Reliance solely on historical land ownership entries without supporting evidence from parties can lead to erroneous conclusions, requiring a reevaluation of claims based on tangible evidence.

JUDGMENT

Saurabh Shyam Shamshery, J.

This case is arising out of a proceeding under U.P. Consolidation of Holdings Act, 1953 (for short "Act, 1953") in respect of a dispute regarding plot no. 941, khata no. 110 situated in village Agraha, Tehsil Badlapur, District Jaunpur.

2. It is not in dispute that in basic year, name of Ram Chandra s/o Ajudhia i.e. original respondent no.4 was recorded. The original petitioner before this Court had filed an objection under Section 9 of the Act, 1953 claiming to be co-sharer of land in dispute to extent of 1/3. Another objection was filed by one Ratipal Singh and others, claiming to be owners of trees standing on land in dispute.

3. The Consolidation Officer, after considering the evidence, oral as well as documentary, on 05.07.1973 rejected the objections submitted by petitioners. The claim of Ratipal (respondent no.5) in regard to ownership of trees was rejected since no evidence was found. The Consolidation Officer has framed following four issues and relevant findings thereof are mentioned below -:

^^izLrqr okn xkVk 941@84 [kkrk 110 ls lacaf/kr gSA bl [kkrk esa jke panz vk;ks/;k crkSj Hkwfe/kj ntZ gSA jktnso flag vkSj jsthr flag us vkifRr izLrqr dh gS fd fookfnr Hkwfe esa mudk 1@3 Hkkx gSA jfriky flag vkfn us vkifRr izLrqr dh gS fd xkVk 941 esa fLFkr isMks+a ds og dSnkj gSa vr% isMksa esa mudk uke ntZ fd;k tkosA okn esa fuLrkj.k gsrq fuEu okn fcUnq cuk;s x;s gSa]

1& D;k jktnso flag o jsthr flag xkVk ua0 941@84 ds 1@3 ds Hkwfe/kj ekfyd gSaA

2& D;k jfriky flag vkjksi xkVk ua0 941@84 ds cSnkj ekfyd dkfct gSa vkSj xkVk futkbZ esa muds isM+ fLFkr gSaA

3& D;k fookfnr xkVk [kkrknkjksa dk ckx gSA

4& [kkrs dk foHkktu D;k gS\

i{kksa dks lk{; izLrqr djus dk volj fn;k x;kA muds fo}ku vf/koDrkx.k ds rdkZsa dks lquk x;k RkFkk i=koyh dk voyksdu fd;k x;kA blh vk/kkj ij okn fcanqvksa ij fopkj fd;k tk jgk gSA

okn fcanq&2

jfriky flag us viuh vkifRr dks iqf"V lk{; ugha izLrqr fd;k rFkk eqdnek dh iSjoh NksM+ nh gS vr% mudh vkifRr [kkfjt gksuh pkfg;sA okn fcanq rnuqlkj fu.khZr fd;k tkrk gSA

okn fcanq&1

jktnso flag us xkVk futkbZ ds laca/k esa udy [kljk cankscLr 1287 Q0 izLrqr fd;k gSA ftlesa xkVk 941@&84 esa tehankj crkSj ekfyd ntZ gSA fooj.k ds ikus esa dkQh isM+ksa dh rWQ~lhy ntZ gS rFkk vehj flag iq= ljtw flag o lfyj flag iq= nsoh flag o jfriky flag iq= Hkxokunhu flag o jUuw flag o lothr flag iq= f'kouanu flag dkfct ntZ gSA blh lk{; ds vk/kkj ij mudk dguk gS fd jkuw flag tks muds firk ds 1@3 ds ekfyd o dkfct Fks bl fy;s mudk uke 1@3 Hkkx ij ntZ fd;k tkosA jkepanz flag dk dFku gS fd xkVk futkbZ esa fLFkr iqjkus isM+ fxj x;s blds ckn muds firk us tehankj ls iqu% izca/k djkds u;s isM+ yxk;s x;s gSa mUgksaus bldh iqf"V esa udy [krkSuh 1356 Q0 izLrqr dh gSA bl [krkSuh esa vk;ks/;k flag ¼QVk gS½ fteu 8 esa ntZ gSA rFkk vU; xkVksa ds lkFk fookfnr xkVksa ijs ¼QVk gS½ 1 lky ntZ gS [kljk cankscLr gky ns[kus ls irk pyrk gS fd dkfct ds [kkrs esa v;ks/;k flag dk uds firk dk uke dkfct [kkrs esa ntZ ugha gS vkSj u vU; fyf[kr [kkrsnkjksa dk bl Hkwfe ij dHkh ntZ gqvk v;ks/;k flag dk uke igys igys 1356 Q0 esa 1 o"kZ ds lkFk ntZ gqvk gSA ,slh fLFkfr esa mudk dguk gS fd muds firk us tehankj iqu% izca/k djk;k lR; izrhr gksrk gSA jktnso flag vius dks 1@3 dk ekfyd fl) djus esa vlQy jgs gSaA okn fcanq rnuqlkj fuf.kZr fd;k tkrk gSA

okn fcanq&3

l0p0v0 dh fjiksVZ gS fd xkVk ekSdk ij ckx gS i{kksa dks Hkh Lohdkj gS vr% xkVk futkbZ ckx ntZ gksuk pfkg;s okn fcanq rnuqlkj fuf.kZ