The has quashed land acquisition proceedings initiated by the for , marking a decisive victory for tribal residents in the Sundargarh district. A bench comprising Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Satish Chandra Sharma ruled that the acquisition of 273.57 acres of agricultural land, intended to provide for mining, violated critical statutory protections under the . The apex court held that in , the of the is an absolute , and any attempt to bypass or dilute this procedure through restrictive interpretations is legally untenable.
The court’s verdict, delivered on , overturns a previous decision by the that had dismissed the villagers' challenges. The Supreme Court underscored that the acquisition process was legally flawed from its inception, failing to meet both the specific requirements for private company acquisitions and the heightened protections afforded to the regions of the Constitution. By setting aside all notifications and related orders, the court has effectively halted the transfer of land while clarifying that the state must adhere to rigorous procedural standards if it intends to pursue the project again in the future.
Strengthening Constitutional Safeguards for
Central to the dispute was the interpretation of , which mandates the of the concerned for any land acquisition within . The state and the company had argued that this requirement was merely directory, citing other clauses that suggested acquiring land should be a "demonstrable last resort." The Supreme Court flatly rejected this "novel interpretive technique," noting that Section 41(3) exists as a standalone, mandatory safeguard. Justice Satish Chandra Sharma, writing for the court, emphasized: “Once the government finally decides to proceed with land acquisition in such areas, it has already crossed the stages contemplated in sub-sections (1) and (2), and has entered the stage contemplated by sub-section (3). At this juncture, the of sub-section (3) cannot be negated by referring to the of the words used in sub-sections (1) and (2).”
The court observed that the importance of this safeguard was highlighted by the fact that the concerned Gram Sabhas had already passed unanimous resolutions on , formally rejecting the acquisition proposal. The authorities’ decision to proceed despite this explicit rejection was viewed by the bench as a flagrant disregard for the democratic and constitutional role of local village bodies. The court affirmed that if the law dictates a particular manner for a mandatory action, it must be performed in that exact manner or not at all, particularly when the protection of tribal land rights is at stake.
Procedural Irregularities in the Acquisition Process
Beyond the lack of consent, the court identified several critical failures in the acquisition process. Specifically, the government failed to comply with , which requires the of at least 80% of affected families before the government examines a proposal for acquisition by a private company. The state’s claim that this consent could be gathered as a "continuing process" throughout the litigation was dismissed as fundamentally flawed. Such an interpretation, the court noted, would render the legislative intent of prior, informed consent entirely redundant.
Furthermore, the integrity of the
report was severely compromised. The court noted that no public hearing was held on the dates initially scheduled, with the state’s excuse regarding COVID-19 restrictions failing to provide any evidence of an actual consultation process. More concerning was the composition of the expert group responsible for evaluating the SIA. The court found that an advisor linked to Dalmia Cement was included in the expert group, which was supposed to function as an independent, multidisciplinary body. The court observed that this arrangement had the
"effect of rendering the deliberation of the Expert Group as a fixed match,"
as it was impossible for a person with a direct professional and financial link to the project proponent to provide an impartial assessment of the social costs versus the proposed benefits.
Interplay Between Mining Leases and Statutory Acquisition Laws
The legal challenge also forced a clarification on the relationship between the , and the 2013 Land Acquisition Act. The company had argued that its pre-existing gave it an inherent right to operate on the land, and that the 2013 Act should not be allowed to "derogate" from the rights granted under the . The Supreme Court firmly rejected this conflation of commercial contracts with public law obligations.
The court articulated that a is a private contractual arrangement between the state and the lessee, which grants mineral rights and generates royalty but does not override the proprietary and constitutional rights of the landowners. “The 2013 Act provides for acquisition of land for the purpose of mining project, which is something that MMDR Act does not provide for,” the court noted, adding that the two statutes operate in distinct spheres and must be construed harmoniously. By initiating the acquisition under the 2013 Act, the state subjected itself to the rigorous standards of that law, and it cannot retreat into the provisions of the MMDR Act to evade responsibility for failing to follow mandatory acquisition procedures.
With the acquisition notifications now quashed, the villagers of Kukuda, Bihabandha, and Lanjiberna have secured a significant reprieve. The Supreme Court has left the door open for the state to initiate a fresh acquisition process, provided it strictly adheres to the law and the findings regarding consent, transparency, and independent oversight. The judgment serves as a robust reminder that statutory safeguards designed for the protection of marginalized communities are not mere procedural hurdles, but fundamental requirements for any valid state action in the interest of development.
gram sabha consent - scheduled area acquisition