AI Overview...
-
Grounds of Objection Must Be Stated - It is essential for persons objecting to land acquisition to clearly specify their grounds of objection when submitting applications or notices, as courts require these grounds to assess the validity of objections effectively. Failure to state specific grounds can lead to rejection or deeming the objection invalid Om Gir VS The State of U. P. - Allahabad, Ranjit Kumar VS State of Bihar - Patna.
-
Necessity of Clear Grounds in Legal Proceedings - When challenging awards or notifications, claimants must articulate specific reasons for their objections. The courts have held that general or vague objections are insufficient; detailed grounds are necessary for proper adjudication Peace Memorial Association, Anantapur VS Collector, Anantapur - Andhra Pradesh, Gopinath Alias Muthukumaraswamy Thiagarajan VS District Collector, Madurai District, Madurai - Madras.
-
Procedure for Filing Objections - Objections under Sections 5A and 18 of the Land Acquisition Act must be filed within prescribed timeframes and should explicitly state the grounds. The absence of such grounds can invalidate the objection or limit its consideration Delhi Administration VS Gurdip Singh Uban - Supreme Court, R. Devendran and others VS State of Tamil Nadu and others - Madras, Ranjit Kumar VS State of Bihar - Patna.
-
Role of Technical and Merit-Based Considerations - Objections based on technical or merit-based issues, such as necessity or public purpose, are considered on their substantive merits rather than procedural grounds. However, objections unrelated to the landholder's rights or specific grounds lack standing R. Natarajan VS The Union of India - Madras.
-
Limitations on Who Can Object - Only persons with legal interest or rights in the land can validly object or question the acquisition process. Those without interest or rights have no locus standi to challenge the proceedings Brij Mohan VS The State of U. P. - Allahabad.
Analysis and Conclusion:
The grounds of objection in land acquisition proceedings must be explicitly stated by the objectors at the time of filing, within the stipulated deadlines. Courts emphasize the importance of specifying clear, substantive reasons to enable proper judicial assessment. Objections lacking specific grounds or filed by persons without interest are generally considered invalid. Properly articulated grounds facilitate fair consideration of objections, ensuring transparency and adherence to legal requirements in land acquisition processes.
Search Results for "Grounds of Objection Must be Stated Land Acquisition"
1977 0 Supreme(Cal) 90 • India - Calcutta
PRADYOT KUMAR BANERJEE, RAMKRISHNA SHARMA
LAND ACQUISITION - COMPENSATION - 15% SOLATIUM - AWARD OF 15% COMPENSATION IS A MUST FOR THE COURT IN EVERY CASES IN CONSIDERATION ... The Land Acquisition Judge raised it to Rs. 300/- per cottah. ... The Land Acquisition Collector assessed the valuation of the land in question at the rate of Rs. 142/- per cottah. ... The King) and that the Land Acquisition Collector must give the basis on when th....
1971 0 Supreme(All) 41 • India - Allahabad
SATISHCHANDRA
WHO HAS NOT ACCEPTED THE AWARD, AND MUST STATE GROUNDS OF OBJECTION. ... any particular grounds of objection to the award. ... any particular grounds of objection to the award. ... The third condition is that the application should state the grounds of objection to the award. The application made by the petitioners did not state any particular grounds of #HL_STA....
2009 0 Supreme(P&H) 472 • India - Punjab and Haryana
UMA NATH SINGH, DAYA CHAUDHARY
(A) Land and Property Law--Acquisition of Land--Public purpose--Urgency provision--Explanations given for showing urgency do not ... (Paras 19 & 20) ... (B) Land and Property Law--Acquisition of Land--Public ... --Reason housing Gurudwara was inadvertently included in earlier notification--However in reply filed by State this is reiterated ... ... On 23.4.2008,the SDM, Bathinda, submitted his report (annexure P4) to the Deputy Commissioner, mentioning that the petiti....
1991 0 Supreme(Mad) 792 • India - Madras
S.GOVINDASWAMY
Section 4(1) - Notification due to long delay between date of issuance of Government order according administrative sanction for acquisition ... or the person interested the land under acquisition is a valuable statutory right to raise effective objection for proposed acquisition. ... From the ratio deducible from the above authorities, it is clear that before invocation the urgency provision for initiation of acquisition proceedings, there must be an urgency proceed ....
1999 7 Supreme 303 • India - Supreme Court
SUJATA V.MANOHAR, J.JAGANNADHA RAO
4(1) notification by filing objection under Section 5A, the said notification must be treated as being in force. ... under Section 5A, in priciple, it must be accepted that they had no objection to Section 4 notification operating in respect of ... Section 5A inquiry was vitiated-Respondents in question did not file objection u/s 5A-Respondents plea that notification in respect ... In connection with owners or persons interested who have not filed objections under Section 5A, in pricip....
1963 0 Supreme(AP) 186 • India - Andhra Pradesh
GOPALRAO EKBOLE
Ratio Decidendi: The Court held that the petitioner's request, made by an endorsement on the receipt, clearly stated the ground ... of objection to the award and filed within the limitation period. ... The Court emphasized that the application need not provide detailed grounds and that the Collector's duty is to determine whether ... be to the measurement of the land, the amount of compensation, the persons to whom it is payable, or the apportionment of the compensation amongst the persons interested. ....
2010 0 Supreme(Mad) 4856 • India - Madras
M.Y.EQBAL, T.S.SIVAGNANAM
to the respondent-Respondent rejected the objection by saying that technical experts stated that the land was necessary and the ... objection raised by the land owners in the land acquisition proceedings not on the inherent merit of such objection but on any other ... by the land owners are to be considered on the merit of such objections and not on any other grounds-The order of rejection of the ....
2018 0 Supreme(Mad) 4447 • India - Madras
S.S.SUNDAR, C.SARAVANAN
if any for proposed acquisition - It is stated that objections which are received within time and same would be enquired - This ... notice was served on appellant - As stated in notice enquiry was conducted - Appellant submitted his written objection through his ... and that therefore no ground is made out for quashing Land Acquisition proceeding - Aggrieved by order of Single Judge of this Court ... By notice dated 22.08.2005, the 2nd respondent her....
2019 0 Supreme(Pat) 2028 • India - Patna
CHAKRADHARI SHARAN SINGH
Act, 2013, shall state grounds, on which objection to award is taken, within period prescribed – Proviso to sub-Section (2) of Section ... case where land acquisition proceedings had commenced under provisions of L.A. ... Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 ... Act, 2013, shall state grounds, on which objection to the award is taken, within the ....
1976 0 Supreme(All) 27 • India - Allahabad
T.S.MISRA
LAND ACQUISITION - PUBLIC PURPOSE - ALIGNMENT OF FEEDER CHANNEL - CHANGE OF ALIGNMENT - MALA FIDES - OBJECTIONS UNDER SECTION ... A person having no right or interest in the land acquired has no locus standi to file an objection and question the validity of the ... The court held that a person having no right or interest in the land acquired has no locus standi to file an objection and question ... Thus a person having no right and interest in the land#HL_EN....
Filter by Legal Phrase
