2023 Supreme(MP) 57
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
Vivek Rusia, J.
The State of M.P. v. Dr. Anil Sinha
Criminal Appeal No. 771 of 1999 (I); Decided on 15.3.2023
Subject
Corruption - Bribery
Act Referred
PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION ACT : S.7, S.13(1)(d), S.13(2), S.20
Headnote
(1) Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 -- Ss. 7, 13(1) (d), 13(2) and 20 -- allegation of demanding illegal gratification of Rs. 3,000/- for surgery in government hospital -- caught red-handed by trap team -- acceptance of money established -- but, mere recovery of money not enough to draw presumption of bribe -- prosecution failed to prove aforesaid money demanded as bribe -- conduct of prosecution also doubtful -- acquittal justified -- no interference called for. (2016) 12 SCC 150 followed. [Paras 11 & 14]
(2) Practice (Criminal) -- appeal against acquittal -- interference not justified merely because appellate Court inclined to take different view on reappreciation of evidence. (2016) 12 SCC 150 followed. [Para 15]
¼1½ Òz"Vkpkj fuokj.k vfèkfu;e] 1988 & èkkjk 7] 13¼1½ ¼Ä½] 13¼2½ rFkk 20 & ljdkjh vLirky esa 'kY; fpfdRlk ds fy, #i;s 3]000@& d¢ voSèk ifjr¨"k.k dh ekax djus dk vfÒdFku & ik'k ny }kjk jaxs gkFkksa idM+k x;k & èku xzg.k djuk LFkkfir & ijarq dsoy èku dh cjkenxh fj'or dh mièkkj.kk djus ds fy, i;kZIr ugha & vfÒ;¨tui{k lkfcr djus esa vlQy fd iwo¨ZDr èku fj'or d¢ :i esa ekaxk x;k & vfÒ;¨tui{k dk vkpj.k Òh lansgkLin & n¨"keqfDr U;k;laxr & gLr{ksi vko';d ughaA ¼2016½ 12 ,l lh lh 150 vuqlfjrA ¼iSjk 11 ,oa 14½
¼2½ çFkk & n¨"keqfDr & lk{; d¢ iquewZY;kadu ij vihy U;k;ky; d¢ fÒUu n`f"Vd¨.k viukus d¨ rS;kj g¨us ek= d¢ vkèkkj ij gLr{ksi U;k;laxr ughaA ¼2016½ 12 ,l lhlh 150 vuqlfjrA ¼iSjk 15½
Vaibhav Jain for appellant; Dinesh Kumar Tiwari for respondent.
JUDGMENT
1. The State of Madhya Pradesh through Special Police Establishment (Lok Ayukta), Ujjain has filed this appeal under section 378 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter referred to as the Code) against the judgment of acquittal dated 1.2.1999 passed by the learned First Additional Sessions &Special Judge (under Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988) Ujjain, District Ujjain (MP) in Special Sessions Trial No.04/1998, whereby the respondent herein has been acquitted from charges of corruption punishable under section 7 and section 13 (1) (d) read with section 13 (2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (hereinafter referred to as the Act).
2. As per the prosecution story from 6.8.1997 to 11.8.1997, the respondent was posted as an Assistant Surgeon & Medical Officer, Orthopedics Department in District Hospital, Ujjain, District Ujjain (MP). On 6.8.1997, Gopal S/o Babulal (PW-1) suffered a fracture in the bone of his left hand in the Indore city. After sustaining the facture, Gopal went to Ujjain to meet his brother Krishnakant (PW-8). Thereafter, he (Krishnakant) was not in the house, he met her neighbour Sunita Prajapat W/o M.L. Prajapat (PW-3), and by evening Krishnakant also returned. The next day, the husband of Sunita and Krishnakant took Gopal to a Private Doctor. Later on the advice of the husband of Sunita, Gopal was admitted to District Hospital, Ujjain, where, he was examined by Dr Anil Sinha (the respondent herein) who advised ortho surgery. On behalf of Gopal, Krishnakant (PW-8) entered intoa conversation with the respondent about the expenditure to be incurred in the surgery. The respondent called Krishnakant in his Clinic and gave prescription Ex.P/13 and Ex.P/14 and demanded Rs.3,000/- (rupees three thousand) as Fees for the purpose of surgery; and applied temporary plaster on the fractured hand. At that time, Krishnakant was having only Rs.700/- (rupees seven hundred) and he borrowed Rs.1,300/- (rupees one thousand three hundred) from Sunita by executing a receipt note Ex.P/10. Krishnakant made a written complaint Ex. P/2 to the Lok Ayukta Police alleging that the respondent is demanding illegal gratification for surgerywhich is supposed to be free in the Government Hospital and he wanted to catch him red-handed.
3. Krishnakant was given a Voice Recorder and sent along with Shivkumar Constable to record the conversation with Dr Anil Sinha. He recorded the conversation with the respondent and handed over it to the Office of Lok Ayukta. Thereafter, a trap was organized. Krishnakant was given 20 (twenty) Indian currency notes in the denomination of Rs.100/- on which chemical powder was applied.
4. A Trap Team proceeded to the Hospital and reached there. They waited till 05.00 PM and Dr. Sinha came to his Clinic. Krishnakant entered into his Clinic and handed over the tainted money to Dr. Sinha. Krishnakant came out and gave a signal to Members of the Trap Team. The Investigation Officer with members of the team entered the room and found Rs.2,000/- (rupees two thousand) below the Paper Tray lying on the Table of the respondent. On recovery of the currency notes, the numbers were matched. The hands of Dr. Sinha were washed with the Chemical Water, which turned pink. Thereafter, the glass and tray were cleaned with cotton and dipped in the solution which turned pink. Therefore, prima facie the acceptance of bribe was found established. Thereafter, the remaining procedure was completed. The respondent DoctorAnil Sinha was arrested and released on bail.
5. First Information Report (FIR) was registered and the charge sheet was filed. The charges were framed, which the respondent denied to the extent that he did not accept an amount of Rs.2,000/- (rupees two thousand) as a bribe, but as a Fee for surgery in his private clinic. He has also admitted the conversation recorded in the Voice Recorder. He has also admitted the recovery of an amount of Rs.2,000/- from his table.
6. Learned Special Judge has consid