1987 Supreme(Del) 157
High Court Of Delhi
RAJ KUMARI SHARMA - Appellant
Versus
RAJINDER NATH DEWAN - Respondent
REGULAR FIRST APPEAL 15 of 1984
Decided On : 03/25/1987
Subject
Wills - CONSTRUCTION OF WILLS
Act Referred
Headnote
Held
that the bequest under the Will in favor of B was to the extent of use, enjoyment and interest during her lifetime with a declaration that after her death the property would go to the legal heirs of the testator. She did not have any right to transfer the property in any manner whatsoever. It was not the typical form of estate inherited by a woman from her husband compendiously known as the widows estate.
that she had inherited the "widows estate" with respect to the other properties and if it was intended by the testator to give her only "womens estate" or "widows estate" then the bequest need not have been made under a Will. The intention must be attributed to the testator that he bequeathed her somewhat different estate than she was entitled as an heiress. The conferment of the power to appropriate the profits and absolute prohibition to transfer the property in any manner whatsoever under the Will, are inconsistent with notions of "widows estate" under Hindu Law. A Hindu "widows estate" was not given to B under the Will, and what was given was only a "life estate". — Lakshmana Nadar and Ors. v. R. Ramier, 1953 SCR 848 relied on.
AJAY KAUL, ARUN MOHAN, M.C.BHANDARE, M.K.CHAWLA, MANJU SRIVASTAV
( 1 ) THE dec ision of these appeals turns upon the construction of the Will as to the nature of the estate granted by the testator to his widow, whether it was a "woman s estate" or "widow s estate" under Hindu Law or merely a limited "life estaie and to the scope and effect of Section 111 of the Indian Scession Act, 1925 as to the vesting of the estate in the class of persons described as legal heirs of the testator.
( 2 ) THE plaintiff who is the appellant herein and defendants 6, 7 and 8 are the daughters of Shri Ram Nath Dewan and defendant No. 1 was his son (now represented by his legal heirs ). Smt. Satyawati was the wife of Shri Ram Nath Dewan and the mother of plaintiff, defendants 1, 6, 7 and 8. Shri Ram Nath Dewan acquired perpetual lease hold rights in respect of plot No. 5, Doctor s Lane, New Delhi. He constructed a building on the said plot of land known as No. 5, Doctor s Lane, New Delhi. Shri Ram Nath Dewan executed a registered Will and testament on April 10, 1942. According to the Will Shri Ram Nath Dewan, the testator, bequeathes the user, enjoyment and interest of his house on part plot No. 5 in Block No. 88, Doctor s Lane, New Delhi worth Rs. 50,000 to his wife, Smt. Satyawati, the demisee during her life after his (testator) death and declares that after her (demisee) death the property will go to the legal heirs of the testator. It is directed that the said demisee will continue to live in the said house according to her sweet Will and shall also have a right to give the said property on rent to any tenant and that the said demisee shall have no right to transfer the property in any way whatsoever. The demisee is also given the right without interference of the legal heirs to appropriate and spend the rents and profits thereof and to make additions, alterations in the building accommodation in accordance with her sweet will and desire and she is made the whole and sole manager and beneficiary of the said property during her lifetime. She is made liable to pay the lease money and to effect repairs.
( 3 ) SHRI Ram Nath Dewan is alleged in the plaint of the suit to have owned and possessed property bearing No. 56, Todar Mal Lane, New Delhi and lands measuring 400 square yards comprised in two plots situate in Vishwas Nagar Colony in Shahdara. According to the plaintiff, Smt. Satyawati owned and possessed property No. 58, Todar Mal Lane, New Delhi as her absolute property, that Ram Nath Dewan died on April 3, 1953 and that on his death Smt. Satyawati acquired life estate/life interest in property No. 5, Doctor s Lane, New Delhi under the Will and in other properties left by him under Hindu Law. Smt. Satyawati died on July 2, 1972. According to the claim made by the plaintiff in the suit, the legal heirs of the testator Shri Ram Nath Dewan acquired the property bearing No. 5, Doctor s Lane, New Delhi as absolute owners on the death of Smt. Satyawati in equal shares. They also, onthe death of their mother, acquired property Nos. 56 and 58, Todar Mal Lane, New Delhi, lands situated at Shahdara and other movable properties as mentioned in the schedule to the plaint. Reference is then made to the power of attorney alleged to have been executed by defendant No. 1 in favour of Shri G. C. Sharma, defendant No. 2 who is alleged to have executed the sale deed dated March 4, 1971 in respect of property No. 5, Doctor s Lane, New Delhi in favour of defendants 3 to 5. This sale deed dated March 4, 1971 is alleged to be wholly fictitious, illegal and without consideration and not binding on the plaintiff and other defendants.
( 4 ) THE plaintiff prayed that it be declared that the sale deed d. ated March 4, 1971 alleged to have been executed by Shri G. C. Sharma, defendant No. 2 purporting to have acted as an Attorney of defendant No. 1 in respect of property No. 5, Doctor s Lane, New Delhi in favour of defendants 3 to 5 wholly false, fraudulent, fictitious, collusive, sham, unauthorised, without consider