The Supreme Court of India is currently examining a significant procedural challenge regarding a dispute over the lighting of the Karthigai Deepam ritual on Thiruparankundram hill in Madurai. A bench comprising Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul Pancholi convened on Wednesday to hear appeals stemming from a ruling by the Madras High Court, which had initially permitted the lighting of a ceremonial lamp at a stone pillar located in close proximity to the historic Sikandar Badusha Dargah.

The litigation centers on allegations of procedural impropriety, with the Dargah Committee contending that a single judge of the Madras High Court conducted a private site inspection without providing adequate notice to the committee. Senior Advocate Huzefa Ahmadi, representing the Dargah Committee, argued before the apex court that the manner in which the inspection was executed effectively sidelined the affected party before a judicial determination was reached.

According to the timeline presented to the Supreme Court, Justice GR Swaminathan of the Madras High Court conducted an inspection of the site on November 19, 2025. Crucially, the committee highlighted that this date coincided with their initial impleadment in the writ proceedings. The committee alleged that they were not properly notified of this visit, thereby losing the opportunity to assist the court in identifying the specific location or provide relevant evidence regarding the nature of the land and the stone structure in question.

"In my respectful submission, My Lords, ordinarily a writ court , a constitutional court , does not, My Lords, conduct private inspection," Ahmadi submitted to the bench. He argued that while civil courts occasionally conduct inspections to establish facts about contested properties, such an action by a High Court judge in the context of a writ petition, without the presence or prior notification of the interested party, represents an extraordinary departure from standard judicial practice.

The committee’s contention is that if they had been present during the inspection, they could have presented critical evidence, including references to a 1923 civil court decree that was subsequently affirmed by the Privy Council. The committee argues that this decree recognized the rights of Muslim parties over the entire hillock where the Dargah stands, including specific areas adjacent to the mosque and Nallitope. By the time the committee filed its counter-affidavit on November 28, 2025, the matter had already been reserved for judgment, leaving the committee with little room to challenge the court’s findings on the ground.

State Intervention and the Nature of the Disputed Pillar

The proceedings also involved the Madurai District Collector, represented by Senior Advocate Gopal Sankaranarayanan. The state government introduced a new dimension to the dispute by presenting records from the Great Trigonometrical Survey. The state argued that the stone pillar—the focus of the religious contention—is, according to its records, a survey marker intended for triangulation and geographic measurement rather than a religious structure.

The state expressed concerns regarding the broader implications of allowing religious claims to be asserted over such markers. Counsel warned that if the Madras High Court ’s original directive remains undisturbed, it could inadvertently encourage similar religious claims over other survey landmarks across the region. "Our fear as the State is that if this were to start happening—that this judgment remains undisturbed—then all these pillars will suddenly get a religious colour," Sankaranarayanan submitted.

However, the Supreme Court bench appeared skeptical of the state’s sudden introduction of this evidence, particularly given the historical context of the land ownership. While the state maintained that the pillar was utilized for checking compasses and establishing meridians, the justices questioned the relevance of these arguments in light of existing civil decrees. The court noted that the land in question is widely accepted as belonging to the local Hindu temple, except for specific portions previously delineated as belonging to the Muslim parties. When pressed on whether the state was asserting its own ownership over the disputed land, the government counsel indicated that the state was not claiming title to the land, which further complicated the bench's view of the state's arguments.

The Scope of Judicial Review

During the hearing, the Supreme Court took pains to clarify the scope of its current intervention. The bench noted that it is currently focused on the validity of the interim relief granted by the High Court rather than issuing a final adjudication on the ownership of the site or the legitimacy of the religious practices involved. The court aims to determine whether the procedural steps taken during the original writ proceedings sufficiently upheld the principles of natural justice, given the contentious nature of the location and the historical claims involved.

The dispute over the Karthigai Deepam ritual has remained a flashpoint in the area since the Thiruparankundram Subramaniya Swamy Temple administration initially rejected a request to light a lamp at the stone pillar near the Dargah. The subsequent legal journey, which saw a single judge authorize the ritual and a division bench uphold the decision in January 2026, has now reached a point of critical review by the apex court.

As the matter proceeds, the court is expected to deliberate on the adequacy of the notice provided to the Dargah Committee and the weight that should be placed on historical civil decrees versus the state’s current survey records. The Supreme Court has scheduled the next hearing for November 19 at 2:00 PM, at which point further arguments are expected to be presented regarding the interim arrangements for the disputed site. The outcome of these deliberations will likely set a significant precedent for how constitutional courts handle site inspections and claims involving overlapping historical and religious rights in disputed public spaces. The current procedural position rests on the Supreme Court's evaluation of whether the High Court’s initial order met the requirements of fairness required for such a high-stakes local dispute.