IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
G.A. Sanap, J.
Gajanan - Appellant
Versus
Deepashree - Respondent
Criminal Revision Application No. 91 of 2018
Decided On : 12-04-2023
MAINTENANCE - CRIMINAL PROCEDURE - Sec. 125, Sec. 127 of Cr.P.C., Family Courts Act, 1984 - The court discussed the provisions of Sec. 125 and Sec. 127 of the Cr.P.C. regarding maintenance, emphasizing the need for enhancement due to changed circumstances such as inflation and increased income of the non-applicant. The court interpreted these sections to affirm the right of the applicants to seek increased maintenance based on their needs and the non-applicant's financial capacity, ultimately supporting the Family Court's decision to enhance maintenance amounts.
Fact of the Case:
The applicant, a wife, and her son sought enhancement of maintenance from the non-applicant husband, who was a professor with a significant income. They argued that the previously awarded maintenance was insufficient due to inflation and increased living costs, while the non-applicant contended that the applicants had sources of income and that his financial obligations to other dependents limited his ability to pay more.
Finding of the Court:
The court found that there had been a change in circumstances justifying the enhancement of maintenance. It noted the significant increase in the non-applicant's salary and the rising cost of living, which warranted a reassessment of the maintenance amounts awarded in 2011.
Issues: Whether there was a change in circumstances that justified the enhancement of maintenance under Sec. 127 of the Cr.P.C. and whether the Family Court's decision to increase the maintenance amounts was justified.
Ratio Decidendi: The court held that the applicants were entitled to seek enhancement of maintenance due to changed circumstances, including inflation and the non-applicant's increased income. It emphasized that the right to maintenance is not static and can be adjusted based on the financial realities of the parties involved.
Final Decision: The court dismissed the revision application, upholding the Family Court's order to enhance maintenance to Rs. 10,000 for the wife and Rs. 12,000 for the son, affirming that the amounts were reasonable given the non-applicant's financial capacity.
JUDGMENT/ORDER
1. Heard.
2. Admit. The application is heard finally with the consent of the learned advocates for the parties at the admission stage.
3. In this criminal revision application, challenge is to the judgment and order dtd. 23/5/2016 passed by the learned Judge of the Family Court, Akola, whereby the learned Judge has partly allowed the application for enhancement of the maintenance made under Sec. 127 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for short "Cr.PC) by the non-applicants.
4. The facts relevant for deciding this revision application are as follows:
The parties would be referred in this judgment by their nomenclature in the application made under Sec. 127 of the Cr.PC before the Family Court. The applicant in this revision is the non-applicant. The non-applicants in this revision are the applicant Nos.1 and 2. The applicant No.1 and the non-applicant got married on 19/5/1997. Applicant No.2 is the son of the applicant No.1 and the non-applicant. At the time of the marriage, the applicant No.1 has passed 12th Standard Examination. The non-applicant is serving as a Professor at Rani Indirabai Bhosale Mahavidyalaya, Kuhi. As per the case of the applicant No.1, after marriage, the non-applicant made a demand of Rs.1, 00, 000.00 from her father. Her father partly satisfied his demand. It is stated that the non-applicant and his other family members started ill-treating the applicant No.1. On 25/5/2008, the non-applicant drove out the applicant No.1 together with the applicant No.2 from his house. The applicant No.1, with the applicant No.2, started residing with her father.
5. The non-applicant did not make any provision for the maintenance of the applicant Nos.1 and 2. They, therefore, filed an application under Sec. 125 of the Cr.PC in the Court of Judicial Magistrate First Class, Akola. After establishment of the Family Court at Akola, the said application was transferred to the Family Court. The matter was settled before the Marriage Counsellor of the Family Court, Akola on 13/6/2011. In terms of the settlement, the non-applicant agreed to pay a sum of Rs.4, 000.00 each to the applicant Nos.1 and 2 from 13/6/2011. The applicants in the year 2015 filed an application under Sec. 127 of the Cr.PC and prayed for the enhancement in the maintenance. According to the applicants, the monthly maintenance awarded in the year 2011 is not sufficient to satisfy their bare minimum needs. There has been considerable rise in the inflation. It is their case that since the cost of living has skyrocketed on account of the inflation, the said amount of maintenance was not sufficient to satisfy their day-to-day requirements. The applicant No.2 has been taking education. The applicant No.1 is required to spend huge amount for the education of the applicant No.2. It is stated that they have no source of income. They are unable to maintain themselves. The non-applicant is Professor. His monthly salary is Rs.75, 000.00 to Rs.80, 000.00. He owns with other family members near about 30 acres of agricultural land. The annual income from the agricultural land is near about Rs.10, 00, 000.00. The applicants, therefore, prayed for the enhanced maintenance at the rate of Rs.20, 000.00 per month each.
6. The non-applicant filed the reply and opposed the application. According to the non-applicant, the applicant No.1 is doing service. She has source of income. She has done beauty parlour course. The parents of the applicant No.1 are financially sound. The applicant No.1 is taking beauty parlour classes. She is getting near about Rs.10, 000.00 per month from the said business. She is doing tailoring work. From the said work, she is also getting income.
7. According to the non-applicant, he has been spending money for the education of his son. His son has passed 10th Standard with 86% marks. He has been regularly paying visit to his son and making provision for his education. It is contended that there is no change in the circumstances. He has not d
AI
The court established that maintenance under Sec. 125 and Sec. 127 of the Cr.P.C. can be enhanced based on changes in circumstances, including inflation and increased income of the non-applicant, rei....
The court upheld the Family Court's decision to enhance maintenance, emphasizing the need for financial support to ensure a dignified standard of living for dependents.
Maintenance under Section 125 Cr.P.C. is a social justice measure to ensure a deserted wife and children receive adequate financial support, reflecting their standard of living during marriage.
The main legal point established in the judgment is that the quantum of maintenance must be determined based on the financial status of the parties, the reasonable needs of the dependant spouse and c....
Maintenance awarded under Section 125 should ensure the dependent spouse's comfort, considering the standard of living and financial capacity of the spouse obliged to pay.
A husband’s legal obligation to maintain his wife and children must be fulfilled despite claims of financial hardship, unless convincingly demonstrated otherwise.
The main legal point established in the judgment is the husband's legal and moral duty to maintain his wife according to his means and capacity, as well as the entitlement of the wife to maintenance ....
The responsibility to maintain adult daughters until their marriage and the just and reasonable nature of the enhanced maintenance were the central legal principles established in the judgment.
A wife can seek enhancement of maintenance under Section 25(2) of the Hindu Marriage Act based on changed circumstances, despite prior agreements.
The word “maintenance " which should not be narrowly interpreted, means the most reasonable requirement for the existence of a person to live separate, and accordingly the expenditure, broadly speaki....
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.