AI Overview...
Explanation of Mutatis Mutandis with Case Laws
Definition and General Use
- Mutatis Mutandis is a Latin phrase meaning with the necessary changes in points of detail or the necessary modifications having been made. It indicates that a particular provision, rule, or law is to be applied to a different context or set of circumstances with appropriate adjustments.
- References: SANNAMALLAPPA S/O M KARIYAPPA VS STATE OF KARNATAKA REP. BY ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING, VIKASA SOUDHA BENGALURU - Karnataka, Indian Tobacco Company Ltd. VS Industrial Court, Mah. Nagpur Bench & another - Bombay
- Insight: The phrase is frequently used in legislation and legal interpretations to extend or adapt provisions to similar situations.
Application in Legislation and Legal Contexts
- The phrase is often employed to apply existing laws or provisions to different statutes or circumstances with necessary modifications.
- Example: In Indian Tobacco Company Ltd. VS Industrial Court, Mah. Nagpur Bench & another - Bombay, it is explained that mutatis mutandis is a rule of adaptation, used when extending legislative provisions to similar subjects or circumstances.
- Case Law: The State of U.P. explained that mutatis mutandis implies applicability of any provision with necessary changes in detail (SANNAMALLAPPA S/O M KARIYAPPA VS STATE OF KARNATAKA REP. BY ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING, VIKASA SOUDHA BENGALURU - Karnataka).
Case Laws Illustrating Mutatis Mutandis
- State of U.P. and State of Orissa:
-
The phrase was explained as applying provisions with necessary modifications (SANNAMALLAPPA S/O M KARIYAPPA VS STATE OF KARNATAKA REP. BY ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING, VIKASA SOUDHA BENGALURU - Karnataka).
-
Land Acquisition and Application of Laws:
-
The Supreme Court clarified that provisions of the Land Acquisition Act 1894 do not automatically apply mutatis mutandis to other statutes like the Tamil Nadu Highways Act 2001, emphasizing that application is subject to legislative intent and context (S. N. Sumathi VS State of Tamil Nadu, Rep by its Principal Secretary - Madras).
-
Application to Transferred Territories:
-
In West Bengal Land Reforms Act cases, the Court held that laws can be applied mutatis mutandis to transferred territories, meaning with necessary adjustments to suit the context (Harendra Nath Singh VS State of West Bengal - Calcutta, DEBI MATA VS STATE OF WEST BENGAL - Calcutta, DEBI MATA VS STATE OF WEST BENGAL - Calcutta).
-
Application in Administrative and Disciplinary Contexts:
-
The phrase was used to extend disciplinary procedures or administrative rules mutatis mutandis, such as in Panchayat cases or employment standing orders, implying adaptation of procedures or rules (Bajrang Lal VS State of Rajasthan - Rajasthan, Indian Tobacco Company Ltd. VS Industrial Court, Mah. Nagpur Bench & another - Bombay).
-
Customs and Re-export Laws:
-
In the context of customs law, mutatis mutandis was used to indicate applying provisions of the Sea Customs Act to re-export scenarios with necessary modifications (Burmah Shell Oil Storage And Distributing Company Of India LTD. : Standard Vacuum Oil Company VS Commercial Tax-officer - Supreme Court).
-
Legislative Delegation and Conditional Legislation:
- The Court clarified that applying laws mutatis mutandis does not constitute delegation of legislative power but rather conditional or adapted legislation, where the legislature's intent is to modify existing laws for new contexts (DEBI MATA VS STATE OF WEST BENGAL - Calcutta).
Summary
- Mutatis mutandis signifies application of a legal provision or rule with necessary modifications to fit different circumstances.
- It is widely used in legislation, judicial decisions, and legal drafting to extend or adapt laws without rewriting entire statutes.
- Case Law Highlights:
- Its use in applying laws to transferred territories (DEBI MATA VS STATE OF WEST BENGAL - Calcutta, DEBI MATA VS STATE OF WEST BENGAL - Calcutta)
- Its role in interpreting the scope of laws across different statutes (S. N. Sumathi VS State of Tamil Nadu, Rep by its Principal Secretary - Madras)
- Its application in administrative, customs, and disciplinary contexts (Bajrang Lal VS State of Rajasthan - Rajasthan, Burmah Shell Oil Storage And Distributing Company Of India LTD. : Standard Vacuum Oil Company VS Commercial Tax-officer - Supreme Court)
Conclusion
Mutatis mutandis is a vital legal concept ensuring flexibility and adaptability of laws and provisions across varied contexts, provided that necessary modifications are made to suit the specific circumstances, as demonstrated through various case laws and judicial interpretations.
Search Results for "Detail Explanation on Mutatis Mutandis with Case Laws"
2021 0 Supreme(Kar) 348 • India - Karnataka
B.V.NAGARATHNA, P.KRISHNA BHAT
State of U.P., the phrase “mutatis mutandis” has been explained as under: “11. The expression ‘mutatis mutandis’ itself implies applicability of any provision with necessary changes in points of detail.” 25. ... State of Orissa this Court held as under : (SCC p. 93, para 17) “17. … Earl Jowitt's The Dictionary of English Law (1959) defines ‘mutatis mutandis’ as ‘with the necessary changes in points of detail’. ... Black's Law Dictionary (Revised 4th....
1982 0 Supreme(Raj) 105 • India - Rajasthan
N.M.KASLIWAL, K.S.SIDHU
Similar observations would govern mutatis mutandis, the issue of unripeness. ... Similar observations would govern mutatis mutandis, the issue of unripeness. ... Another exception to this rule is contained in the explanation appended to it. ... The proviso and the explanation thus make it clear that the rule regarding minimum qualifications as laid down in clause (a) and (b) is not an absolute rule. It is subject to exceptions given in the proviso and the explanations....
2015 0 Supreme(Mad) 1538 • India - Madras
M.DURAISWAMY
The Act cannot be read and interpreted to mean that the provisions of Land Acquisition Act 1894 apply "mutatis mutandis" to the Tamil ... mutandis" to the Tamil Nadu Highways Act 2001 - As such, the mandate prescribed under Section 11A of the Land Acquisition Act 1894 ... legislating a new Highways Act - The Act cannot be read and interpreted to mean that the provisions of Land Acquisition Act 1894 apply "mutatis ... The Act cannot be read and interpreted to mean that the provisions of Land Acquisition Act 1894 apply " #....
1981 0 Supreme(Raj) 56 • India - Rajasthan
M.L.SHRIMAL, MAHENDRA BHUSHAN
The suspension of a Sarpanch under particular circumstances of a case may be considered necessary or desirable to save the Panchayat ... Government, after considering the merits of the case, is required to decide whether a charge sheet is to be served on the holder ... After a preliminary report has been submitted and a prima facie case is made out against the delinquent elected officer, the State ... ... (5) The provisions of the Rajasthan Disciplinary proceedings(Summon-ing of Witnesses and Production of Documents) Act, 1959 (Rajasthan....
1997 0 Supreme(Cal) 263 • India - Calcutta
BHAGABATI PROSAD BANERJEE, VIDYA NAND
Fact of the Case: The case involved the applicability of the West Bengal Land Reforms Act to the transferred territories ... WEST BENGAL LAND REFORMS ACT - APPLICABILITY TO TRANSFERRED TERRITORIES - WEST BENGAL TRANSFERRED TERRITORIES (ASSIMILATION OF LAWS ... Whether the West Bengal Transferred Territories (Assimilation of Laws) Act, 1958, empowered the State Government to make the West ... The Bihar Land Reforms Act, 1950 shall stand repealed and the provisions, of the West Bengal Estate Acquisition Act shall apply #....
1989 0 Supreme(Bom) 312 • India - Bombay
H.D.PATEL
Employment (Standing Order) Act are engrafted into the Bombay Shops and Establishments Act with only necessary changes in points of detail ... It is well settled that the phrase "mutatis mutandis" is often used in legislation in applying or extending legislative provisions to same or similar circumstances or to same or similar subjects. It is nothing but a rule of adaptation. ... At first blush there may appear to be some substance in the contention that the above passage governs the problem that has arisen in this case....
1960 0 Supreme(SC) 233 • India - Supreme Court
J.C.SHAH, K.C.DAS GUPTA, M.HIDAYATULLAH, N.RAJAGOPALA AYYANGAR, S.R.DASS, S.K.DAS
Section 42 of the Sea Customs Act, which allows drawback on re-export and is applicable mutatis mutandis, provides : ... "When any goods, capable of being easily identified which have been imported by sea into any customs-port from any foreign port, and upon which duties of customs ... A notification issued under the Indian Aircraft Act, the rules framed thereunder and the Indian Aircraft Rules, 1920 appointed the Civil Aerodrome, Dum Dum, a Customs Aerodrome, and to that Customs Aerodrome, the provisions of the Sea Customs Act mutatis #H....
1972 0 Supreme(Cal) 115 • India - Calcutta
P.B.MUKHARJI, B.C.MITRA
I hold that this was not a case of delegation and I say that it was, at best, a case of conditional legislation. ... The Court held that the legislature has applied its mind and has laid down the law in this case. ... OF WEST BENGAL - TRANSFER OF TERRITORIES ACT, 1956 - Section 3, 43 and 44 - WEST BENGAL TRANSFERRED TERRITORIES (ASSIMILATION OF LAWS ... The expression 'mutatis mutandis' is an expression taken from Latin language and has the well known implication which means with due a....
1972 0 Supreme(Cal) 114 • India - Calcutta
B.C.MISRA, P.B.MUKHARJI
Fact of the Case: The petitioners, representing the family deity of Panchkote Raj Estate, challenged the notifications ... OF WEST BENGAL - TRANSFER OF TERRITORIES ACT, 1956 - SECTION 3, 43 AND 44 - WEST BENGAL TRANSFERRED TERRITORIES (ASSIMILATION OF LAWS ... various Acts and Sections, including the Transfer of Territories Act, 1956, the West Bengal Transferred Territories (Assimilation of Laws ... Dutt's argument seems to have been that by leaving with the executive the right to apply the provisions mutatis #HL_START....
1981 0 Supreme(Cal) 345 • India - Calcutta
SABYASACHI MUKHARJEE, C.K.BANERJEE
mutandis to a license granted under Section 6A. 2. ... provided for in Section 6A, but which were provided elsewhere in the Rice-Milling Act or in the rules framed thereunder, would apply mutatis ... Fact of the Case: The appellant, the owner of a husking mill, was operating the same without a license. ... In view of Sub-section (6) of Section 6a, sub-section (4) of Section 6 will apply mutatis mutandis. Thus we find that Section 6a is not repugnant to or inconsistent with Section 6. ... mut....
Filter by Legal Phrase
