid". ... Closed Fracture Distal End Left Radius Closed Fracture Left Ulnar Styloid Reduced Muscle Power [42] Plaintif merujuk kepada Revised Compe....
would be an equitable amount for fracture of distal end left radius, and for fracture of left ulnar styloid. ... of the left radius ulna/ ulnar styloid process" (e) - Mahkamah Tinggi mengesahkan award Mahkamah Sesyen berjumlah RM28,000.00 bagi "closed fracture of distal end right radius and ulna styloid" ; [2012] 1 PIR 74 di mana Mahkamah membenarkan award RM25,000.00 bagi "closed fract....
fracture left ulna styloid and closed fracture distal radius with radial styloid fracture suffered by the Plaintiff here is significantly more serious than the fractures of the lower ends of and left radius and ulnar styloid in the case of Chong Kiat Mian v. ... [49] In our present case there is no medical opinion to state that the closed fracture left ulna styloid#HL_....
retinae; closed right wrist dislocation with right radius and ulnar styloid fracture". ... radius ulnar styloid fracture, multiple facial fractures as described above, frontal concussion and right subconjunctival haemorrhage and right multiple orbital fracture". ... 16) Right Wrist Subluxation with Closed Radius Ulnar #HL_STA....
, subconjunctival and subretinal haemorrhages with left eye commotion retinae; closed right wrist dislocation with right radius and ulnar styloid fracture". ... medical and specialist reports which have noted the injuries and disabilities: (a) Hospital Raja Permaisuri Bainun Ipoh: "diagnosis - wrist subluxation with closed radius ulnar styloid fracture, multiple facial fractures as described above, frontal concussi....
He had suffered with trans-scaphoid perilunar dislocation right wrist, fracture of the radial styloid, fracture of the ulnar styloid and compound fracture right 1st and 2nd toe. He was treated with wound debridement strapping, closed reduction and plaster application. ... We are satisfied in the facts and circumstances of this case that 6% can safely be reckoned as the extent of reduction in earning capacity. 6.
Fracture to both bone right leg. 7. Fracture right ulnar styloid." 2. He was an inpatient till 26.2.1999 for 99 days. ... Fracture (Rt) ulnar styloid. He was treated by sound debridement, external fixation (Rt) leg and K.Wire fixation (Rt) foot. He underwent amputation of 4th toe at MTP level. ... The fracture of both bones right leg was mal united with postero medial bowing of right#HL_....
Close Fracture Distal End Left Radius and Ulnar Styloid. ... styloid". ... Chan Kook Shang & Anor [2003] 3 MLJ xvi di mana Mahkamah mengawardkan RM17,000 untuk 'fracture ulna styloid' dan kes Samsuri Lajis & Anor v. Mohd Asrul Mahmod [2010] 1 PIR [7] dimana Mahkamah mengawardkan RM40,000 untuk kecederaan "fracture of the distal end of left radius (the fracture has united with gross stiffness of the hand movements), award sejumlah RM30,000.00 adalah w....
Closed fracture of the left distal and radius with volar displacement & left ulna styloid fracture ii. ... Closed fracture of the left distal and radius with volar displacement & left ulna styloid fracture: RM33,000.00 ii. Scars: RM3,000.00 iii. Future surgery: RM16,000.00 iv. Pain & suffering: RM10,000.00 v. ... - Based on my understanding, the ulna styloid fractures will normally come together with the radius and ulna. These are ....
It is seen that Plaster of Paris was applied on the right hand of the claimant as part of the treatment. Despite the fact that Plaster of Paris was applied on the claimant, the Tribunal granted only a sum of Rs.3000/- towards loss of earnings. He sustained various injuries in the accident including fracture of radial and ulnar styloid.
Base with fracture Radial Styloid and Ulnar Styloid with severe; f) Crushing of 4th and 5th fingers Degloving right thigh with cut lacerated wound 10 x 3 cm. medial aspect of the right foot; e) Crush injury right hand with fracture of 2nd and 3rd proximal phalanz. The injuries sustained by the claimant are evident from Exs. P4 and P5 discharge summaries and supported by oral evidence of the claimant and two doctors, who were examined as PWs1 to 3 respectively.
The doctor had assessed disability at 23% of the whole body. It can be easily said that the claimant underwent lot of pain, shock and sufferings. An amount of Rs. 40,000/- was awarded towards pain & suffering. In the case of “Nagarajappa” (supra), the claimant sustained injuries of compound fracture of ulnar styloid process of the left hand and subluxation of the left wrist.
In the instant case, the appellant has sustained a fracture of distal end of left radius with fracture of left ulnar styloid process and fracture of distal end of right radius with mild diastasis and soft tissues swelling around the wrist joint. The doctor has assessed the disability at 33% in respect of the right upper limb and 21% towards left upper limb and 20% in respect of the whole body, which prevents the appellant from painting in view of multiple injuries sustained by him.
In this case, the appellant has sustained a fracture of distal end of left radius with fracture of left ulnar styloid process and fracture distal end of right radius with mild diastosis and soft tissues swelling around wrist joint. The doctor has assessed the disability at 33% in respect of the right upper limb and 21% towards left upper limb and 20% in respect of the whole body, which prevents the appellant from painting in view of multiple injuries sustained by him.
An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers
Please visit our Training & Support
Center or Contact Us for assistance
Scan Me!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :
Back to top
