Searching Case Laws & Precedent on Legal Query.....!
Scanned Judgements…!
Searching Case Laws & Precedent on Legal Query.....!
Scanned Judgements…!
Pay Fixation on Appointment in New Organization after VRS - When an employee takes Voluntary Retirement Scheme (VRS) from one government organization and then gets appointed in another, pay fixation depends on specific rules. Generally, if the employee resigns to take up another government post, their past service is protected and can be considered for pay fixation and pension benefits, provided the resignation does not entail forfeiture of service ["Mrs. Dheerja Sharma vs Chandigarh Administration through Secretary, Education, U.T. - Central Administrative Tribunal"] ["Gurcharan Singh vs Education Deptt. Ut Chandigarh - Central Administrative Tribunal"].
Past Service and Pensionary Benefits - Pensionary benefits are linked to qualifying service. Service rendered in previous government organizations, including KVS, can be counted for pension and pay fixation if the resignation was submitted to take up another government appointment where service qualifies for pension. Resignation under sub-rule 2 does not entail forfeiture of past service, allowing counting of previous service ["Mrs. Dheerja Sharma vs Chandigarh Administration through Secretary, Education, U.T. - Central Administrative Tribunal"] ["Gurcharan Singh vs Education Deptt. Ut Chandigarh - Central Administrative Tribunal"].
Pay Fixation Rules - Pay is typically fixed at the minimum of the pay scale unless pay protection is granted. In cases where employees switch organizations, pay fixation considers the last drawn pay, increments, and whether the service qualifies for pension. The rules specify that pay protection is granted, and previous service is counted, if the resignation was submitted to take up another government post ["Mrs. Dheerja Sharma vs Chandigarh Administration through Secretary, Education, U.T. - Central Administrative Tribunal"] ["Gurcharan Singh vs Education Deptt. Ut Chandigarh - Central Administrative Tribunal"].
Impact of VRS on Pay and Pension - Employees opting for VRS are entitled to terminal benefits, including gratuity and ex-gratia, based on their last drawn pay and length of service. However, pay revision benefits are generally not applicable post-VRS unless explicitly provided in the scheme. The pension is related to qualifying service, and once VRS is availed, additional benefits are not usually granted for past service unless the scheme specifies otherwise ["Mrs. Dheerja Sharma vs Chandigarh Administration through Secretary, Education, U.T. - Central Administrative Tribunal"] ["Gurcharan Singh vs Education Deptt. Ut Chandigarh - Central Administrative Tribunal"] ["M.e.co.f.e.d vs SHRI TIKENDER SINGH - Meghalaya"].
Specific Case of Service in Other States or Organizations - Service rendered in other states or organizations like KVS can be counted for pension if the resignation was submitted to take up another government job, and the service qualifies under pension rules. Pay fixation and pension benefits depend on whether the resignation was accepted under rules that protect past service ["Mrs. Dheerja Sharma vs Chandigarh Administration through Secretary, Education, U.T. - Central Administrative Tribunal"] ["Gurcharan Singh vs Education Deptt. Ut Chandigarh - Central Administrative Tribunal"].
Analysis and Conclusion:In summary, if A takes VRS from one government organization and then secures an appointment in another government organization, his pay fixation and pension benefits depend on whether his resignation was accepted under rules that protect past service. If the resignation was submitted to take up another government post where the service qualifies for pension, then his previous service can be counted for pension and pay fixation purposes, and pay may be fixed with pay protection. However, specific schemes and rules (such as VRS schemes or pay protection OM) may restrict or specify the extent of benefits, often excluding pay revision benefits after VRS. Ultimately, the key factors are the nature of resignation, whether the previous service qualifies for pension, and applicable rules governing pay fixation and pension calculation ["Mrs. Dheerja Sharma vs Chandigarh Administration through Secretary, Education, U.T. - Central Administrative Tribunal"] ["Gurcharan Singh vs Education Deptt. Ut Chandigarh - Central Administrative Tribunal"].
Taking Voluntary Retirement Scheme (VRS) from one government organization and securing a new appointment in another is a common career move for many public servants seeking fresh opportunities. But a pressing question arises: if A takes VRS from one govt organization and gets appointment in another how his pay will be fixed taking into account the pensioary benefits of earlier service? This scenario raises concerns about service continuity, pay scales, and pension integration. In this post, we break down the general principles based on established rules and case law, helping you navigate these complexities.
Note: This is general information and not specific legal advice. Consult a qualified professional for your situation.
VRS, often termed a 'golden handshake,' is a voluntary exit option where employees receive a lump-sum package in exchange for terminating their service. Courts have consistently held that it leads to a complete cessation of the jural relationship between the employer and employee. Maharashtra State Financial Corporation Ex-Employees Association VS State of Maharashtra - 2023 1 Supreme 450A. K. Bindal VS Union Of India - 2003 3 Supreme 669 As one ruling states, The main purpose of paying this amount is to bring about a complete cessation of the jural relationship between the employer and the employee. A. K. Bindal VS Union Of India - 2003 3 Supreme 669
This severance means VRS optees are treated as a distinct class, separate from those who retire by superannuation or continue service without break. They cannot claim parity in benefits like pay revisions or service weightage. Maharashtra State Financial Corporation Ex-Employees Association VS State of Maharashtra - 2023 1 Supreme 450 Unlike resignation, which may allow service transfer in permitted government moves, VRS mandates full termination. P. Giri VS Managing Director, Tamil Nadu Transport Corporation Villupuram - 2013 0 Supreme(Mad) 2058Reserve Bank Of India VS Cecil Dennis Solomon - 2004 2 Supreme 371
Typically, upon joining a new government organization after VRS, your pay is fixed as per the recruiting organization's service rules for a fresh or new entrant. Previous service does not count for increments or adjustments. This stems from the contractual finality of VRS: An offer for voluntary retirement in terms of a scheme, when accepted, leads to a concluded contract. HEC Voluntary Retd. Emps. Welfare Soc. VS Heavy Engineering Corporation LTD. - 2006 2 Supreme 617
Supporting this, cases on re-employment post-VRS emphasize fresh fixation. For instance, in retrenchment followed by re-appointment scenarios (analogous in finality), pay is set at the initial stage without protection. Sanchareshwar Madhavrao Kadam VS Principal District Judge, Parbhani - 2019 Supreme(Bom) 1533 However, pure absorption cases (not VRS) may protect pay if rules allow, like under Rajasthan Service Rules Rule 26(1)(a)(ii). Mohd. Raiyazul Haq Qureshi VS State of Rajasthan - 2019 Supreme(Raj) 716
Pension from the previous service is calculated based on qualifying service up to the VRS date and paid separately by the prior employer. It does not factor into new pay fixation. Under CCS (Pension) Rules, voluntary retirement after 20 years qualifies for pension on exit emoluments, but exclusions apply for absorption cases. Union Of India VS Rakesh Kumar: Subhash Chand: P. K. Surendran Nair - 2001 3 Supreme 48
Key points:- Earned Pension: Based on actual service; no full weightage if VRS is for immediate re-employment in PSU/autonomous bodies. Union of India VS A. S. Gangoli - 2007 4 Supreme 260- Ex-Gratia Dominates: VRS packages include ex-gratia beyond normal terminal benefits, treated independently. Assistant General Manager, State Bank of India VS Radhey Shyam Pandey - 2015 0 Supreme(SC) 188- No Offset in New Salary: Prior pension runs alongside new emoluments without deduction or inclusion.
In VRS schemes, ex-gratia is often 1.5 months' emoluments per year of service, plus notice pay, with EOL considered if permitted. B.Rajeswari, Vs The StateM. SEENAPPA, CHITTOOR DIST & 3 OTHERS Vs PRL SECY, ANIMAL HUSBANDRY DAIRY DEV. & FISHERIES DEPT., HYD Pension remains assured but distinct. Union of India VS A. S. Gangoli - 2007 4 Supreme 260
When VRS is taken for immediate joining in PSUs/autonomous bodies, optees form a separate class due to assured re-employment perks. They receive pension without weightage but must obtain prior permission to avoid forfeiture. Union of India VS A. S. Gangoli - 2007 4 Supreme 260
For government-to-government moves, no explicit formulas exist, defaulting to termination principles. However, in redeployment (not VRS), prior service counts for pay/pension but not seniority. Deputy Director of Public Instructions, Udupi District, Udupi VS B. Pundalika Marathe - 2011 Supreme(Kar) 350
While VRS generally severs ties, exceptions arise:
In one case, continuous service post-takeover preserved benefits without fresh appointment, but VRS lacks such continuity. Tourism Corporation of Gujarat VS V. K Dharia - 2012 Supreme(Guj) 655
To manage transitions effectively:- Verify if your VRS qualifies as deputation absorption; seek pension transfer under CCS Rule 37-A/48-A if applicable.- Calculate prior pension on exit emoluments; new pay per FR/SR entry-level + qualifications.- Obtain prior permission for new role to safeguard benefits.- Plan finances assuming separate pension and fresh salary—no integration.
Legal heirs may claim arrears, but post-VRS claims are generally barred. Assistant General Manager VS Radhey Shyam Pandey - 2020 0 Supreme(SC) 218
Understanding these rules empowers informed decisions. For personalized guidance, reach out to service rule experts or legal counsel. Stay updated on pay commissions and notifications for evolving scenarios.
References:1. Maharashtra State Financial Corporation Ex-Employees Association VS State of Maharashtra - 2023 1 Supreme 450 - VRS cessation and distinct class.2. Union of India VS A. S. Gangoli - 2007 4 Supreme 260 - Premature retirement for PSU re-employment.3. A. K. Bindal VS Union Of India - 2003 3 Supreme 669 - Golden handshake finality.4. Assistant General Manager, State Bank of India VS Radhey Shyam Pandey - 2015 0 Supreme(SC) 188 - Contractual VRS nature.5. HEC Voluntary Retd. Emps. Welfare Soc. VS Heavy Engineering Corporation LTD. - 2006 2 Supreme 617 - Binding contract post-acceptance.6. Union Of India VS Rakesh Kumar: Subhash Chand: P. K. Surendran Nair - 2001 3 Supreme 48 - CCS Rule 48-A exclusions.7. P. Giri VS Managing Director, Tamil Nadu Transport Corporation Villupuram - 2013 0 Supreme(Mad) 2058 - Resignation transfer (distinguished).8. Reserve Bank Of India VS Cecil Dennis Solomon - 2004 2 Supreme 371 - VRS vs. resignation.
#VRSPayFixation, #GovtJobs, #PensionRules
In the State of Punjab, service of other states/U.Ts/Central Govt. is not counted for fixation of pay or for pensionary benefits. Moreover the pay-scale of both the posts was also different. ... The second claim of the applicant is for counting of service rendered by her in previous organization i.e. KVS for pensionary benefits. ... However, the pay of the applicant after appointment in Chandigarh Administration as....
In the State of Punjab, service of other States/U.Ts/Central Govt. is not counted for fixation of pay or for pensioary benefits. Moreover the pay-scale of both the posts was also different. ... He contended that the question whether service rendered in Govt. Aided Privately Managed Schools is countable towards pensionary benefits on retirement from Govt. ... The second claim of the applicant is for counting of #HL_....
scale for earlier period. ... revision once they have opted for VRS. ... to pay gratuity irrespective of the fact that they have accepted benefit under the VRS. ... which are not admissible under the Service Rules. ... of pay revisions in 1987 and 1996 in the State of Meghalaya which was adopted by the appellant organization for its p style="
1) An employee is regular or permanent, whose request for VRS is accepted would be entitled to an Ex-gratia payment equivalent to one and half months emoluments (Pay + DA) last drawn, for each completed year service or the monthly emoluments ... iii) E.O.L. up to a period of one year will be considered for calculation, of Ex-gratia benefits provided the service regulation of the concerned organization permit sanction of such E.O.L. ... The 3rd resp....
1) An employee is regular or permanent, whose request for VRS is accepted would be entitled to an Ex-gratia payment equivalent to one and half months emoluments (Pay + DA) last drawn, for each completed year service or ... One month/3 months notice pay as per the service conditions applicable. ... iii) E.O.L. up to a period of one year will be considered for calculation, of Ex-gratia benefits provided the service....
But, for another term contained in the voluntary retirement scheme that the pay of the petitioners would be re-fixed in the revised scales of pay there would not have been an occasion at all for BHEL to give a fresh look to the compensation and other terminal benefits paid to the petitioners. ... Hence, it is urged that the service on NMR or WC basis is not liable to be computed for the purposes of VRS benefits. ... Judgment ... This writ petition h....
The official will remain in service till the tenure of the present govt. or till his services are required by the Hon‟ble Chief Minister, Govt. of NCT of Delhi whichever is earlier. 4. ... ), i.e., last basic pay drawn + grade pay minus pension. ... was reduced to one rupee per month. ... It is also mentioned that the applicant does not get any right of account of the appointment and that the engagement can be termi....
encashment upon recalculation of the said amounts taking into account the revised pay structure. ... In the said case the Court was called upon to consider the constitutional validity of Regulation 9 of Delhi Road Transport Authority (Conditions of Appointment and Service) Regulations, 1952, which gave power to terminate the services of an employee after giving one month's notice or pay in lieu thereof ... As we have pointed out, paragraph 5(iii) of the VRS#....
VRS employees chose to opt and leave the service of the corporation; they found the VRS offer beneficial to them. ... scale for an earlier period. ... for payment of arrears on account of revision of pay-scales and allowances as also for the difference of voluntary retirement benefits accruing to them on account of revision of pay-scales, if and as may be made effective retrospectively to the employees of the Corporation by the Boar....
[9] The VRS Scheme nowhere suggests that one day's break, not attributable to the employee, would deprive him from the resultant benefits of continuous service. ... with one day's break, was required to be taken into account while determining the amount of compensation under the previous service towards VRS Scheme. ... While settling the claim of respondent under the VRS Scheme, only the regular service#HL_E....
Last pay on old post Initial pay on new post 1 2 3 (a) Substantive on a permanent post and not Officiating on a higher post. (1) A Government Servant already service in one service, cadre or department who is appointed to another service, cadre or department by direct recruitment or special selection, (including transfer other than by deputation) from one service, cadre or department to another and not by promotion according to service rules, shall have his initial pay fixed as follows:- Cate....
Since the petitioner was appointed afresh as per order No.820 dated 05.11.2015, his pay was liable to be fixed at the initial stage of the pay prescribed for the said post for junior clerk in the light of Rule 11 (1) (a) of the Maharashtra Civil Services (Pay) Rules. Therefore, there is no question of protection of pay of the petitioner. Since the petitioner has been given appointment afresh after retrenchment, his earlier service period was not liable to be taken into account for the purpose of pay protection and seniority and thus as per the new appointment, his pay has been righ....
Resultantly, the respondents shall recalculate the VRS amount by taking into account the pay-scale of old 4th central pay commission and the dearness allowance which was given to the employees of State Government at the time VRS was granted to the employees by the corporation.
The appellant is directed to recalculate the amount due and payable to the respondent-employees towards the retirement benefits under the VRS which was floated in the year 2000 and pay to the respondents the difference of amount after taking into consideration the period of service with respondent No.2 from 1980-1985. This exercise shall be undertaken and completed within a period of 3 months from the date of receipt of this order. 8. In the result, these appeals are devoid of merit and are accordingly dismissed along with the Civil Applications.
3. In terms of said provision of law, respondent herein will get seniority in the new institution from the date of joining with prospective effect pursuant to the order of redeployment. His earlier service in previous school will be taken into consideration for the purpose of pay, leave and pensionary benefits only. As such, last pay drawn by him in the previous school is saved for the purpose of fixing his pay in the new school in pursuance of aforesaid proviso referred to supra.
An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers
Please visit our Training & Support
Center or Contact Us for assistance
Scan Me!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :
Back to top
