2022 Supreme(P&H) 1893
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH
Avneesh Jhingan, J.
State Of Punjab – Appellant
Versus
Mohan Singh – Respondent
CRA-S-1350-SBA-2005
Decided On : 30-11-2022
Important Points
Subject
Criminal Law - Corruption
Act Referred
PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION ACT : S.13(1)(a), S.13(2), S.7
Headnote
Acquittal - Prevention of Corruption Act - Sections 7, 13(1)(a), 13(2) - The court discussed the evidence and concluded that the prosecution failed to prove the case. The trial court's decision of acquitting the respondent was upheld based on the lack of compelling and substantial reasons for interference.
Fact of the Case:
The respondent, a Medical Officer, was accused of demanding and accepting bribes for medical treatments. The prosecution failed to prove the case, and the trial court acquitted the respondent.
Finding of the Court:
The court found that the prosecution failed to prove the case, and the trial court's decision of acquittal was upheld due to the lack of compelling reasons for interference.
Issues: The main issue was whether the prosecution had proven the case against the respondent beyond a reasonable doubt.
Ratio Decidendi: The court upheld the trial court's decision of acquittal, emphasizing that interference in an appeal against acquittal is warranted only if there are compelling and substantial reasons for doing so.
Final Decision: The appeal by the State of Punjab was dismissed, and the acquittal of the respondent was upheld.
Mr. Arun Luthra, DAG, Punjab, for the Appellant; Mr. J. S. Thind, Advocate, for the Respondent.
JUDGMENT
Avneesh Jhingan, J. (Oral) - State of Punjab is in appeal against the acquittal of Mohan Singh (respondent) in FIR No. 112 dated 3.12.1997, under Sections 7, 13(1)(a) read with Section 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (for short, 'the Act') registered at Police Station, Vigilance Bureau, Jalandhar.
2. The facts as put up by the prosecution are that the respondent posted as Medical Officer at Government Hospital, Sirhali Kalan, District Amritsar in the year 1993-94 demanded and accepted bribe of Rs.8200/-from Sham Lal for his treatment; Rs.5000/- from Jagtar Singh for treatment of his wife-Manjit Kaur and Rs.1100/- from Swaran Singh for the treatment of his father-Jarnail Singh. FIR was registered, after receipt of sanction to prosecute, charges were framed.
3. The prosecution to support its case examined sixteen witnesses.
4. In statement under Section 313 Cr.P.C., the respondent denied the allegations and stated that it to be a case of false implication, as he had made reports against Gurmej Kaur Staff Nurse and Inderjit Singh, Pharmacist who were indulging in private practice as medical practitioners. He further stated that in departmental enquiry held on similar allegations, he was exonerated.
5. In defence, the appellant examined eight witnesses.
6. The trial court after considering the facts, appreciating the evidence concluded that the prosecution failed to prove the case and acquitted the respondent vide judgment dated 3.3.2005.
7. Learned counsel for the State submits that the trial court erred in acquitting the respondent. Prosecution witness PW1- Sham Lal had supported the case of prosecution and that testimony of PW13-Swarn Singh proved payment of Rs.1100/- to the respondent for treatment of his father.
8. Learned counsel for the respondent defends the impugned judgment. He submits that there are major variations in the depositions of the prosecution witnesses.
9. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
10. The trial court had threadbare considered the evidence adduced. Sham Lal who had allegedly paid Rs.8200/- to the respondent for his treatment stated that he had borrowed Rs.1200/- from Harjit Singh (PW7) and Rs.500/- from Santosh (PW8). Further that Rs.5000/- was returned to him by respondent in the presence of a congress worker who had mediated. His deposition was not found reliable as the person who had mediated was neither named nor he was examined. Sham Lal had testified that the amount was paid in the presence of PW3-Sharanjit Kaur, whereas Sharanjit Kaur had not deposed that she was present at the spot when the bribe was paid. PW7-Harjit Singh in his cross-examination admitted that no money was demanded by respondent from Sham Lal. Similarly, PW8-Santosh from whom Rs.500/- was borrowed by Sham Lal had not stated that she was present at the time of demand and acceptance of illegal gratification.
11. Another aspect was considered by the trial court that Sham Lal had sworn an affidavit Ex. DA to the effect that no illegal gratification was paid by him to the respondent. Sham Lal admitted his signatures on the affidavit. Attestation of the affidavit was proved by examining DW5-Sakattar Singh, Reader in the court of Naib Tehsildar, Patti.
12. Adverting to the payment made by Jagtar Singh for treatment of his wife Manjit Kaur. Jagtar Singh died during interregnum and Manjit Kaur was not examined. PW5-Harbans Singh, Brother-in-law of Manjit Kaur deposed and in cross-examination he admitted that in his presence there was no demand or acceptance of bribe by the appellant from Jagtar Singh. PW10-Joginder Kaur stated that Jagtar Singh had paid the amount to the respondent in her presence. Her statement was at variance with the deposition of her husband-Harbans Singh and she had stated that her husband never visited the hospital during the period when Manjit Kaur remained admitted. On the other hand, Harbans Singh stated that he along with his wife Manjit Kaur and brother Jagtar Singh