The District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission in Panchkula has delivered a significant ruling against Reliance Retail Limited and Reliance Smart Superstore, holding the entities liable for deceptive trade practices and deficiency in service. The consumer forum’s decision stems from a complaint filed by a local resident, Nishtha Raghav, who alleged that the company unilaterally diverted partial refund amounts from her online grocery orders into a proprietary digital reward wallet instead of returning the funds to her original payment method. The Commission, presided over by Sh. Satpal with Members Dr. Sushma Garg and Dr. Suman Singh, directed the retailers to pay ₹2,500 as compensation to the complainant and imposed ₹5,000 in punitive damages, to be deposited with the Free Legal Aid State Commission of Haryana.

The dispute originated from two separate transactions conducted via the JioMart mobile application on January 23 and January 25, 2026. In both instances, the complainant ordered a specific chocolate product that was subsequently marked as unavailable. While the retailer sent digital notifications confirming that a full refund of ₹19 per order had been initiated to the original payment mode, the actual amount credited to the complainant’s bank account was only ₹18. The remaining ₹1 from each transaction was diverted to the user’s "Twid" (Pay with Rewards) account without the consumer’s informed consent. Despite formal grievance requests filed through the application and a subsequent legal notice served in February 2026, the retail entities failed to address the discrepancy or provide a satisfactory resolution, leading the complainant to approach the consumer forum under Section 35 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019.

Addressing the Deceptive Refund Mechanism

During the proceedings, the counsel for the complainant presented evidence, including order records and refund communications, to demonstrate that the retail platform misrepresented the refund process. The Commission observed that while product unavailability is a common operational occurrence in retail, the arbitrary retention of funds within a closed-loop digital ecosystem constitutes a significant departure from fair trade practices. The forum emphasized that monetary transactions require transparency and that consumers maintain the right to receive their funds through the exact channel from which the money was initially debited.

"A consumer cannot be compelled to accept wallet credit in place of a refund to the original mode of payment," the Commission noted, highlighting the distinction between a bank account and a restricted reward wallet. The Bench further remarked on the lack of evidence indicating that the complainant had authorized or even been made aware of any corporate policy that would permit such a transfer. By shifting portions of the refund into a reward system, the retailers effectively created an incentive for the consumer to return to the platform, a move the Commission categorized as a " dark pattern ."

The judgment clarified that the conduct of the retailers, when viewed in the context of the Guidelines for Prevention and Regulation of Dark Patterns, 2023 , points to a deliberate attempt to manipulate consumer autonomy . The forum found that the repeated nature of the refund diversion—occurring in both transactions—suggested that the practice was not an isolated accounting error, but a systematic attempt to retain capital within the service provider's digital infrastructure. "The conduct of the opposite parties, in the absence of any established authorisation for the wallet adjustment, clearly amounts to deficiency in service ," the bench stated, underscoring that such actions undermine the trust required in online retail environments.

Accountability and Punitive Measures

The procedural history of the case reflects a persistent lack of engagement from the opposite parties. Although they entered an appearance through legal counsel, the retail entities failed to file a written statement despite being granted multiple opportunities by the Commission. Consequently, the forum struck off their defense on June 26, 2026. Evaluating the case based on the merits of the unrebutted documentary evidence provided by the complainant, the bench concluded that the retailers were jointly and severally liable for the financial and emotional distress caused to the petitioner.

"Such conduct, cannot be treated as a mere inadvertent accounting error, particularly when it has the effect of retaining the consumer's money within the service provider's digital platform," the order observed. By forcing the consumer to pursue a formal legal complaint over a nominal amount, the retailer exhibited a disregard for the principles of consumer protection. The punitive damages awarded are intended to serve as a deterrent against similar practices that prioritize internal business metrics over the transparency of financial transactions.

The Commission has mandated that the total sum, encompassing both compensation and punitive damages, be paid within 45 days of the order’s communication. Should the retailers fail to comply with this directive, the complainant has been granted the liberty to initiate execution proceedings under Sections 71 and 72 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, which could lead to more stringent legal consequences for the company. This judgment serves as a cautionary precedent for e-commerce platforms regarding the automated handling of refunds and the ethical boundaries of utilizing customer funds within digital reward ecosystems. The case is now consigned to the record room following the announcement of the verdict on October 28, 2026, marking a successful resolution for the complainant who sought to hold the retail giant accountable for its service shortcomings.